DekuNut
I play my drum for you
The game days will remain the same length, so long as majority is not reached
Zelda15
You're pretty much inactive since the beginning of the game. I remember that you were mafia in Lucid dream mafia, and back then you were really afraid to post to make mistakes. You have played a few more games since, but your playstyle seems similar. If a few inactives are mafia, you might be one
Oh, lol. Sorry, I mixed you up with someone else there. That removes that from my suspicion. But you still fit in the group of less active peopleOoops, accidentally hit post. I meant to say that this was the PM Kokiron sent me for the Lucid Dream Mafia.
damn how cocky was this post lol i was a bit tipsy when i wrote this, sober for my other ones though and lol@cocky being censored@Soul I play a very aggressive game, which is how I (imo) became one of the top players on the forum. I know I sound ****y, I'm just explaining to you, I'm confident in my game, and that's how I play. I think you're scum, I vote. I'm not a cautious player. Don't take it to heart.
I have 2 theories.
They are both based on the (attempted) kills the mafia carried out so far. The first target was Sadia. Sadia is a special target. She was at that point not a threat, and in my opinion she is a very underrated player. I know that several other more ancient players share my opinion on that, and therefore I think it is unlikely that we have a team with only new players. Sadia's kill was pushed by an "experienced" mafia member.
Kokirion was also a strange target during the second night. It would've made more sense on day 1, because I played a bigger role for the town there. During day 2, I was often attacked and lost a lot of trust. Killing me then would make little sense because I could've been a possible lynch for today. Anyone who would still target me, say for example to frame Pendio, is playing a thought out game. In that sense this is somewhat in line with Sadia's death. The mafia is probably led by a player who knows his/her stuff.
That is also my first theory. There is one mafia member who has orchestrated this. This is someone with a history with Sadia. I suspect that this player is one of the following:
- Ver-Go-a-Go-Go
- Tristan
- ALIT
- Mido
Possibly Viral Maze should also be a part of this list, but I simply do not know if he had a connection with Sadia.
The player out of this list has a relatively dominant personality as to be able to take the lead. Mido is very social, but also quite mediating by nature. That's also why I put him on the bottom, I think he's the least likely of them to fit that description. ALIT is the second least likely, because his connection with Sadia is weaker and he's never ultra engaged from my experienced. Tristan and Vergo fit the description better.
The other 3 members are filled up by (former) inactives. Probably from the list of:
- Zelda15
- Doc
- Night Owl
- Crusader
- Jamie
Ver-Go-a-Go-Go
Vergo... your relation to Sadia, and your capacity to dominate the mafia team if you'd be a member is why you are this position of my list. No matter how much I analyse the list of people, I can't find people that would fit the description more. BUT, I also pointed out earlier that I thought your post against me just before nightfall would be somewhat strange if you were the one planning to kill me. Therefore, I'm a bit less sure about you. At most, you being scum or not is probably flipping a coin.
But, flipping a coin is better than the chances of a random lynch. I would be willing to lynch Vergo or Night Owl today. Night owl is the best example of one of those possibly "inactive" members, and Vergo fits the description best as the mafia player who has been responsible for their strategy so far. Even if they're both town, this already gives us much info, because it highly limits the other possible scum members if they flip town.
Out of these 2, I prefer lynching Night Owl. If Vergo is town, right now he's more valuable. He's the one I suspect the most, but I'm willing to watch him a little longer.
Vote: Night Owl
I agree that there's at least one mafia member that's more familiar with the player base that we have here. I still don't fully believe your soft-claim (as I said in my last post, who could possibly counter-claim when there's no way to know if we were targeted by the mafia during the night? This could be a gamble that there's no real communter in the game and you're seeing if you can pull off the fake-claim, which I've definitely seen you do before), but let's assume for the purposes of this analysis that it's true and you really are town.
I thought the same, but how do you explain the night scene then? I don't think it was a doctor, because the way the scene is written just doesn't work with one, and Deku seems to take great care in writing his scenes properly. If you're entertaining the possibility of there not being a Commuter in the game, how do you explain that night scene? Is there a different role you've got in mind that could result in flavour text like that?
Thinking and trying to put pieces together is about all I can do. Unfortunately my real life tendency to watch and think causes me to fall on the more inactive side of things. I admit that I have a tendency to just agree with other's analysis of people, but that's only because I've never been the best at reading and catching the red flags others do.LOOOOONG POST
Night Owl
The same as for Jamie. In addition, as I pointed out in one of last posts, you behaviour so far really fitted someone who is scum. "Intelligent" remarks about the game set-up etc., avoiding direct confrontations. If some inactives are scum, I think you have the highest chance of being one of them.
Out of these 2, I prefer lynching Night Owl. If Vergo is town, right now he's more valuable. He's the one I suspect the most, but I'm willing to watch him a little longer.
Vote: Night Owl