Pirates Mafia: Curse of the Black Pearl

[Keyshe]

Eh.. the only vote past page 3 was in Mafia D : The Sith Lords (http://zeldadungeon.net/forum/f111/pirates-mafia-curse-black-pearl-42600-8.html#post715056) 6 out of 7 where on page 2 or earlier. So that part of her story has been consistent.

 

[Eduarda]

I don't really know what you guys are pointing at. I looked over her posts. The content seems ok, I guess. Her activity seems scummy. I need more posts from her to really decide. I think she put the whole "Let's find scum" just like that, for no real reason. But her lack of defense seems scummy. I want to see her on day 2. That's when I'll really be looking very closely at her (assuming I'm still alive). I expect her to get a move on by day 2, as none of her "day 1, nothing scummy" would be effective at day 2 in my opinion.

As for the lying:



I don't believe that. Especially, if you look closer at the games Annie posted. Half of Rainy's random-votes (or votes thrown out on a whim) were like 80-90 posts in. Way past page 3.

I just looked back. Most of them were between 20-30 Here's the link to my post.

Am I missing something?

 

[A Link In Time]

EBWODP

That's an interesting snippet from Rainy's post, Viral.

I'd like to focus on this part:

I actually think it's better to lynch someone then no one, because lynches get you somewhere (although I'd like to make them logically orriented, as in don't willy nilly it).

When has day one random voting actually helped the town? A townie usually perishes in the process and the mafia gain a second kill through their night action. I find it more sensible to not kill someone during RvS since the mafia will decapitate a townie. The information from that player's death provides us with direction on how to progress. It's best to minimize senseless kills because they're rarely to the benefit of the town.

EBWODP

ninja'd

 

[Viral Maze]

Post 165, and 173 in Werewolves is what's getting at me.
Overall, I just think Rainy is lying. Why I'm voting for Rainy is cuz I think musicfan is innocent and as for the Marshal, he's new, so thus him defending himself a lot (which I didn't think was too suspicious, yet) seemed... logical, in a sense.

Also, how many post/page do you guys have it set to?

 

[Keyshe]

I agree ALIT a lynch only based on RVSing would be bad. It'd more or less would be a random lynch with like 75% killing a townie. I don't mind RVs for conversation starters but vote/lynchs more on fact's/evidence will create more evidence.

So the only thing I can really land on as off with Rain is her lack of interest to dig up evidence/reactions to find a good vote/lynch.

 

[A Link In Time]

Also, how many post/page do you guys have it set to?

I stick with the default 15 posts per page.

And now I suppose we sit back and wait.

There are a lot of people who still need to chime in.

 

[Kirino]

In Werewolves (I think), Rain was random voting all the time halfway through the game, an she's been random voting in previous games often too, and now she's contradicting herself. That's why Viral's voting her.

 

[Viral Maze]

I got 25 going (so we're on page 10, for me, lol).

 

[Eduarda]

Post 165, and 173 in Werewolves is what's getting at me.

This and this?

Oh my goodness. My suspicion on her jumped.

Overall, I just think Rainy is lying. Why I'm voting for Rainy is cuz I think musicfan is innocent and as for the Marshal, he's new, so thus him defending himself a lot (which I didn't think was too suspicious, yet) seemed... logical, in a sense.

I dunno. He seems too pressured. I think people are mostly pressured when they want to (or have to) live. Like when someone's dependent on them. So that means that:

1) He's a scared newbie
2) He's mafia

And a 3rd option.

Also, how many post/page do you guys have it set to?

Default.

I agree ALIT a lynch only based on RVSing would be bad. It'd more or less would be a random lynch with like 75% killing a townie. I don't mind RVs for conversation starters but vote/lynchs more on fact's/evidence will create more evidence.

This.

 

[Keyshe]

EBWODP:

Ah... yeah I see

Well since there's not much to go on...

Vote: Xinnamin

RVS yo

http://zeldadungeon.net/forum/f111/mafia-e-gahh-werewolves-39645-12.html#post644998

I have a tendancy to want to vote every day, because in one mafia game we would be mod-killed if we didn't make a vote that day. Force of habbit...

http://zeldadungeon.net/forum/f111/mafia-e-gahh-werewolves-39645-12.html#post644998

I'd like to hear her comment on this :/

 

[Eduarda]

EBWODP

In Werewolves (I think), Rain was random voting all the time halfway through the game, an she's been random voting in previous games often too, and now she's contradicting herself. That's why Viral's voting her.

Really?

I'm really thinking to vote her now. But I want to hear her defense first.

Or I can always change my vote.

Unvote: musicfan

Vote: Raindrop

 

[Viral Maze]

I dunno. He seems too pressured. I think people are mostly pressured when they want to (or have to) live. Like when someone's dependent on them. So that means that:

1) He's a scared newbie
2) He's mafia

I'm on the fence with The Marshal, but I feel like that horse has already been beat, thus why I'm focusing on another horse :p

Speaking of this, I'd like Dan's opinion on whats going on. No specific question, just what do you think, Dan.

 

[Eduarda]

Viral, you jumped from 5 to 12 posts today

Here are all the people who posted 4 or less time. And Pendio posted 5 times.

Dan
4 Posts

Heroine of Time
4 Posts

Keeseman
4 Posts

Sirmat
4 Posts

Darknut_Hunter
2 Posts

Thareous
2 Posts

Josh
2 Posts

 

[Viral Maze]

I hate telling our power roles what to do (and hate it more when other people say it), but those are all great vig options. Especially Josh (<3), and Dan.

 

[Keyshe]

Pendio tots scum vig him!

Yes I agree Marshal has been done to death-- there is no way to progress with it other then jump to a lynch. Better to read off how he vote and acts from now to day two first. I think, as it's not like we can freak him out more lol.