Oh, of course. By no means did I mean that he's the only one who acts like that. However from my experience, Josh does it the most and further into the game than most people. Like people who troll a little bit on Day 1 and take it more seriously later on. Until Josh starts taking it seriously, he's not much of a help at all. :/
Ya, I suppose that's true. I dunno, I'm not personally ready to vote for him yet, but I am curious to see his response. Especially considering he's yet to post more than once.
My thinking is that if you are good at finding scum (which I'm not claiming to be) then you can probably detect a lot of them based on their first day behaviour. And thinking too much is better than thinking too little, at least you are engaged with the game and are more likely to notice scumtells.
I partially agree. I think that, more than looking at their behavior on Day 1, it's usually Day 1, 2, and 3 that are the most indicative. It's the change in behavior, or lack thereof, that gives the most solid indication of wrongness with a player, IMO. Aside from looking for who's hiding, that is, but that's also best gleaned from looking at them over a period of time.
And ya, fair enough. Just giving my thoughts on individual accusations. That said, I think I'm with you now....
You seem to be targeting quite a few people, getting their minds all our minds on what they'd be. Meanwhile, I see it as directing the attention away from you. That, to me, gives off an air of Mafia deception.
What attention away from him? When did Jimmy have negative attention on him in the first place? He doesn't have any reason to take attention off himself, and he's doing the opposite by leveling accusations. While I disagree with some of his targets, he is playing the game legitimately. I think your reaction is suspicious.