Alright, so the other day I was listening to some awesome Zelda music covers, and I really awesome idea popped into my head. It sort of coincides with some things I'm really interested. Namely, I love hearing Zelda music played by skilled violinists. So it's no surprise that my earlier answer was 'violin'. But I've come to realize that I'd like there to be much more than that.
I want the instrument to be very complex. I mean, basically like the 64 era ocarina. For those who don't totally remember, you played the main game songs just with simple buttons. But if you wanted you could really get complicated with it. Holding different buttons or titling the control stick could give you half and quarter notes and vibrato. So, the complexity was there for those who knew how to use it or wanted to play around, but learning it was never required. But, if you provide a tool for fun-having, then people will of course pick up on that.
What I'd like to see implemented is a sort of… composer tool. (ok i have to say i'm gaining new momentum and ideas for this idea even as i type this, so it's gonna change from what i thought up yesterday). Originally I thought it would be cool just to do this with Link's Violin. You could compose your own violin songs, and write them down on parchment. Then, with dozens, perhaps hundreds of small hidden grottos sprinkled throughout the world, you could go to any of those special locations and leave your composition scrolls in treasure chests that you've already opened. Then, in a feature much like the Tingle Bottles (which gave people an enormously entertaining creative outlet) from WWHD, you could have other players discover your compositions and play them back (you could likely have a "Stone of Agony" feature that lets you know when someone's hidden composition is close by). The addition to this idea I just came up with, however, is a form of 'concert mode', where there might be several other NPCs in the game, each with their own instrument. You could not only record Link's violin parts, but parts for the other instruments as well. Then players who discover them could take them back to town and have the scores played, orchestra style, by Link and the accompanying NPCs. Who knows, maybe the appreciative townsfolk might even reward you with rupees or other items! I just really like this idea. It can foster cooperation and appreciation in the fan community, and it can be a way that players are drawn into the game, especially because with all the possible instruments, you can make lots of lively and creative characters to play them, and it's very likely that players will find at least one that they can really relate to and enjoy. What do you guys think?