Very nice thread!
I was born back in 1988, yeah, the 8-bit era... But never played Nintendo games until the Game Boy (and still, not Zelda)! Would you believe it? I was more of a Sega guy, loved Shinobi and all those Laser Gun games like Laser Ghost... But Nintendo... I knew Mario, I was very curious, but never played or maybe just tried it... I also knew Zelda 1, but never played it... Until like 2002!!! I downloaded some NES Roms just to try them out. Zelda was very great, I had some memories of it, but never played it very much, 'cause I hate playing on an emulator. But I started reading Zelda Wiki and other Web sites and found about the Timeline theories. THAT's what really made me curious! I already loved timelines and was already planning on doing an incredible overall timeline that spanned from King of Fighters to Street Fighter, to Marvel Comics, DC Comics, Mortal Kombat and so on, through successive crossovers...
The first Zelda I owned is Zelda 1, when in 2005 a frend sold me his NES with that as the only game. I spent very fun hours playing it, but I still haven't finished it. Then in 2008 another friend sold me her N64 with Mario 64. A great game, but then I bought OoT and Wow! What an awesome game! So I started buying all other ones. I made so pureposelly to investigate about the timeline, but I wouldn't if I didn't love the gameplay.
So I'm quite a young Zelda player, but in these 5 years I bought almost every other Zelda game. I only miss Majora's Mask, Phantom Hourglass and Skyward Sword (apart from minor games such as the CD-i), but I still have to complete some of them.