Search results for query: *

Bah, that's not true. You posted plenty of stuff to be suspicious of, we just never followed up on it. Pretty stupid of me, but Keyshe made a nice catch. You were entirely justified in posting this right here. :P

Well, the first hint was that you reluctantly changed your vote from Ark to Hanyou on the day before last, and then he was murdered by the Vigilante that night. That pretty much sealed the deal for me, but to further convince me you kept asking everyone who they else they thought might be scum...

Well don't you two just feel awful now :P Heh, but yeah, I'm glad this game ended in our favor. Keyshe, I knew you were the Vigilante for quite some time now so no surprise there, but I'm glad that Vergo turned out to be innocent. Ever since the last day started I'd been suspicious. A little...

It's become quite a tradition, hasn't it? :lol: ET said that he suspected them due to your post, so I doubt it wasn't anything significant, probably just an attempt to get on your good side and make it seem as if he was contributing to the investigation. As for what I'll do if jetter turns out...

I can't decide whether I'm glad jetter posted or not. On one hand, he won't be modkilled and we'll have to actually use our lynch on him, revealing one less identity, but on the other hand we all seem to have mutual suspicion towards him. Voting would now appear to be an easy choice. The ball is...

Huh, I was right for once. That's a nice feeling, and now that we've only got one piece of scum left I'm next to certain that we'll win. I'll try and make this post as short and to the point as possible. I understand the half-suspicions that Keyshe and Vergo harbor towards me, and I'd be lying...

I was attempting to exonerate you. My point was that since you voted to lynch a Mafia member when you weren't obligated to, you were most likely not scum due to the fact that it's unlikely that you'd throw your own teammate to the wolves. Of course, if it bothers you, I don't have to defend you.

Fair enough. Seven people remain, including myself. I'm a townie, and I'm nearly certain Vergo and Keyshe are townies. So that brings us down to four more people. Vergo mentioned the possibility that jetter may be modkilled for inactivity soon, so there's no use in lynching him, as Axle will...

I wouldn't jump the gun with Meego. Ark posted his suspicions of Keyshe shortly before Meego did, and it appears as if she was just jumping on the bandwagon, so to speak. I don't believe it was a very well though decision. I'll avoid discussing jetter if he's really going to be modkilled soon...

Sure, ganging up on people is fun. In all seriousness though, I may have poked fun at Keyshe for suggesting it before, but I don't think it's a terrible idea to target the inactives. I've listed more than enough reasons to be suspicious of them in the past. Plus, Hanyou's appears to be an...

Relax, that was a (mostly) humorous remark. I'll write more about my thoughts in the next few hours or so, but I just needed to get that across.

Agh, won't this ever leave me alone? I've explained my prior behavior quite thoroughly multiple times, I'll hunt down each post if you'd like. As for your suspicions of zack125, I feel like the Mafia would have sewed his mouth shut after the first two if he was truly part of their ranks...

To be fair, I'm the one who singled out the inactives first. He could have just as easily not voted, however. There's a big difference between casting initial suspicion on a comrade and throwing them to the wolves. It's also not like she was the only one with a plurality of votes behind her...

Slightly. I'm not FOSing you or anything, but I just found it a bit odd that you initially sounded very excited for the game but then neglected to post again over a two-week period. I do get that real life is still there though, and I didn't find it suspicious so much as odd. Nothing personal...

My reason for asking that was to back up a theory I've had. So far, both nights have ended at the latest possible date. I think the first night deadline was actually extended briefly. Unless Axle has been having some technical difficulties (which doesn't seem to be the case), it means that some...

I need to switch up my approach a bit. It seems that they opposite of what I had thought was true. Now that we've finally (and inadvertently) unconvered some mafia members, it'll be easier from here on out. I've wanted the same thing for a while. ---------- Post added at 12:27 PM ----------...

EDBWOP That reminds me Axle, at the end of every day you post something like "You have until (insert date here) to submit your nightkill choices". When you say that, do you mean that the game will start at that date at the latest, or it will start at that date no matter what? For example, had...

This may seem odd, but I think I'm going to abstain from voting this round. I don't feel too sure about anyone and don't want to mistakenly throw someone to the wolves. Plus, it's not as if there is a limited amount of votes being cast.

By popular request, here is my current analysis. It’s been a rather sleepy day, but I’ll do my best. First off, TreeHuggerPanda. She’s been acting dodgy since (literal) Day 1. What particularly arose my suspicions was this post: To me, this screamed an outrageously mocking tone. However...

I don't need to hear anymore from those who have posted recently. My suspicions are only growing stronger towards the three I called out in my first post of day two.

Okay, complicated analysis coming up. Anyone looking above can see that TreeHuggerPanda mistakenly believed that Durion was still alive. I'm convinced that Durion was killed on Mafia orders (although the Vigilante targeted him as well), so it casts doubt on THP alleged Mafia connections if she...

