Search results for query: *

Alright, well you wouldn't know this but whenever I do my % tallies I always include myself. And "likely" is a term relating to probability. So 100% likely to be town means 100% probability of being town. I just think including myself in the list helps others keep organized. Also karu, I...

I highly disagree with the Dekunut lynch. If you read my posts at the beginning of the day, and perhaps my mentions of power roles, you might notice some soft claiming in there. I feel like pointing that out might even be too much. So now either A) I'll be the target of the mafia tonight...

Awesome! I need to go to work soon and I'm pretty satisfied that I got my ideas out with my last post. Sometime over the weekend I'll pull up the posts from the players mentioned and analyze them. For now - Unvote Vote : karu As I said before, I'm teetering on both Toxic and Johnny...

Sorry for keeping this one brief but I'm having a hard time getting back to sleep without getting this one in just because Pendio hasn't confirmed an extension. I'll have a more comprehensive post when I actually wake up tomorrow. I find it very interesting that karu has stopped playing the...

Vote : Extension. With everyone wrapping up finals I think it would be nice to get some time to talk when they aren't stressing over school.

EBWODP : For anyone who didn't get the armor reference, Tyrion Lannister. I know it's the wrong show but I haven't seen Sherlock so it's the best I can do. Anyway, I want to see what people think about this. There is no question that I'm the most active player this game and that most people...

@Tristan to be honest I keep brining it up because I want to point out my own flaws before Johnny, who I think is scum, can. I'd rather turn what I perceive to be blunders into armor that will be harder to use against me.

Thanks @DekuNut so it might just be hoe he plays. Still seems scummy to me. Hopefully we can get more people talking because I feel likes it's pretty much just the two of us today with some sprinkles from others.

EBWODP I just went though again and noticed these little nuggets of hypocrisy that I thought were interesting. Tristan made a joke vote against Pendio, but he's hugely against No Lynches Day 1! As long as he's not the one who actually makes the vote and gets the scrutiny. Anyone play any...

Well considering your little back and forth yesterday I did feel the need to defend myself. In fact if I hadn't, I think you would've tried to spin it the other way that I pushed for the lynch on an "easy" what we now know is townie. So it's nice to hear from others who I'm leaning town for...

EBWOTP I forgot to put EBWODP above but it looks like we don't have the merging problem anymore thank goodness.

I've re-read some of Libk's posts, he's still pretty close to middle for me. He has been asking questions and pointing fingers at people who are pretty low on my likely to be town list (Toxic Snowman) and the pointed fingers haven't been to redirect attention away from himself. However, I...

@DekuNut, that is a good point. I haven't really re-read again recently and when I did I was focusing on others than Libk, and my focus on Tristan was because of the discussion that was already happening around him today and him and Storm being on the vote early together and Storm's flip of 3rd...

EBWOTP @Tristan don't mind me I'm just an idiot. In your final vote count I was colored in green for town. http://zeldadungeon.net/forum/threads/pok%C3%A9scum-mafia-the-first-generation.49879/page-53 Again, I don't necessarily think that this game would have a town aligned poisoner, but I do...

EBWODP @Tristan please see above

Alrighty, I'm home and can give a little more meat to my post this time. I'm going to go over the list and give my thoughts on everybody. Moonstone - Me, town 100% likely, but of course I would say this. Mido - leaning town. Someone pointed out it would be a weird move for scum to lynch the...

Hey all, at work so I can't get a detailed word in right now. I'm pretty disappointed in Doc's flip since it makes me look scummy. That's what I get for trying I guess. I am town and I'm not sure what other than my scum hunting attempts will make you all think otherwise. I think I've been very...

Fair enough. I have to keep in mind that you won't necessarily play like me. I was over enthusiastic as a newbie and made myself appear scummy many times when I was actually town. I hope that I can see what your other suspicions are before this day is over.

EBWODP : I have to add that my suspicions on both karu and Johnny haven't waned, but I do think that Doc is connected to them, too. He hasn't posted and as soon as Vergo and I bring him up, karu and Johnny swoop in to try to stir the air. I kinda feel like we've found our mafia. But perhaps...

Here is my thought process: I'm already leaning that karu is newbie mafia. The way she played in the beginning had me leaning that way and her sudden jump in really hasn't changed my opinion. I'm heavily leaning that Mido is town at this point. She has been going after him relentlessly when...

You seem to be rather defensive of her.

Freudian slip perhaps? I'm interested to see where she takes this.

Vote Extension Hopefully Doc can get a word in

I appreciate your thoughts but when you get a chance to go through everything you'll see I've been leaning that Doc is scum since day 1 and was tossing up between voting him, karu, and vergo. Vergo's comment on Doc's inactive playstyle as mafia and my experience with Doc as an active town was...

I have work so I probably won't get another word in for this day. I was already happy to lynch Doc. As I said before I've played with him once while he was town and he was much more active than he is this game, and Vergo saying he's played games where Doc was scum and inactive only gives me...

