You could be a Town Joat, maybe Kirino is scum, Idk. Do you think he got luckily with anticipating you targeted Doc, or do you think he is a Mafia Tracker?
Game Thread Raccoon City Mafia (Game Thread)
- Thread starter CynicalSquid
- Start date
- Status
Mellow Ezlo
Spoony Bard
Mafia Tracker is certainly possible. However, I want to hear what he has to say.
Right now, I am actually starting to lean more towards Kirino being a town tracker and you being the GF who simply chose an easy role to fake claim and decided to holster last night for exactly the reason you stated.
Mellow Ezlo
Spoony Bard
Right now, for me, I think this is pretty much banking on what Kirino says when he comes in.
I mean it's fair to have me in the PoE, but keep in mind if I was the Godfather and Kirino is a Town Tracker thsn Soneji wasted a roleblock on a scumbud which would just be terrible play.
In addition to what Rubik said, the flavor claimed that “nothing happened” last night. By contrast, if a kill was launched but was blocked, you’d think it would mention that, the same way that other kills that didn’t go through were mentioned in previous flavor scenes. So the most probable interpretation (and the only one from my perspective) is that mafia chose not to NK tonight.
There’s also no explanation for how I was able to track Tristan’s kill yesterday. The notion that I’m the mafia tracker doesn’t hold up because SMS claimed to investigate me and found that I was green. If he’s telling the truth, then I can’t be a mafia tracker, and if he’s lying, then I still can’t be the mafia tracker, because then SMS would be the last mafia lol. Not to mention that a mafia team without a Godfather seems pretty unlikely.
As for who the Godfather is, it clearly can’t be Rubik, and I don’t see how it could be Tristan either: I confirmed that he targeted and killed Doc the other night, someone else killed Moe, and there was also a third kill that didn’t go through. The only way I can think of that Tristan would be scum is if the mafia had some secret additional kill that they could use alongside their regular kill, which seems ridiculous, even in a game like this. So that would seemingly only leave SMS.
There’s also no explanation for how I was able to track Tristan’s kill yesterday. The notion that I’m the mafia tracker doesn’t hold up because SMS claimed to investigate me and found that I was green. If he’s telling the truth, then I can’t be a mafia tracker, and if he’s lying, then I still can’t be the mafia tracker, because then SMS would be the last mafia lol. Not to mention that a mafia team without a Godfather seems pretty unlikely.
As for who the Godfather is, it clearly can’t be Rubik, and I don’t see how it could be Tristan either: I confirmed that he targeted and killed Doc the other night, someone else killed Moe, and there was also a third kill that didn’t go through. The only way I can think of that Tristan would be scum is if the mafia had some secret additional kill that they could use alongside their regular kill, which seems ridiculous, even in a game like this. So that would seemingly only leave SMS.
This is what I find odd. You’re the one who investigated me, so shouldn’t you know that I can’t be Mafia Tracker?
Mellow Ezlo
Spoony Bard
Unless I'm misremembering, Kirino tracked Soneji that night? My mind is a little fuzzy but I remember something along those lines.
If that's the case, I don't see any reason for Town Kirino to lie about his result, and there was no evidence of a redirector in this game, so that would be a completely valid point.
This is why I hate MYLO, there are reasons for both you and Kirino to be scum and just as many reasons for you to be town and it makes my head explode.
Mellow Ezlo
Spoony Bard
You came up innocent, I'm not a role cop. Since everyone here came up innocent, the remaining scum has an innocent modifer clearly.
Sure, but Mafia Tracker with an innocent modifier seems very rare. It’s generally only GF that has investigation immunity.
It could be that Tristan is like a JoaT Godfather and blocked Poyzin that night when Soneji blocked me.
At this point I'm thinking the Godfather has multiple abilities anyway.
Mellow Ezlo
Spoony Bard
Honestly, at this point SMS is the only remaining player who has in no way been able to prove his role. I do find it strange that Soneji would target him, but it's also possible that he had another hidden ability of some kind?
The godfather is likely Tristan, it's the only scenario that makes sense to me now after the cobfliction of Poy's and Soneji's blocks. Also Teistan clained he did nothing on that night when I was blocked.
- Status