Yeah I recognise some people from this thread as well. :P
To answer more seriously about the ZU thing, there's not going to be any merge there. Jason isn't willing to sell and it also isn't something that makes sense for Mases business-wise. Unlike ZI which gets a lot of "clicks" from getting...
I'd be interested in doing another game some time definitely, and you're all welcome to visit ZU's mafia boards. Here's Discworld Mafia, a game I GMed (with another member) if you want to have a look at what it's like there...
That's alright, I think you played well, it was a good job getting to the end at all. Serial killer is definitely a tough one to win with - in some versions of Mafia the SK and Godfather are given bulletproof abilities to give them a chance. If Mafia and SK don't win very often here it's worth...
Actually, I might as well post now while I'm here.
The main issue I had with the game is that at least 3-4 times the GM leaked fatally compromising information about the Mafia in one form or another. All three of us Mafia hid pretty well in my opinion but then for example Eoghan died because a...
Good game. I liked a lot of it but had a few frustrations where I felt like the barrier for Mafia to win was nearly impossible. I'll post more thoughts tomorrow.
However, there's the chance the killer could vote at the end of the day to stop the no lynch, so let's make us accountable.
Here's how we could do it assuming blackkirby doesn't appear again by end of day. Let's take the risk and trust SMS. Then we'll split the vote amongst the other three...
Ok I think I have an idea. I've been thinking about how many killers are left but I realized it doesn't matter. Whether there's one killer or two a no lynch would be the worst situation for them and best for town (if there's one killer they'd kill and then it would be 1v2 the next day and they'd...
Read my post again, I said he was guilty, not the SK. Knowing exactly his role is something for the specific Role Cop role, others get different variations on results. Wish I could be less vague but I'm trying really hard to dance around the no more claims today rule by providing information...
We don't actually have anyone confirmed as safe from being the Godfather. Let's go through everyone:
I'm probably the safest claim out of anyone here, because it's backed up by several things - proof in the form of a Mafia Framer being in the game but nobody for him to use the framing on, as...
The past day is basically all that's relevant right now anyway, we've been recapping the previous days throughout this day.
Just leave a vote today and we can decide where to go from there.
My view: right now the only player we have a solid lead on is Linkdude74. We've been suspecting two...
Unvote
Vote: Linkdude74
Honestly I think he's still the best lynch option (if we're overthinking it and there's only one killer left like the GM suggests then we've caught him) but can't do anything with the last player afk.
@Blackkirby Have you had the chance to read through? It's been a few...
Actually thinking about it in the absence of a fourth player to make majority lynches happen I'd be happy for a no lynch. It means the killers would take each other out and if there's one town and one cultist remaining it would be a win for both.
My main concern with sacrificing myself is that we've seen the cult leader die but haven't seen his follower mentioned in the night 1 death post yet (night 1 mentions the cult leader abducting a blonde girl, probably fiora), so the town might lose if I die and then the killers kill each other...
There are two players guaranteed to lose if this plan goes through. The serial Killer and the last mafia. If Linkdude74 and Blackkirby don't come in to vote for it I think we've caught our last two.
One more reiterating of where we're at:
Cody:
-Claims an investigative role, backs it up with...
@Blackkirby We don't have the numbers to lynch today without you, have you had the chance to look through the thread? We can give you a summary otherwise.
I'm heading away from my computer again now so will not be able to make big posts like this again until tomorrow probably, but can answer smaller questions. I really suggest everyone read the lore/death post stuff I brought up - I think a lot of our ideas on how the game works have been based on...
I wanted to clear this up for @Spiritual Mask Salesman also regarding the thing about three mechon from the first death post that he mentioned, I finally realized what he meant. Let me help clear this up.
Metal Face/the serial killer is the one with claws.
This guy isn't a Mechon, you can...
Thirdly is my post on the night death posts and determining who is who. We actually know who each of the mafia characters involved are thanks to it being flat out said. I know everything can sound interchangeable when it's a big series with lots of characters, so I'm going to use images to show...
Secondly @Spiritual Mask Salesman, on the topic of my defending the doctor on Day 1, I wanted to clear up what I meant. I was going to do this earlier but couldn't find the search, so I had to check manually.
This is what happened: Right near the end of the day the vote was just about tied...
Okay I'm going to cover one thing at a time: the first is whether there are inconsistencies about my role.
This is your first game, right? A decent-sized role-madness game like this often has a few roles of each type. If we look at the roles considered normal on Mafiascum (a big Mafia site with...
All I want to do is talk out potentially the last day in the game so the town doesn't mislynch, I don't think that's unreasonable. As a show of being willing to listen I'll even unvote Linkdude74.
Unvote: Linkdude74
@Linkdude74 This is also relevant to you. Whether you're town, Mafia or SK if...
"Gut instincts" aside, your logic is provably wrong. Voting wrong would be deadly for the town, it would lose us the game today. Please reconsider.
I can give an in-depth run through of the death scenes, I didn't previously as I just pointed at them for others to read, but now I realise for...
I'll respond fully when I'm at my computer, but please unvote for now as I can prove you have the facts muddled up. I can prove that JC-Hurin and Eoghan weren't Mechon just by linking to their character pages.
http://xenoblade.wikia.com/wiki/Dickson
http://xenoblade.wikia.com/wiki/Lorithia
Well...
Not sure what to make of this. This is such a late time to make a switch. Let's give Blackkirby time to catch up. Luckily we have another three days or so to decide.
@Blackkirby Have you been following along with the thread?
Same reason he threw Eoghan under the bus probably. If you read Eoghan's final posts where he got upset he mentioned being upset at being bussed, and with JC-Hurin shown as mafia now that explains why. Some people have a very "I'll survive at all costs" attitude to the game.
Assuming the game...
I want to reiterate that the death posts show that there isn't a vig. You're very likely overthinking this. We caught a killer who got role blocked and caught. He's claimed to be a vig and yet read these death posts ...
Yeah I would agree, the prominent point of the night was the fact that the Cult leader got killed, which considering he'd probably been recruiting for a few days was reaching dangerous levels. Here's something else to note: On the night that Linkdude74's kill got role blocked, the "community...
I definitely recall fighting Diego over it. Right now I'm having trouble finding a thread search button for this thread though. Am I missing it or does Xenforo not have it?
@Spiritual Mask Salesman @Mellow Ezlo
Here are the facts. Linkdude74 is a killer. This isn't in question. Not only was it proven by ALIT yesterday who role blocked him and stopped a kill, but Linkdude74 himself just admitted it in this thread. He's now claiming to be a vigilante but the death...
I put out the idea of a vigilante in that post just for you, a extended branch for you to cling to. If only you were a vigilante you could have been killing on the side of good, right? So you could escape being caught out yesterday.
There's only one problem. The GM has made it clear repeatedly...