Game Thread My Hero Academia Mafia

[Libk]

If you really are a town roleblocker, then this isn't lylo. We lynch me or Krow, block kill, win by lynching other next day.

 

[Libk]

Again I don't doubt you took Music's role, but I think you're All for One and took it through your quirk.

 

[Krow]

And SMS, if you aren't lying and I die you block the hell out of Krow. Only chance to win as town.

Actually thats a point I want to bring up. If a towny is lynched today and SMS is telling the truth, as long as the towny isn't Axle he can guarantee blocking the gf. Day post states this is the final battle. If we're really in lylo, then I think it's even clearer that SMS is scum

It's down to the final 4. If town dies, scum kills another town. Scum wins, 1v1 isn't a thing.

If you really are a town roleblocker, then this isn't lylo. We lynch me or Krow, block kill, win by lynching other next day.

Now that's just desperate. Lynch me or you and then block the kill? You already said Axle is innocent. If we kill me, why would you ask him to block you? Panic induced scum play.

 

[Libk]

You're not reading the whole post. If SMS is telling the truth we aren't in lylo.

Axle is cleared

Assuming SMS is telling the truth we lynch me or lynch you. If the lynch flips town, SMS can assuredly block the mafia NK the next night and then lynch that person.

The mod post for day 5 makes it apparent we are in lylo so SMS can't be telling the truth.

 

[DeletedUser9]

Going to say this now just in case. Deku is a nickname and the real name of that character is Izuku Midoriya. Just a random tidbit of knowledge.

Axle, my point on asking you to role claim was so I could judge between the three of you and see who is lying. There is a chance that it's Libk or SMS who are faking their claim. I will outright say this now, I am terrible at judging people based on Meta and get confused easily by it. Such is why I told Minish long ago in the game that I hated it and found it useless.

However, I am pretty good with flavor depending on the game and I'm one person in the game that has watched every episode of MHA so far. What I'm getting at, is that based on your role claim (do not soft your character, just the role) I should be able to see who is who without hearing the actual names.

I know it sounds farfetched, but I took down All Might (forum member) due to my knowledge of the show and flavor, whereas he tried to fool everyone thinking no one knew the show enough to move against him. I know who SMS "says" he is, and in terms of Libk I can only think of one character that would have an ability called Night Stalker and still be a hero. Not knowing anything about yours just puts an enormous "?" on you and throws me off. Hiding your role has no positive effect anymore, you cannot die overnight for revealing it, as this is the final vote anyway. It's best to have all the cards on the table.

I understand, and that makes sense. Just to explain myself in the same way you did, and to put it as you did: I know it sounds far-fetched, but the way I usually find scum is simply reading their behavior. It's how I first played Mafia and to this day is the funnest way for me to play Mafia.

I'm not trying to stroke an ego when I say this, I'm trying to tell you a fact to clarify my actions: Before I disappeared off the site for 4 years I was one of the best players on the site, and back then I ignored claims pretty much entirely. I know I keep referring to it, but that Serial Killer game I won was not just a game where I laid low or hunted whoever was a threat; I was the only player in that entire game who found a single Mafia during the vast majority of it. So, just as you're assuring me that your method is how you can most effectively play the game, I'm assuring you that I have my own method.

With that in mind it's because of the circumstances of your claim that you're the only player I trust right now. I'll give a claim if it's truly needed, although it seems like we're gravitating in another direction now so I'm not sure it is.

What more can I say? If I was the last Mafioso I wouldn't be going after Libk, that's for sure. I would have tried framing you. And I think the only reason Libk is trying to frame me now is because I told the results of my Roleblock early. I roleblocked you and it didn't stop the Nightkill, therefore you aren't a Mafioso. If I was a Mafioso there would be no benefit in me clearing you. That's really all I can say, if you still want to lynch me, I can't stop you.

It's just as much of a scum thing to do things that don't make sense for scum. Even if you believe that if you were Mafia you wouldn't be going after Libk, the reality is that if you were you SHOULD go after Libk.

That's the exact reason people aren't trusting me -- and shouldn't -- just because I defended, say, Storma before he was lynched. I would have done that as Town or Mafia. It doesn't mean anything on its own.



