Vergo I would like to thank you for starting off the discussions. ...I'm a little lethargic today; third day in a row with very hot weather... So if I say something that doesn't make any sense... make me clarify please! I've been reading a lot and I need to get some of my observations and theories off before I lose them. (Sorry, this is going to be long...)
I myself have been leaving PJ, Zack, Meego and Vergo alone for the most part because of the possibility and fear of bringing suspicion on our special townies. But now I am worried about us missing the scum and killing our last remaining townies and Vigilante, so now we really can't jump to conclusions and paranoia...
I am a little reluctant to feel completely sure that Vergo, PJ and Zack are all definitely townie. From the beginning my gut told me to trust Charge and PJ, and distrust you Vergo, as well as Hanyou, and Viral (for how dangerous you three could be). I really can't stop thinking that if you were mafia no one would suspect you now that you got the Godfather lynched. I know it would be beyond foolish to act on that this day, but if we aren't finding the last scum, that is something someone should look at as a last resort.
For PJ my gut said one thing, while reason said another, especially as the days went on. While for the most part you have been very intelligent and logical about your analysis and suspicions, you've never been seen to lead the charge against any (confirmed) mafia. And on the last day you seemed to me a bit reluctant to go after the in-actives, even though you put the idea first. And you have also caused a bit of confusion too, like on the first day. But also you said yourself that you were joking around with me about the in-actives... that leaves me a little nervous...
I have no intention of voting for you or Vergo on this day, but if things look hairy after this fourth night, I feel I need to put this out there and leave no stone unturned. I recommend all of you do the same. Even though some of you have shown confidence in my townie-ship, don't neglect on asking questions on anyone,
even me.
As for Meego... I am still waiting to talk to her. I don't want to jump to conclusions and vote for her solely based on that she voted for me. Until last voting she was mostly suspicion-free from me. Since Ark also suspected me and looking back I can't say I've done a whole lot to be free of suspicion. I challenged his FOS on Kokiri, which was a big mistake on my part. Looking back, it was obvious that he was the Killer... I also don't have a lot on Meego as scum either. While she could be scum, she's just as likely a townie. She went after Kokiri, but the mafia would also want to get ride of him. Hanyou FOSed the Killer on day one too. I'd like to ask you Meego on who you are suspicious of as scum and hear your analysis.
Enemytracker, you have no more suspects? Take some time and think about it. There are at two scum left. Take a second look at the remaining players and think over who they might be. I won't lie and say I don't suspect you highly as scum, especially after this
post... but I don't want to write you off without giving you a chance.
And Zack I have been nervous about you for awhile now... a lot of what you say seems odd and almost scum-ish to me, but then you do something that looks very townie. You've stayed very calm and defend yourself well against accusations. THP is our best evidence we have to go on. She goes after Zack (
Here.), and then painfully defends a townie K4King, then changes her vote to Charge. Also after Zack announces that he believes MK9 is the cop, he is nightkilled. This seems very much pointing to the fact that he is townie. But I still can't shake off feeling suspicious of Zack. And I can't quite figure out what THP was trying to do... did she chicken out? Or something more elaborate?
We also should be considering Kokiri's theories and suspicions, but with a grain of salt. HE too would have wanted to find the scum, it would make him innocent of suspicion but also protect himself from the mafia. But keep in mind that he would have to save himself and get anyone who was a danger of suspecting him taken out too. Both he and Charge were suspicious of Zack, as was Xinnamin.
Charge.
Kokiri.
At the end of this... until I can get more information and input from you guys :puppy::
I FOS: Meego, Enemytracker, and Jetter as the most likely scum. But the odd thing is Jetter voted for Enemytracker, and Enemytracker voted for Meego. The scum are suspecting each another and selling one another out. Unless... PJ and Meego are the scum... because you two have (as I remember) never gone after one another... or voted for THP. PJ you've twice now pushed that scum wouldn't vote/throw own teammates to the wolves. And that brings us back to Zack and THP... Another combo could be Zack and Enemytracker, or Jetter and Meego... I personally think that both ET and Jetter being scum is a little too easy.