Beginner's Mafia 2 - Windfall Island

[Celeboy]

Well if he speaks truth, then Celeboy is a townie. However at this point there is no way to be 100% certain, and I don't feel safe enough to trust anyone quite yet. The only person who I am not worried about is zelda_8.

Well, rule No 1 is don't trust anyone, but If you don't trust me, then the townies will loose another person...

Anyway, I have said before (i think) that I don't really have time to read through every post and come up with accusations, but the one I have made was a bit feeble... I~ just need more leads and I want to find something someone hasn't already said! Also, doesn't this show that I haven't a clue who is and isn't Mafia? If I was Mafia, then I would have known.

In my opinion, Pocket Asian is acting odd, I'm not sure if that is how he always plays, but he is kind of refusing to answer MikauIncarnate's Question:

Like I said, he might always do this, but to me it looks like he's hiding something...

I've been playing like this since Mafia Round 4

Well, I have only started on this one, so sorry for a wrong accusation.

 

[Meego]

Hrm. Well seeing Pocky's post I guess I'll lift my vote on zelda_8. And yeah, I bet I look all suspicious now, but you'd be foolish voting for me.

Unvote: zelda_8

 

[Eduarda]

Quick question, how many pairs of 'lovers' are there on Windfall Island?

 

[MikauIncarnate]

There could be 3 (maybe even 4). There are the "best friends" Joanna and Potova, as we've already seen. There could also be another set of masons, called "gossipers" or something that would be Pompie and Vera. The "lovers" would be Anton and Linda, and it's also possible they could be Lenzo and Mineco. Considering the high probability of there being at least more than one set of masons, I'm willing to believe Celeboy for now.

 

[Eduarda]

No, the lovers aren't masons so I doubt there are any masons in this game.

 

[MikauIncarnate]

No, the lovers aren't masons so I doubt there are any masons in this game.

Aren't masons just a group of people who know who each other are? And aren't lovers just a two person group of masons?

 

[Eduarda]

Yes, but lovers aren't masons in this game. If there was supposed to be at least one pair/group of masons in this game, it would be probably be lovers. Since lovers aren't masons, there are high chances that there aren't any masons in this game. That's what I'm saying. That means that most probably nobody other than the Mafia (and cop and doctor) knows any one else's roles.

 

[MikauIncarnate]

Yes, but lovers aren't masons in this game. If there was supposed to be at least one pair/group of masons in this game, it would be probably be lovers. Since lovers aren't masons, there are high chances that there aren't any masons in this game. That's what I'm saying. That means that most probably nobody other than the Mafia (and cop and doctor) knows any one else's roles.

There is "at least one pair/group of masons:"

He was Joanna, a best friend (mason)

And I find it highly likely that there is another.

 

[Eduarda]

Oh, I completely forgot about that, sorry, my fault... So I guess that 3 of the protown roles are figured out then: Cop, and 2 Masons.

Back to the game, I think that we should reach a decision soon about who to vote off. The day ends tomorrow, and the highest voted person is at 2 votes. That's too little to cast/decide a lynch. I find celeboy's defense reasonable, so I'll leave him for now, but for sure IGMEOH. Who do you guys think is the most suspicious and why? I'm still with TheGreen being the most suspicious, but I'll try and see if anyone else comes into my eyes. For the time being,

Vote: TheGreen

 

[Viral Maze]

I'd be down to vote for a lurker/inactive. I'll need to think a bit though.
Also, Celeboy, is lover your role? If so, who's your lover buddy?

 

[Celeboy]

I'd be down to vote for a lurker/inactive. I'll need to think a bit though.
Also, Celeboy, is lover your role? If so, who's your lover buddy?

Well, yeah, I guess so. My lover is... uh... I haven't a clue, to be honest... but my job description says that I want to find my lover... hmm... Oh, well.

 

[Raindrop14]

lolrly? So you're going for Celeboy just to get him to post some more? What about TreeHuggerPanda? zelda_8? The Green? Illmatic? Deku Shroom? What about Gonzo? All of these people listed have less posts than Celeboy, besides Gonzo, who has the same amount of posts.

That's how I use RVSing.
The way I play is I "inspect" one person at a time so I don't get too confused, and seeing how Jedizora fliped cop and he was defending Zelda_8 I see Zelda_8 as innocent.

 

[Elfen]

Well if he


This post was made before he voted in day two. If you claim you are ready to vote in a post, then why not do it then rather than saying you are going to wait until later? Also right after claiming that you are ready to vote, you say you don't know who to vote for.

My gut still tells me that Elfen is scum. I went back and looked at the all the vote tally's. Elfen was one who didn't vote on the first day, then on the second day he was the last one who voted and it seemed like he just bandwagoned on Caeda to get a lynch. Celeboy was second to last who voted and he also just seemed to bandwagon for the lynch.

FOS:Celeboy
Vote:Elfen

Well for your first statement. The reason why I said I don't know who to vote for was because I was having mixed things between Caeda and Celeboy. To me, the both seemed to be suspicious to me, thus giving me confusion on who to vote for. And I was really ready to vote but still unsure.

Second statement: The reason why I didn't vote on day one cause the day ended while I was at my dads, and I like do a lot of things over their and I could barely get on besides my phone. And I refuse to use my phone to post things due to it's bad and all. The reason I voted for Caeda was because of her inactivity. Cause that does strike things to me some what. But she really didn't attempt to defend her self well so yeah :/ a mistake a lot of people made :/.

 

[Viral Maze]

Well, yeah, I guess so. My lover is... uh... I haven't a clue, to be honest... but my job description says that I want to find my lover... hmm... Oh, well.

Sooo, lover is your role? You are a Town Lover, not a Vanilla Townie? And you don't know who your other lover is?

Forget your character description for a second, and just tell us what the 'green text' in your PM says. Not your character's name, but the role you received.

 

[Elfen]

ummm Viral, or whomever. What is this role/name claim thingy??