Well as much as I hate to go back on my word I'm going to have to leave my vote on karu. Really for me Storm or Tristan being a part of the mafia hinges on karu's flip and as much as I would like her to get to keep playing it doesn't make sense to vote for someone based on what I'm assuming...

Only reason I'm on Tristan instead of Storm right now is due to the defense of karu who I'm leaning a bit scum but giving her a chance since she did meet my request in addition to his odd comment about not telling her to jump on the vote which I went over last post. That said Storm has thrown...

Sorry it's hard to quote on phone and have it format properly. Obviously you or Storm haven't asked karu in game to jump on with you but you could've in mafia chat. I appreciate that karu got back to us. I'll leave her alone for now. But Tristan I was already a little suspicious of you and...

Alright, I've gone through again and nothing on anyone else really stood out to me other than Storm's little spat at the beginning of this day. Since nothing else really stood out I'm just going to go ahead and analyze Karu's posts in full since she is still currently my top lynch option. I...

Interesting. I think you've made a great find here. If they are connected it would also explain why Johnny was trying to divert attention to me. However, unless karu decides to play and give me her list at least for today, I'm definitely leaving toward her lynch. As much as I want her to get...

When you get a chance can you post a list of the players in order of who you feel is most suspicious? Even if you're wrong there are no hard feelings in mafia. or shouldn't be. ill beat up anyone who gives you a tough time for it.

Interesting. Probably 3 mafia like last game right? And 3 who haven't even posted once today. Definitely think at least one if not two of those are mafia. @Ver-go-a-go-go @karu @Doc Penny for your thoughts?

No prob. Thanks for letting us know. Before you get too busy I hope there is more action for you to comment on. I'll do what I can to stir things up.

I guess I would say that currently my top three lynch candidates are 1. karu - just because she's new doesn't mean she isn't mafia aligned. Her defensive attitude could be seen as newbish however, when I was new, I was still very excited to talk even if it painted me in a bad light. She was a...

If Mido is actually innocent do you plan to hold it against me no matter what or are you still open minded? I think I've been very fair in my assessment of him. To be fair, his activity is a little suspicious.

Everyone at this point is a viable option to me. Other than maybe Dekunut because he's been very active so far and pushing for conversation, I feel about the same about everyone. My top suspicion on Mido is simply due to his weird comment on the first day that I already pointed out and for...

Ok I was right. Minish was the first to bring up the roles. I imagine that and her careful yet still analytical posts made her a prime target for the mafia. They probably killed her due to thinking her role would be very useful against them. I'm not really sure what a watcher is but I...

I think it's possible one member of the mafia was able to tip the vote and the rest of the team didn't feel the need to pile on afterward. But it could also be that the mafia didn't want to look suspicious on day 2 and kept their head down. I'm not sure which I think is more likely yet...

I agree with Deku. I'll dig more into the posts but it's pretty tough to do on mobile alone but my only guess right now is that mafia wanted to go after one of the more active players this time around and perhaps they targeted her since IIRC she was the first to bring up "good roles". Perhaps...

Storm instead of bringing it to public do you mind just venting to me instead? I hope you know I won't judge. I just don't see what is causing this and want to help everyone have fun playing together.

Interesting. I'm going to be with family for the next 18 or so hours but I'll make a fleshed out post as soon as I can.

I'm a little suspicious of it too but she is new and I know I've done that when I was new too. I'm not sure how I feel about it yet but I would like to give her a chance at least for now.

As I just said last post I don't think we'll get any new answers voting to lynch someone who hasn't posted even once. So kinda random not-so-random Unvote Vote : Doc He posted twice at the beginning of the day, a revenge vote and then a joke. And as I was also saying, my family is coming...

The only problem I have with the Din lynch at this point is that it doesn't really say anything about anyone's alliance. I'll decide a new vote tomorrow morning.

Ebwodp : also I know I'm going to get jumped on but when I said I wouldn't hold it against Karu it didn't mean I didn't still think it was suspicious and that she gets a pass for being new. I just know I've done the same in a town position when I first started. Pro tip : don't play at work...

Ebwodp : gah this is why I hate playing on my phone.

Not necessarily but voting without a reason usually is kind of suspicious. I know you're new so I'm not holding it against you but I did want to point it out and ask.

EBWODP? I'm off to work folks. I think this was a very productive morning. Please keep it up in my absence!

Wonderful! Thank you. This kind of discussion is exactly what I'm going for. I was thinking similarly myself and was tossing up between voting for either your or Din.Farore.Nayru tomorrow after giving people some time to react to what I said and adjusting accordingly. Oh jeez remind me not...

True, but how do we get info without talking? And, while we do have some good roles this time around, a lynch will still produce more answers than just the night kill. At least with the lynch we can look more closely into the people who voted or chose not to vote depending on the flip.