@Libk I'm still a bit torn between you and SMS. The reality is I'd probably be voting you if not for your argument against SMS and I guess I want to see him reply to you as well.

 

[Libk]

I'm not askimg to be blocked, I'm saying we still win if sms is telling the truth and we lynch me. Or if we lynch you and you flip town. Do you see why that doesn't make sense considering this?

The end was at last upon them. Rubik gave one last thumbs up to the hero cause before he fell. This final battle would determine whether the hero society would continue to thrive or if it had seen its final days.

Rubik was Ochaco Uraraka, a Vanilla Townie.

The Living (4):

@Axle the Beast
@Krow
@Libk
@Spiritual Mask Salesman

The Dead (11):

Musicfan - Shoto Todoroki, the Town Roleblocker/Vote Manipulator (Lynched Day 1)
funnier6 - Eijiro Kirishima, the Bulletproof Townie (Killed Night 1)
LittleGumball - Shota Aizawa, the Tree Stump Maker (Killed Night 1)
Stormageden747 - All Might, the Town Jack-of-all-Trades (Lynched Day 2)
Pendio - Tsuyu Asui, a Vanilla Townie (Killed Night 2)
Kirino - Gran Torino, the Town Cop (Killed Night 2)
All Might - Muscular, the Mafia Strongman (Lynched Day 3)
Bok Chan Sama - Tomura Shigaraki, the Mafia Roleblocker (Killed Night 3)
Minish_Link - Katsugi Bakugo, the Town Vigilante (Killed Night 3)
HeroOfTime - Stain, the Serial Killer (Lynched Day 4)
Rubik - Ochaco Uraraka, a Vanilla Townie (Killed Night 4)

Day 5 Begins!

With 4 alive, it takes 3 for a majority lynch. Day 5 ends on Friday, July 20th at 6:30 PM EST.

 

[DeletedUser9]

After re-reading Libk's post a few times, Krow, I believe he's talking about getting lynched and SMS roleblocking the last Mafia so we have a final 3-man Day.

However that kills us if SMS is scum so I don't understand the logic fully?

 

[Krow]

You're not reading the whole post. If SMS is telling the truth we aren't in lylo.

Axle is cleared

Assuming SMS is telling the truth we lynch me or lynch you. If the lynch flips town, SMS can assuredly block the mafia NK the next night and then lynch that person.

The mod post for day 5 makes it apparent we are in lylo so SMS can't be telling the truth.

That being said, I feel like theres more to your role than just seeing who roleblocked back then. If All Might was a JOAT, why can't All for One be?

I'm not askimg to be blocked, I'm saying we still win if sms is telling the truth and we lynch me

If I get lynched, I will flip town. Assumign the day magically continues, and Axle is for sure town, you will be blocked and will for sure be scum.

As for LYLO, I'm betting ALiT forgot to post it. I believe even Axle mentioned we were in LYLO. I could be thinking of someone else though.

 

[Libk]

After re-reading Libk's post a few times, Krow, I believe he's talking about getting lynched and SMS roleblocking the last Mafia so we have a final 3-man Day.

However that kills us if SMS is scum so I don't understand the logic fully?

That's the point I'm trying to make. It all depends on if we really trust SMS. I'm not saying "hey lets Lynch me" I'm saying we can't possibly be in lylo is SMS is telling the truth. Leading me to believe he's lying

 

[Libk]

That being said, I feel like theres more to your role than just seeing who roleblocked back then. If All Might was a JOAT, why can't All for One be?



If I get lynched, I will flip town. Assumign the day magically continues, and Axle is for sure town, you will be blocked and will for sure be scum.

As for LYLO, I'm betting ALiT forgot to post it. I believe even Axle mentioned we were in LYLO. I could be thinking of someone else though.

The beginning of ALITS post indicates LyLo

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Hi, All for One.

