No. It seems I should have been more clear, but I was specifically talking about the idea of reading into the kills in that post as well.
And yes, we don't know anything about how many kills to expect, so suggesting vig(s) should holster in order to read into the results was meaningless? The context was very specifically about that.
Could you clarify what you're saying here? I don't know why, but I'm just having a hard time understanding it.
You were the one to bring up reading into the kills. Which seemed to be a counter point to Mezlo saying that the vig should holster. Are you saying that was misinterpreted now?
Ya, I can understand how you see that. Though, in regards to Bok, I said it looked like he was really fishing with his suspicion on Pendio, and I still think that. That's why I said it was too early to assume he was planting seeds, because Pendio hadn't really done anything obvious that would've given me that impression. It really did look like Bok was trying to plant seeds for Kuro though, considering he voted for someone completely different whilst saying Kuro looks suspicious, which, if Kuro is scum, is exactly what I'd do if I was also scum (I mean, just look at Anime Boys).
Bok's reasoning for thinking Pendio is planting seeds about funnier looks to be the same as your reasoning for thinking Bok is planting seeds about Kuro. Pendio said he was suspicious of funnier and would vote him later if he needed to, but placed a vote somewhere else. Bok said he was suspicious of Kuro and would vote him if needed, but placed a vote somewhere else. It's seeming like the same scenario here.
It's usually a pretty safe bet to assume that when someone is the same as when they're town that they must be town, not fool proof naturally but I guess I don't see what the deal is about the holstering since that's not really something I worry about and something that's pretty normal for him to talk about.
Not exactly. Some people play the same either way. I think Mezlo is a good example of that and that's why it's so hard to get a read on him. But I don't think there's enough to go on from either game to say what Kuro's normal townie self is and if it's different than his scum play. The holstering thing isn't the main concern about him right now, though it did look like backtracking a bit.
Everyone seems to assume it had to be on someone inactive but it really didn't matter, I wanted to pick someone who was generally inactive because usually if you want to have a random wagon it's a better idea to pick someone inactive so as to pressure at the same time. I understand he isn't inactive this game but so far his actions don't seem towny at all.
I asked that question, because in the post I quoted you said "Because I was thinking I'd start a wagon on someone who isn't normally very active and you were the only one who fit." That seems to suggest that you specifically wanted to choose an inactive person.
It's different because I have no idea if he still wants the answer or not. I see he quoted the answer but I can't be sure he read and accepted it or whether he has a problem, thus it's a lot more helpful if he acknowledges the answer or deletes the question as he writes the post because otherwise it's confusing.
Fair enough, but I think you're going to run into that quite a lot. Like I said, people quote as they read through, and it's hard to go back and change all the quotes around and delete what's unnecessary and whatnot. I spent a bit of time doing that myself earlier, so it's usually just easier to post as is, and you can re-answer the question to refresh people's memory.
I sorta care because now I have a scum lean on Pendio so I'm okay staying on him and not switching.
Oh okay. Wasn't exactly sure what you meant by that, and your explanation didn't seem like what you were implying at the time.
It's rather a dumb reason but when me and music start agreeing it usually means he's town, I understand nobody else would think so. So far he hasn't done anything he wouldn't normally do, so as expected.
Music hasn't been scum yet (in recent games with us, I know he played some in the past) so I think it would be hard to say either way.
Btw Minish, have you thought about who you're going to vote?
I think we have a pretty interesting situation going on here, where different people have brought up three different pairs where there could be connections. So, it might be best to focus on those three pairs for today, as any of them could give us information due to the points brought up against them. I'd say out of those six people (you, Pendio, Bok, Kuro, Mezlo, and music) the ones that stand out to me the most out of each pair are Kuro, Mezlo, and then I can't really choose between you and Pendio.
I'm not quite sure what my read on Mez is. He's giving me some weird vibes this game, but I do agree with a lot that he has said.
Kuro would be a good option, since he/Bok have been brought up by multiple people so he could really give us some information. Plus I find that he's been a bit wishy-washy, and I don't really like voting just for the sake of bandwagoning.
You're not screaming town to me like you usually do when you're town, but I also don't get super scummy vibes either.
So I guess what I'm saying is, right now I'm leaning towards Kuro, but I'm just having a hard time trying to discern how I'm actually reading people.
And Pendio has been a little odd, but isn't looking too extremely different from his town play.