How do you feel about all his reasonings about what might be scum play and might not and his reluctance to actually vote?
I think your post summed it up pretty well, in that he should do more focusing on what is scum play rather than what might be scum play. Seems like he's doing quite a bit of accusing and not putting much action behind it.
Turns out I couldn’t see it on my theme. S’all good now though.
Hmm, weird. Well if anyone wants me to try and fix it and repost for convenience I will!
If there isn't some kind of redirect in place, I feel pretty confident I tampered with his kill. All Might saying I targeted funnier is bizarre, but perhaps it was kokirion who was redirected, and I followed him because I used my action on him originally. I wanted to hold off with saying this, but it's also another reason why I suspect Kirino as he seems pretty cozy with koki right now.
I'm a bit confused why you're still suspicious of Kokirion after it's basically been confirmed there was a lightning rod. I do think he's suspicious, but not for the reason you're implying. With the lightning rod it doesn't matter that you originally targeted Kokirion, because your target wouldn't affect him, it would affect whoever the lightning rod is. Even here you say if there's not a redirect in place you feel confident you tampered with his kill, but we're pretty positive there was and yet you still seem to be following the same path of logic?
I voted for All Might because someone was forcing a sudden tie between the two of them that looked like an attempt to save All Might from getting killed, which is more likely to be scum motivated than town motivated. I switched my vote after the fact.
Actually, thanks for that explanation because it does make sense and makes me a little less wary of you now. Though I'd still like to see a little more reasoning like that behind some of your other posts.
I played a lot of games with her and we clashed a lot. Because of that, I spent a lot of time analysing her playstyle in the past. Normally, if she is town, she kind of plays like this: she is careful, clueless and a bit chaotic at the beginning. She is incredibly good at picking up small details, though, and when she finds something she instantly ties all the red dots together. Her careful balancing between Tristan and All Might, her always-present suspicion of me (by in the end choosing for voting All Might instead of Tristan despite my lobbying) etc. is just really typical for her town play. Her last threat WAS suspicious, but it was just one post whereas the rest of her posts screamed town to me. I consider her the best scumhunter at ZD, and if she IS town I would not want to waste that. Not without allowing her to show a bit more, instead of lynching her before she has said a single word in her defence.
See, I don't think it was her last threat alone that looks scummy. It was basically all of her posts near eod, when all the voting/unvoting was happening. She didn't seem so much like she was connecting dots and balancing between Tristan and All Might, but more like she was trying to play both sides to be safe. It looked wishy-washy which isn't uncommon for scum to do. Her posts before that did look decent, but those were at the very beginning of the day when I feel like she had a much easier time appearing to look good by questioning easy points. She mostly questioned funnier a lot, which basically every 'new' person who plays with him does regardless of their alignment.