Vote: Spiritual Mask Salesman



This quote was in direct response to me saying this




He seemed quite sure there was no scum roleblocker, and even tried to use the mod roleblock to hide the fact. While the thought was something I brought up, I later stated that the mod confirmed to me that his roleblock was not part of my result. I think this was an attempt to keep Bok's role secret and try to move on as the "Town Backup", however something had been bothering me about that claim. Now what I'm saying might seem crazy, but I think it's the only explanation, I think SMS is all might and was able to steal Music's quirk. That's what All for one does. He steals quirks. The only other character that it could possibly be that I could think of is from a different class than the main cast of heroes in the show. And he's only able to copy the quirks of those he touches for 5 minutes. I believe SMS when he says he's now a role blocker but I don't believe town.

Unlike you, I didn't have the benefit of being completely aware of what roles the Mafia had. I thought that maybe one RB that showed up was the Mod RB, until you clarified.

@Krow , Thematically it doesn't make sense, to me at least, that Deku would be a backup. That's not Deku's power. If he could backup anyone it would only be All Might's backup, not Todoroki or the other heroes.

Well I'm no expert on My Hero Academia Mafia, so I'm not sure if all the other roles have exactly fit the mafia game power roles they have been associated with.

Lastly I offer this.




This post came after it was common knowledge that Minish didn't kill on night one. Additionally SMS should know that blocking the godfather wouldn't stop the strongman. You'd have to stop the strongman so It's not likely that you blocking Axle did anything night one.

I've played in games where blocking the Godfather screws up other Mafioso roles, either makes some not work, or causes them to hit targets they weren't intended to hit. Games over on the ZU Forums, and perhaps they were very unique, but I played the majority of Mafia games I got experience from on ZU back in 2015 and 2016 while this Mafia section was inactive.



Really it's just odd to me that SMS speculated against an SK when 1. We knew Storma investigated Pendio night one so no chance of the JOAT doing an NK, and 2 We know minish didn't shoot on night one. I guess basically I'm wondering what your thought process was here because there's no way blocking the possible Godfather would have resulted in blocking the strongman kill and you should know that. And now that we're at a point where we can be sure we've had no doctors, it would make sense that a roleblock could stop a NK.

It was a legitimate mystery to me why All Might, the forum member, wouldn't use his strongman ability. I tried weighing the posdibility that there wasn't an SK because I like to look at scenarios from all angles. But in the end I did agree we must have a SK in the game and I agreed it was likely HeroOfTime. And if you're going to call me out on that you should call out Axle too, he completely disregarded the possibility of an SK being in the game, but it's clear that was just an error on his part.

TBH I think you're trying to use "I role blocked Axle but there was still a kill" as an easy way to try and put sus on me and get me lynched.

It wpuld have been much easier for me to not say I RB Axle at all, and try to frame him, if I was a Mafioso. I heavily attacked Axle yesterday, there would be no reason for me to back off on him unless I was telling the truth, and that truth clears him.




AND I just caught you in a bit of a contradiction. You know I outright claimed. I'M the reason you even claimed yourself. Look above for proof. You claimed a bit after I pointed out the second RB.

Already addressed this point.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

I screwed that up.

 

[Krow]

I agree with you that since the game is still going it's 3v1, but there isn't going to be another day; 4 players left, one is mafia. If we lynch a townie tonight, then a townie is nightkilled in the night and there's one mafia and one town and that's an auto Mafia win. This is LyLo. And I can only confirm, as you said yourself, that lynching me is a Mafia victory.

Yup there it is.

Honestly trying to turn the lynch on me doesn't help your case. Yes, I'm aware SMS could be scum. But panicking and saying "if I die block the hell out of Krow" means you believe him doesn't it?

The beginning of ALITS post indicates LyLo

Which indicates, this vote ends it. There is no tomorrow, only tonight if we are wrong.

 

[Libk]

In response to it being easier to try andynch axle, how? With Krow and I being basically VT, you had to "Block" Axle.

@Krow THAT'S MY WHOLE POINT. I'm not trying to lynch you.

Which indicates, this vote ends it. There is no tomorrow, only tonight if we are wrong.

If there is no tomorrow, then SMS MUST be scum. Otherwise he could block the mafia NK tonight if we mislynch today.

 

[DeletedUser9]

I just realized something: Libk has two votes so the fact that he's not getting hammered (with every active player online) must mean he's Mafia.

Oops no it just means I forgot to count.

Vote: Libk