Justac00lguy
BooBoo
Yeah my votes staying on Thar.
Thar said:Well, strictly speaking, I was the Town Healer last time, but their abilities are the same, sooo... Yeah.
Besides, I already softclaimed, albeit it was Twilight and I didn't use "Doctor" to describe myself. Cross-compare my claim with the official roles in the sign-up thread if you have to.
Wait, that was a legit softclaim? I thought you were joking...
Thareous, I explicitly said to NOT post ANYTHING related to the game at Night. The others were pushing it, but they never posted any legit information. However, YOU'VE explicitly admitted to breaking the rules. We're gonna need to have a chat to determine whether I should modkill you or not.
NOTE: This does not confirm that Thareous is the Doctor. The previous sentence, in tandem, does not confirm that he isn't. That is all.
Wait, that was a legit softclaim? I thought you were joking...
Thareous, I explicitly said to NOT post ANYTHING related to the game at Night. The others were pushing it, but they never posted any legit information. However, YOU'VE explicitly admitted to breaking the rules. We're gonna need to have a chat to determine whether I should modkill you or not.
Um... guys? Stop talking about game-related stuff, lol.
JuicieJ made me Mother Brain, the Town Virgin.
Hm, so this is what I can summarize on this game so far:
The Living
Mellow Ezlo - totes suspicious af
A Link in Time - fairly active, but nothing's caught my attention
Big Octo - can't say
justac00lguy - counterclaimed(?) Doctor
Keeseman - fairly inactive
Erebea - inactive
pkfroce - Vig (Ridley)
Thareous - Doctor (Mother Brain
Rachel - edikah
AvatarFlygon - lol
Heroine of Time - who knows?
Yeah, I really don't know anything. But judging from what we've been told about the roles, this is where we stand:
4 Zebesians left
1 Doctor (Thareous?)
1 Vigilante (I believe pk's claim at the moment, and Rachel made a pretty good point about that on the last page)
1 Bulletproof (possibly someone who is acting more dangerously - to attract attention and let the mafia possibly waste a kill, if the strongman isn't used - but who knows)
1 Watcher (who I'm guessing either doesn't have leads yet or hasn't stated them yet)
3 Mafia (I'd say the role cop is the most dangerous, but that's just me)
This post is mostly for my own reference. If I'm missing something crucial, please let me know.
Umm... Thar? You say you protected Big Octo on Day One and ALiT and Day Two. Well... okay, for starters, Bocto... didn't even do anything of importance on Day One, so you really wouldn't have any reason to protect him. Second... You protected ALiT on Day Two, but wouldn't you have protected pkfroce after he roleclaimed? I mean... you're saying you're doctor, but you didn't protect the one that we all kind of agreed to protect? (forgive me if I'm mistaken about what happened, btw). I can only conclude that you are lying about being Doctor.
Uh, anyways, yeah. Thar is simply too suspicious to leave out in the open. I say the safest route for now is to lynch him. Alternatively, we could just wait for the Mafia to get him, like he said, and if he stays alive, we'll know he's Mafia. BUT maybe he ISN'T Mafia and the Mafia don't kill him, thus making our suspicions rise and we end up lynching a townie.
Hm... Avagon makes a good point. Why didn't you protect me? However, why am I still alive? Unless someone else is Doctor? And JC has kind of caught my eye now too. Because if Thar is the Doctor after all, then that would make JC look suspicious for wanting to lynch the Doctor. However, I think it's more probable that Thar is scum because I should be dead if he didn't protect me.
Now either Thar is going to argue that he's still the Doctor or he's going to say that it was tactic...
am i dead yet