Super Smash Mafia 2: Originals vs Clones - Game Thread

[Jirohnagi]

Who do you think attacked Eduarda? I'm pretty sure it's obvious that Mafia attacked but the question is who did they send.

I honestly am not sure, i didn't even know the mafia could attack people by sending someone else.

 

[Johnny Sooshi]

I honestly am not sure, i didn't even know the mafia could attack people by sending someone else.

So did you target Eduarda? If not you had to have been attacked.

 

[Eduarda]

Also, in regards to "how Johnny got more damage than Eduarda's parameters indicate", Johnny's a blocker, right? So therefore, Johnny cancels out Eduarda's counter-y ability. Then someone else attacks him.

During Night 1, Jamie PMed me and told me that I can't be roleblocked because of the same reason Johnny stated (I can't say the actual wording).

Johnny, it seems like you know a lot about my role

 

[Doc]

And like I said before, there's still no justification. You both jumped on and hammered away. I'm forced to accept Eduarda's claim because Jamie basically confirmed it. On the flip side you haven't done much to address why you'd trust her or establish reasoning on your own for why i was a good choice. Yeah, I get it, it sucks what happened cause it out you in a bad spot, but you gotta justify it.

I was solely basing my attack on what Eduarda had said. After yesterday, I think it is quite clear that she is not scum and find her trustworthy. Her third party claim made me believe her even more, because I see no reason for a third party to reveal unless it is to remove scum and, as result, gain the town's trust. There is no doubt in my mind that Eduarda is still looking for a way to win. But to reveal when she did would be stupid unless she thought she found scum. So I trusted what she was saying and believed that you were definitely scum who attacked her.

 

[Jirohnagi]

So did you target Eduarda? If not you had to have been attacked.

Learn to go back over posts Johnny, stated several posts ago i didn't attack Eduarda. Check page 19/20.

 

[Frozen Chosen]

The way she described her power was as reflexive. A reflexive ability wouldn't get blocked because it doesn't target anyone. It passively reacts to people who target it. A paranoid gun owner would still kill a Role Blocker because it was targeted. That's the way I saw the role. If it worked where it was actively blocked, then nobody who targeted her would have received damage. Now obviously it's possible nobody received damage from Eduarda, but as many people as there are who roommate yesterday, it seems improbable that so many roles have attacks at night. Jamie has confirmed this isn't role madness. So imo, I don't think I could have stopped a reflexive role/passive role, only an active role.

During Night 1, Jamie PMed me and told me that I can't be roleblocked because of the same reason Johnny stated (I can't say the actual wording).

Gotcha. I don't think I've ever played with that kind of role before. So Johnny used his ability, the action failed, and then took damage that may have been modified by something. Eduarda was attacked by either Sadia or Cthulhu.

 

[Frozen Chosen]

Learn to go back over posts Johnny, stated several posts ago i didn't attack Eduarda. Check page 19/20.

I guess what he is asking is if you targeted Eduarda, not attacked. But if you understood that, then fair enough.

 

[RegalBryant]

OK. I am the vigilante. My night attack parameters are 70%-90%. I targeted Johnny yesterday. Either someone blocked me, or Johnny(or perhaps Eduarda??) is lying about something

your thoughts?

 

[Eduarda]

Haha great!

Mafia blocker probably won't target you. @Jamie did you mess up?

 

[Eduarda]

@Doc but do you have anything else to say on what's been going on so far?

 

[Eduarda]

Oh no, Gummy's reading the thread

 

[Mellow Ezlo]

@Eduarda does your role have a percent chance of failure?

 

[Mellow Ezlo]

*50% damn phone

 

[Jirohnagi]

I've no interest in targeting Eduarda seeing as i'm town i can't do jack to her.

 

[Eduarda]

@Eduarda does your role have a percent chance of failure?

Good thought, but nope. I wasn't given any chance of failure