Hey all, at work so I can't get a detailed word in right now. I'm pretty disappointed in Doc's flip since it makes me look scummy. That's what I get for trying I guess. I am town and I'm not sure what other than my scum hunting attempts will make you all think otherwise. I think I've been very fair in all my attempts too.
Johnny quoted this post too, but honestly, I disliked this post the first time I saw it. You've been pretty high on my town list pretty much all game, but this post really stands out to me. You had no real reason to say this, since nobody had even brought up the fact that you got Doc lynched. Considering the vote was tied all around anyway, I don't think anybody would have really brought it up, or if they did it wouldn't have meant much. This reminds of me someone, I think it was Alit, in TF2 mafia saying they were fine with being investigated, completely out of the blue, because he knew that the cop couldn't investigate that night and wouldn't survive to the night when he could be investigated. I know the circumstance is different, but I can't help but be reminded of that post. Just seems out of the blue to me. You're talking as if people are already accusing you. No real reason for a townie to talk this way. You're still leaning town to me for the most part, but I'm gonna keep an eye on you.
I've re-read some of Libk's posts, he's still pretty close to middle for me. He has been asking questions and pointing fingers at people who are pretty low on my likely to be town list (Toxic Snowman) and the pointed fingers haven't been to redirect attention away from himself.
However, I think pointing out karu for saying mafia in one of her posts on page 13, which was the only way I noticed her slip, has me wondering if he is mafia and trying to turn things on townie karu subtly.
Alternately he could be town pointing out a Freudian slip and using every small detail to his advantage to find scum.
To me, the two are interchangeable between 50-55%. I hope today is active and with more votes because, honestly, the lack of votes really makes it hard to find solid evidence, at least in my opinion. Which is why I'd rather vote and be wrong than not vote at all, because at least this way people can scrutinize the way I'm voting and come up with an opinion of me.
This is an interesting find for sure. Not too sure what to make of it for now. Libk is neutral in my books, but perhaps there really is more than meets the eye. I'll take another look at his posts and see if anything else stands out.
Tristan made a joke vote against Pendio, but he's hugely against No Lynches Day 1! As long as he's not the one who actually makes the vote and gets the scrutiny. Anyone play any other games with Tristan in both mafia and town role to give some further insight?
I am against no lynches. However, I also don't like participating in Day 1 lynches for the most part unless I see some real good reason to vote for that person (with some exceptions, like in some games where I've been pro-RVS, it's somewhat situation-dependent). I like to let Day 1 play out, and if there's a lynch going on then great, if not then I'll probably cast a vote just to ensure one will happen, but that's not always necessary.
I mean, he was town in Smash Mafia 2 and had no Day 1 votes. He also had both normal votes and joke votes on Day 1 in Ouran High School Host Club during Day One. As Town in Smallest ZD Mafia he actually suggested ending the day with an RVS. So he's been all over the board. And I don't remember the last time he was scum actually...
I personally don't see that as scummy, but you do have some logic there, so I'll provide the insight you asked for so you can do whatever.
If you want an example of my scum game, check out Wizard 101 Mafia. That's the most recent one that I can think of. Keep in mind, though, that I was a replacement, so you'll have to jump ahead to like Day 2 or 3 (can't remember exactly).
I agree with you guys on Toxic btw. I'd be inclined to vote for him, but I'd like to give him a chance to get a word in first. I might iso him later if I have time, along with Libk and maybe Johnny. Don't expect many (if any) posts from me though between now and tomorrow afternoon because I have a lot of stuff to do tonight and a final first thing in the morning. Just thought I should pop in and say some stuff.