DURION'S DEAD LOL. That's all I have to say.

Anyone else think this comes across as odd? I should probably shut up, actually, since I used this type of reasoning to persecute Xinnamin who was innocent, but the way I read this in my head just sounded very.... mocking, almost. IGMEOY, TreeHuggerPanda

We've got quite the track record, haven't we? I'll have to run over the implications these new deaths bring a little later, but I'd like to request that Hanyou and Kazumi make a post to..... assure me of their existence, I suppose. I know Hanyou posted once or twice in the early days of this...

EBWOP I don't recall Arkvoodle posting either, although that may just be faulty memory on my part.

Not solely on that quote, but on ones like it. If you'd like I can hunt down all of the posts I found overreactive, but you'd have to teach me how to link a post like that. It's not simply the fact that she did defend herself, but rather the fashion in which she did. After all, if I was basing...

That's exactly my point, given that she appears to be "one of the sharper knives in the draw", I wouldn't expect her to get so defensive and cast suspicion on herself. She wouldn't unless the accusations made her nervous due to the fact that they were spot on. And as for her vote for zack125, I...

.....that says Link to the Present was modkilled.

Where was zack124 modkilled? I can't seem to find it. And I stand by what I said before about Charge and Vergo's back-and-forth at the beginning of this thread.

Respectfully, I disagree. It isn't unusual at all for me to try and rally people to my cause, as I truly believe that you're part of the mafia. I'm not really redirecting anyone's attention as no one seems to be focusing right now anyway. It was a simple reminder, nothing more. One day of voting...

EBWODP Also, I find your accusation a tad odd. I haven't seen zack125 post very often, and if he has it obviously hasn't been impressive enough to remain in my memory. I'm not totally invalidating your vote there, but I'd just like to point out the possibility that you're purposely choosing to...

I feel like a bit of a politician in saying this, but with the day ending tomorrow I'd like to remind everyone how I still think Xinnamin is the greatest threat here. Particularly those who have had their votes reversed by the tragic death of a Link to the Present. I invite everyone to read my...

I've explained that the majority of my posts within the first few hours of the game weren't serious. I was trying to "spark" the game to life while entertaining some particularly flippant urges. As I've said before, I don't really have much else to work with, other than inconsistencies in a...

PJ's analysis I’m not going to address whether Charge may or may not be scum now. My reason for this is that I believe that it is much more likely that Xinnamin is a part of the mafia, and therefore our efforts should be focused on eliminating her first. After all, it only makes sense to go...

Brief question to either Viral or Axle; is there a disadvantage to casting your vote early?

No hard feelings :) .....And I'll do the same.

What....what part aren't you getting? I've explained myself quite well and yet, for whatever reason, you're unable to process that information. You don't notice any difference between my early posts and my posts now? Or do you just think I got less stupid overnight?

Keep in mind that we got through ten pages in about three hours. I don't want to argue semantics any further but, that still qualifies as being early in the game.

We've been over this. Any "accusations" I made in the first few pages of this thread were merely me being facetious. I've provided perfectly logical reasons explaining my behavior and while you should believe me. I suggest you try to improve your argument a bit instead of constantly rehashing...

(For real, this time) I can't say anything for sure, obviously, but I'm getting an odd feeling from Xinnamin. Her last few posts have been rather defensive and intimidating, and from what I've seen of her outside of this thread is not the kind of person who'd get irritated so easily. Therefore...

I fail to see how that's suspicious. I didn't read the rules thoroughly enough the first time around, but later I reread them and discovered some things that I had missed. One of them was the fact that observations from outside the thread couldn't be used as evidence (the other was that I...

@Viral Maze, I was trying to start the game up. Honestly, I thought it was pretty obvious from the way my posts were worded that I wasn't being entirely serious. Why would I suspect someone after a single post? That, along with the exaggerated phrasing and overuse of emoticons should be more...

You mean the FoS I used three times? Last time I checked more than three people posted before me.

OMG! Really! Me? OMG this is so unexpected and sudden! NOBODY has excused me yet! I guess my puny intellect is no match for your incredible deductive skills! I can't believe your the first person to point out the fact that accuse people quite a bit! It's definitely not like you're perpetuating a...

For the love of God, I pointed the FoS at three people! Why have I suddenly gained the reputation of accusing everyone above me?

C'mon, be fair. I haven't raised suspicion on EVERYONE who's posted above me. In fact, I only nominated three people for the FoS. Sounds like someone's a bit bitter.

Whatever you say, not-so-innocent bystander. SNAP!

Why wouldn't I want to stay alive? Are you trying to say that I have a deathwish? If so, is that really mafia behavior?

Hmmmmmm? Who says I haven't done any analysis?

Pppphtt. You can deflect all you want, but I know the truth.