Kay back from my
traumatic wonderful day at work and ready to reply to posts!!
Send help!!!
@funnier6 There isn't much to quote, considering he has barely any posts. I said what I needed to - his posts are very few and he doesn't have much going for him other than casing Tristan, which turned out to be a mislynch, so I want to focus there on the wagon for now.
Well what you didn’t say was what actually makes that suspicious. I don’t him well enough to get a read in him easily but I feel like there are some points you could elaborate on cause it mostly feels like you’re scum reading him because he included you in a scum team theory.
Also just because you lynch town doesn’t make you scum. And just because you lynch scum doesn’t make you town. So I wanna see something deeper.
I agree with funnier, a subtle mention of storms in your post would be enough for me to believe in a lightning rod. The first person to post today claims it.
As for
@A Link In Time …
My initial thoughts were based off intuition, but Tristan's death pushed him forward for me. I did notice something else slightly suspicious Day 1. I'm not so skilled at quoting this particular event, but maybe someone else can find it? While the All Might and Tristan wagons filled, it was slightly ahead in All Might's favor. But kokirion put in his vote of Tristan to tie it up, afterwards he said something about Tristan and two others went crazy swapping their votes. I guess I also chose All Might due to the fact kokirion might have been trying to tie it up to force a No Lynch and save All Might, then the town finished Tristan?
I totally forgot why I quoted this but I did want to ask you. Was it you or was it me? If you know what I mean.
That said, kokirion reading me, Tristan, and funnier as a scum team bothers me more today now that Tristan has flipped town.
If you’re town why shouldn’t it have bothered you if Mez was scum?
Seems less likely than the doc hitting correctly. I doubt we have doc + bodyguard + lightning rod in a single setup (and if we did, scum would probably have a strongman to get through it or something), otherwise that's too much protection.
It IS possible that scum has a delayed kill or something, though. That seems a lot more likely to me. Less likely than the simple doc scenario unless we see 2+ kills tomorrow, though.
I find the first scenario much more likely than the second. That’s a bit out there for a Pendio game.
I still kind of want to either pressure or kill ALiT, though.
Vote: A Link in Time
I remember I asked you for thoughts and I feel like you gave them but I went back and didn’t see any so if you did feel free to quote but, I’d this vote for what alit has said before your last vote or after?
I know how you’re not big on claims (or maybe my memory has failed me again) but rn I believe her and don’t see why anyone else shouldn’t.
Many PRs have nothing to do with night actions, and it's more likely that a minor PR would answer the question, which would still give the Mafia information and help them narrow things down.
Well looks like that’s no longer needed anyway.
This seems like a lot of weird speculation to me. I get trying to figure out what happened at night, but this many flip-flopping posts on what happened doesn't do town any good and just causes confusion. The first post about a doctor was decent speculation, but then the rest is just pretty unlikely.
I think funnier already pointed it out, but yeah roleblocks typically always block a faction kill (unless it's interfered with some other way).
I think this is a solid theory on what happened last night. I feel like Pendio does usually tend to sneak a few hints into his flavor posts, and the storm feels like one of those.
I agree, that just doesn't seem like scum All Might. It's unusual at all for him to be that active and voting day 1, so I don't think he would do it as scum. I'll admit that I was a bit iffy on him day 1 because I didn't agree with his reasoning at all on the rvs votes, but it just seems pretty risky for scum to push the lynch that strongly.
This quote also screams All Might to me. This is what was missing from the previous game when he was scum. It also makes a lot of sense and backs up the lightning rod theory.
It actually seems to be fairly common in Pendio's games. I know I was a lightning rod in Anime mafia and I think there was another lightning rod type role in X-Men mafia. Those are just the ones I can think of off the top of my head, but it's not exactly far-fetched. Especially since the theme is BotW and I feel like it would be sorta fitting with all the lightning storms in the game.
I highly doubt it would be a delayed kill, since that's very rarely seen. I think the only type of delayed kill I've seen mafia have is Poisoner, and in that case they still had their night kill as well.
My activity kinda depends on if I'm around when there's a lot of discussion going on. A lot of times when I post it's when not very many others are on so I don't get into that set of back and forths and instead have to reply in wall-posts.
I'm curious as to why you have a town lean on Kokirion. I understand the other two, but tbh I have a hard time reading Kokirion in the first place and aren't sure why you're leaning town for him.
I'm going to have to re-read day 1 to get a better sense of my reads. A lot of craziness with votes happened near eod when I wasn't around so I'm gonna have to try and sort all of that out. I think it's a little weird how many people were trying to name possible scum teams on day 1 with nothing to go off of, so I feel like that might be a good place to start looking. I dunno, but to me that usually seems like a scum tactic to leave some breadcrumbs to push later on.
How do you feel about SMS right now?
I'll admit that today I'm not so much focused on All Might, and I won't vote him again unless he gives me reason to today, like if he tries steering us toward another mislynch.
Lol for one thing that’s a very town thing for him to do and for another thing that’s a useless way to read someone. “Oh hey you, mafia member, I’m town reading you right now, but if you vote town I’m so going after you!” It just doesn’t make sense.
And you're looking too hard into it, I told everyone in the last game, and in games prior that I always wait until last minute to cast my votes on Day 1 whichever allignment I'm with. I could go find the quote for you but I'm not threatened by your pressure vote to get me talking.
Actually it isn’t pressure. I legitimately feel like you’re a good lynch today. I do appreciate the talking though.
Then tell me what your hidden deeper reasoning in that post is, then. As you said, I'm oblivious and pitiful, so my inferior brain is incapable of picking it up. Please deign to explain it to me.
I didn’t get it either at first but if you look closely at her post I quoted I think you’ll see it.
If ALIT would be scum, he would've known from the beginning that Tristan was town. Maybe him defending Tristan was not an attempt to save a scumbud, but rather an attempt to gain town credit after day 1
You’re like, taking the evidence to fit your theory. “If ALIT is scum, maybe this is why he did it.” Well either he or he isn’t and unless you happen to feel that he was attempting gain town cred,
thus he’s scum, I see no point here. ALIT is scum,
thus he was trying to gain town cred, isn’t an argument.
Now, I'm not saying ALIT is scum
Then who are you saying is scum? Who are you going to vote? Have you any town reads?
This post was quite scummy. It is indeed easy to sit back, to not support the leading lynch and to only weakly support the alternative while threatening the people that dare to take a more proactive stance that they will be suspicious if they later turn out to be wrong.
Yeah okay, “the post is scummy” the question is, is Sadia scummy? I feel like most of what you’ve been saying is just pointing out “scummy” things and waiting for someone else to vote them for it so you can say you saw it the whole time and join in.
Have you nothing to actually contribute? Who are you going to vote? Me again?
