I've read through D3, and intially, I was a bit confused as to why everyone was thinking they were still in DS1, but
as funnier6 pointed out, the setting fluff hadn't changed from D2, which also took place in a desert. If this is true, that must mean someone used an ability that prevented Town from reaching DS2 (or a modifier- either way, something that would benefit Mafia way more than Town), which makes me even more confused about why you guys think I'm a scum-aligned role.
Wouldn't the Mafia have taken advantage of this and let one more Day go by instead of night-killing the Dreamer the following night? I'm more inclined to believe the Mafia got lucky with their nightkill (or did it because Bok was replacing Domozilla, but that's purely speculation).
Also, I really don't like the sheer amount of inactivity that happened D3. On top of that, I don't like that you guys- ESPECIALLY because you thought you were still in DS1- decided to lynch an inactive player in a Dreamscape instead of discussing a plan of action to either do
one of the 3 options I suggested or a different plan entirely. Where did your brains go, Town?
Anyway, here are my reads. Whoop dee doo...
@karu and
@Ragnarokio -
Neutral.
Post something, PLEASE. karu, you haven't posted since D1, and Rag, you haven't posted since D2. What's up with that?
Minish_Link -
Town.
They have been very active and helpful this game, and I haven't seen them drop any flags that would normally hint at a scum role.
I don't know what kind of role Minish is softing here (guessing it has something to do with funnier6 talking like a baby), but it doesn't matter atm since it's the frequency and content of their posts that convince me they're Town.
funnier6 -
Neutral.
I'm still skeptical of them because of their playstyle.
I am not positive, but there is a pretty good chance Rubik is scum. Really annoying I’m not sure but in case that clicks with anyone.
I don't understand. Are you softing? Or are you just speaking from your gut again? I really don't like this kind of playstyle, anyhow...
Ayano/Bok -
Neutral.
Don't know what to think of them yet because they've replaced players twice already. They still seem pretty deadset on getting me killed, which they've been from D2, but what's interesting this time is that they share the same sentiments I do about D3, which differs from what they previously thought D2.
You guys really should have had two people commit suicide and kill Ryuken yesterday. Uncle Bok won't always be here to tell you guys what to do.
Except that doesn't really seem viable. If we're sending people back then it will take extra days for everyone to reach ds3 and if mafia has the option between knocking people back a level and killing them then all they have to do is keep bumping one person back at a time to stop us from reaching ds3. Your plan seems like it would take too long and would just give the mafia more time to pick us off.
Tunneling, much?
Doc -
Town.
They've posted their reasons for being inactive, and their vote on Storma D1 is the one thing on my mind that still puts them as Town.
Rubik -
Town.
Still getting very strong Town vibes from them. It's clear that they have a lot of experience in Mafia, but more importantly, what puts them out of the radar is how their playstyle this game contrasts their playstyle in Shrek Mafia.
Agh, I really don't like how my reads came out. I don't feel very confident placing this vote, but considering what's happened, our best bet now is to try to get the Mafia in the real world.
Vote: Bok Chan Sama
Yes, they've been replacing inactive players and were Town when they died, but because of their differing thoughts about a plan of action and how they've consistently targeted me, this is what makes me vote for them.
- - - - -
I'm just gonna address both of these posts together. I agree with funnier here. Dreamer Cop is pretty useless to town, considering that Dreamer is a modifier and can be claimed at any time. So why would we need someone to Cop that just to tell us they're town if they can do it themselves. It would make much more sense for it to be a mafia role. I feel like Dreamer Cop could be like a variation of role cop which is usually mafia aligned. Since mafia having a role cop wouldn't be as beneficial this game due to some of the roles being unusual, it would make sense to have a cop to detect dreamers instead.
In my opinion, my role can be useful if for some reason the Dreamer refuses to suicide or speak up either due to being inactive or
due to actually being scum, and I can just call them out.
Inception Rule #4 said:
Dreamers will be members of the town, unless the Dreaming mechanism is affected by outside forces.
I'm actually starting to get a scum vibe from him from everything he's said today. And I'm guessing you have a reason you're saying this. I think there might be a good chance we're looking at a Ryu/Rubik team here. Rubik's suggestions seem like they're trying to buy mafia time and subtly protect Ryu. And he's the only one that thinks Dreamer Cop seems more like a town role than mafia.
Not to mention, both Ryu and Rubik came into this day seemingly more 'organized' than other days. It seems like they may have discussed their plan going into today in the scum chat the previous night, knowing that they were killing the dreamer and we would all be back on the same level.
I can kind of guess based on funnier6's playstyle why they would suggest Rubik as scum, but I don't like your reasons for agreeing with funnier6. Just because Rubik voiced his own thoughts and doesn't agree with everyone else about my role being Mafia-aligned makes him scum? That sounds silly to me. Your assumptions about what Rubik and I are doing sound a bit far-fetched, especially the part about us planning in the scum chat. Can you elaborate on why you think our posts seem more "organized" than other days?
You also seem to be convinced funnier6 is softing something, which I personally don't think is the case. Then again, I can never tell what goes through their head.