Game Thread Breath of the Wild Mafia

[A Link In Time]

@funnier6 I am not mafia.

 

[A Link In Time]

Also, regarding Sadia, I have not played with her in years, so I hardly remember how she plays. My town read is purely based on her play this game.

 

[Rubik]

Is your vote on alit for something he said yesterday or something he said today?

It was placed earlier today because I perceived a similar play-pattern to the game I played with him when he was scum.

The fact that he's essentially claiming to be a roleblocker doesn't help his case either.

 

[Rubik]

@funnier6 I am not mafia.

Convincing

 

[Kirino]

I'm not sure what you mean. I targeted kokirion last night, yet you said I was on funnier so idk. I used my ability on what I believe to be the mafia night kill.

I believe he was referring to this:

@All Might Are koki and I the only people you saw target funnier last night?

Wait and see.

Alright. But please get back to me on this before the end of Saturday as I may have important information to share depending on your response.

 

[Ronin]

Do you mean that seven people in total targeted Flora (besides you), or that seven others besides the ones you already mentioned did, such that the toal is 9? It seems to me that you meant the former, but funnier thinks you meant the latter, so it'd be nice to clarify before discussing it further.

Yes, I meant the former. Flora's name was not part of the results.

No, although if your watching ability was redirected to Flora anyway, I'm not sure why asking about funnier in particular is relevant.

Because I wanted to make sure of something, that's why. Who did you use your role on?

I'm not sure what you mean. I targeted kokirion last night, yet you said I was on funnier so idk. I used my ability on what I believe to be the mafia night kill.

Last night you told me that you had some vital information to share, but you needed my confirmation first. I might have missed it when I was skimming through this morning.

 

[A Link In Time]

Yes, I meant the former. Flora's name was not part of the results.

Because I wanted to make sure of something, that's why. Who did you use your role on?

Last night you told me that you had some vital information to share, but you needed my confirmation first. I might have missed it when I was skimming through this morning.

Oh, that information was that I had actually targeted kokirion. I wanted to say so earlier but the talk of the lightning rod made me unsure but with your most recent revelation, I feel more confident in kokirion being mafia.

 

[A Link In Time]

It was placed earlier today because I perceived a similar play-pattern to the game I played with him when he was scum.

The fact that he's essentially claiming to be a roleblocker doesn't help his case either.

I'm honestly not sure what to tell you because you seem to tunnel on me every game. My role is one that may be either town or mafia, that is true, but I am a townie. I am tired of you vaguely voting me for something you think is my scum meta when you are totally wrong instead of just reading my content this game.

 

[Kirino]

I’m going to quote more of your post, but I wanted to point out that the total on my list is nine because seven people besides all might targeted flora and all might and she herself are included on the list.

Yes, I meant the former. Flora's name was not part of the results.

Ah, right. I forgot that Flora didn't count. In that case:

1. Flora - Lightning Rod
2. All Might - Watcher
3. SMS - Cop
4. ??? - Protective role
5. ???
6. ???
7. ???
8. ???
9 Mafia night kill

I'm one of the 5-8, and I'm sure that ALIT is one of them too (and for now, I'm assuming he's town). That leaves four remaining roles, with one of them being the Mafia nightkill, one being a protective role, and at least one other (possibly two) likely being another Mafia role; SK is also likely. Since koki is the other known actor, he must be one of these four, which doesn't look particularly good for him at the moment.

We could possibly get more information and narrow things down further if we had the other actors, but it depends on if/when All Might chooses to reveal them.

Because I wanted to make sure of something, that's why. Who did you use your role on?

Rubik.

 

[funnier6]

As for her connection with ALIT, I gave my reasoning previously: she, Flora, and ALIT all defended Tristan Day 1 and then went on to accuse those who suspected him, something I believe is a Mafia move, such that I'm confident that at least one among them is scum. Since Flora is essentially confirmed, it's between Sadia and ALIT, with the town flip of one making the scum flip of the other more likely, in my opinion.

Oh, I see. Personally I’d rather ALIT over Sadia though.

It's possible that ALIT is the Mafia roleblocker, but unless he could rule out the possibility of a town roleblocker, he's liable to be counterclaimed, so I doubt it.

Actually he softed after the daily claim was already used, so it’s more or less impossible for someone to effectively counter. They could want him dead really badly but not really elaborate why, and if the town Role Blocker happens to be pancake or Sadia they may not say anything at all. I don’t thibk he would have any counter to worry about for a full day with that gambit and that could buy him some needed time with the heat he was getting today.

@funnier6 I am not mafia.

Lol okay guess I won’t worry about you anymore. XD

We could possibly get more information and narrow things down further if we had the other actors, but it depends on if/when All Might chooses to reveal them

I agree.

As a little experiment, what does everyone think about ALIT and kokirion being the wagons today? Assuming all might keeps the rest of that list to himself these are two I feel are most likely to be scum so I think it would be interesting if we kept the wagons close for a while.

Vote: ALIT

 

[Kirino]

Actually he softed after the daily claim was already used, so it’s more or less impossible for someone to effectively counter. They could want him dead really badly but not really elaborate why, and if the town Role Blocker happens to be pancake or Sadia they may not say anything at all. I don’t thibk he would have any counter to worry about for a full day with that gambit and that could buy him some needed time with the heat he was getting today.

Actually, unlimited counterclaims are allowed:

I do not count counter claims as role claims, so if one role claim has been made on one day, it is perfectly possible to counter it without the risk of being mod killed.

 

[funnier6]

Actually, unlimited counterclaims are allowed:

Yeah, I know, but the only official claim we have is Cop, so unless you’re counterclaiming Cop it’s a separate role claim and isn’t allowed because only one role claim per day. We could all counter Cop but nothing else.

 

[Rubik]

I'm honestly not sure what to tell you because you seem to tunnel on me every game. My role is one that may be either town or mafia, that is true, but I am a townie. I am tired of you vaguely voting me for something you think is my scum meta when you are totally wrong instead of just reading my content this game.

Can you name an example of me tunneling on you previously?

 

[Rubik]

I'm sure we can soft counterclaim something if need be.

 

[Kirino]

Yeah, I know, but the only official claim we have is Cop, so unless you’re counterclaiming Cop it’s a separate role claim and isn’t allowed because only one role claim per day. We could all counter Cop but nothing else.

Right, my bad. However, anyone can counter-softclaim him by just claiming that he's lying or that he couldn't possibly be the role he claims he is, or just counterclaim him tomorrow, and I still think it's unlikely that ALIT would risk fakeclaiming in light of these very likely possibilities.

I wouldn't necessarily be too strongly opposed to an ALIT lynch, if for no other reason than the information it would provide, but I think Sadia and Kokirion are better targets today.