(adult timeline)--/-
LttP-LA LoZ-AoL WW-PH
MC FS OoT----<
(Child timeline)--\-MM TP OoX
your absolutely right, but why didn't anyone(including me) notice this earlier?
----------------
now all thats left is FSA, we put in FS we have to add its partner. any suggestions?
If I were you, I'd say it goes as
............./-TWW/PH-
FS/FSA-LttP/LA-LoZ/AoL
TMC-OoT
.............\MM-TP-OoX
Zemen has succesfully shown points to how TMC could come first, even though I still don't agree, but nobody has
ever stated why they think FS comes before OoT as well.
I believe that the manual hints (hints, doesn't imply) that FS and FSA have the same hero, so that could be enough....
The Seal War can't be in the adult time,because Ganon is sealed,and only escapes to be stoped by the great flood.
If ALTTP took place on the Adult Timeline it would have to be before WW.
FSA shows that Ganondorf has been reborn in the Gerudo tribe.
And Miyamoto disagrees with you. He specifically said that OoT
is the SW, meaning LttP comes in the AT.
Later, they released FSA, which was clearly a prequel to LttP. But Hyrule was in an island in that game. That just strenghtened the intent for LttP to follow TWW. You can't ignore that...
ALTTP would still have to take place in the child timeline.
After Wind Waker Hyrule is lose.
We generally work with two possibilities:
1. Link and Tetra found a new land, as suggested by Daphnes, and founded a new kingdom there.
2. The GDT plan worked and the islands got bigger forming large landmasses.
Either way, it is pretty plausible that a
new Hyrule existed after TWW...
There are all sorts of problems if ALTTP takes place on the adult timeline.
1.Hyrule is gone.
2.The tale of the Seal War is gone(If Link and Tetra did start a new Hyrule they would not know any of the legends of the old Hyrule.
3.The Master Sword is stuck in Ganondorf's head,so how does it get to the Lost Woods?
This is why I don't think ALTTP can fit on the adult timeline.
1. look up this post for this...
2. The Book of Mudora was said to have the legends of Hyrule written in it. That's from LttP, meaning the legends of old Hyrule survived.
3. This is a good argument. I have to say that, if the water level dropped, and the landmasses got bigger, as proposed by the GDT, the MS would simply come back to surfice. Placing it in the pedestal from there would be simple...
The Seal War might have been retcon by Nintendo,and FSA can be explained away by saying it was for gameplay purposes.
If there was a retcon, don't you think Aonuma would have told us so in
this interview?
Also, the fact that Hyrule is in an island doesn't add much to gameplay, so there are only gameplay reasons...
1.Please explain if you can,I'm all ears
.
2. The people of old Hyrule knew the story of the Hero of Time.In WW only the people on Outset Island knew anything about the legend about the Hero,but they did not know about Hyrule itself or about the Sages who played a big part in the legend of the Seal War.
3.I agree with you about point#3.
1. The GDT plan...
2. It was written in the Book of Mudora. People didn't have to know it
3. The GDT plan could explain that too...
