Mellow Ezlo- Hardly know where to begin on this one, bruh has almost fifty posts which is the largest amount on day one I can recall him ever having though its been a hot minute since the last large games he wasn't inactive in. Typically would want to say more active Trist is more scum Trist since motivation but like. Idk if he's just gotten smarter, but his reads aren't what I would expect from scum Trist and the way he's been going about it aren't what I would expect, he's so casual. The amount of effort he's put in is really unnecessary, idk if it's like him to overachieve as scum like that, or ever really which makes it a little harder to pin since it's a big motivation shift. The biggest thing for me is that he doesnt seem to care what anyone else thinks, he's not being overly friendly, at times unnecessarily harsh, just doing his thing and btw screw you. I'd be impressed if he was scum but hopefully if he is it'll become more obvious over time.
Rubik- I've already sort of explained this one but his posts just aren't what I would expect. They're too simple. Too easy. He knows this. He's not dumb. He's blatantly posting one liner after one liner of barely anything with zero elaboration and thats just not his style. It's just so careless, and Rube's not a careless person. Also I feel like he's legitimately upset that his posts aren't being taken as good contributions. I also feel like scum Rube would absolutely love lynching sun after he claims third party day one but could be wrong there. I would be very unimpressed if this turned out to be scum Rubik
naga10 @naga10 you scum bruh?
Spiritual Mask Salesman Where the heck are you man? Wheres the top poster sms? @Spiritual Mask Salesman
Morbid Minish
funnier6
Kirino
Jinjo
DawningWinds
DekuNut
Poyzin
Ragnarokio
Johnny Sooshi
Killjoy
Giri
The Sun Fan
ExLight
MixMasterLar
Lets try this again, ignore the bold I copy pasted sort of
Mellow Ezlo- "the biggest thing for me is that he doesnt seem to care what anyone else thinks, he's not being overly friendly, at times unnecessarily harsh, just doing his thing and btw screw you" This big thing has only gotten bigger, I can only recall one instance of Tristan being aggressive as scum and that was for unrelated reasons really, I feel safe town reading his anger lol.
Rubik- I believe him when he said he ought to be mechanically confirmed, I dont know why or how, but Rube dont take no cheap shots and I dont think thats something he would make up
naga10/fg I think- From the surface skim I've done of her posts she seems pretty typical peppy town fg, idk when I'll feel comfortable doing a more detailed analysis than that but she seems fine at a glance
Spiritual Mask Salesman- I dont really think he deserves the heat he's been getting, theres just a couple of things that just bother me, and one of those is his random defense of me after Trist voted me around post 700. Like, I just dont get why he'd defend me there, he'd already pointed out that he thought some of my play was weird, so it would've been easy him for him to progress that into voting me with Trist, but he doesnt and instead says Trist's just sound like typical me, which idk I just cant help feeling like scum sms would've been inclined to agree, not disagree. He apparently also has some info that clears Lar so that helps (though man I wish he had info saying we should lynch Lar instead. His motivation is rather low but that's true across the board for him so I dont really think it makes him any more likely to be scum. I'm just inclined to believe him.
Morbid Minish- There are a lot of different ways I could explain this one. She's got too much motivation, her pushes make sense, but the one that really gets me is how she talks to me. I dont really know how to put that last one into words without being depressing, but considering that Min is in three different games right now I find it really hard to believe that she's got the motivation to be here doing things as much as she has and being an active part of things going on instead of shifting into that more passive wall posty state she gets sometimes when she doesnt want to deal. I liked the Giri push she made last minute yesterday cause it did make sense, here take your lurker lynch just dont lynch sunfan isnt something I see scum Minish doing, it would be better for her to leave Giri alive to get mislynched or mod killed later, when there were all sorts of bigger fish possibilities to counter sunfan. It could just be a callback to when she did the exact same thing in Superman as town but thats not how it feels to me, I felt like she genuinely wanted the Giri lynch to happen over the sunfan one.
funnier6- has for some reason not softed his role yet, haha wonder what it is
Kirino- I dont remember why I was town reading Kirino in the first place tbqh, I'll have to check my old post. I dont really feel like going through his ISO rn so I'll come back to it
Jinjo- First off, havent found anything related to the OMGUS nonsense but I could swear I'd seen her do something like that somewhere before. Anyway even after skimming through all those games I couldn't really tell you if I'm not being biased with the scum read. Yes the tone drives me nuts and seems to be more like scum Jinjo and yes the pushes are extraordinarily weird and the accusations of lying about not remembering are so bonkers but like. It might just be because all of that was directed at me, and I know its complete bull and that it seems like the biggest sidestep backhand that I've ever seen in my life. Jinjo has never acted this aggressive about anything as far as I can tell and she's normally so logical and generally level headed that its just like I dont even know whats going on. Especially being she's getting upset because I dont find her scum play all that memorable. I just dont understand where shes coming from on literally anything. I want to think she's scum but I'm going to have to take a long hard look at her ISO again if I want to think about this logically.
DawningWinds/Pan- remains to be seen, but probably town
DekuNut- will never be seen, refuses to participate, is currently on my nerves
Poyzin- I explained this a good bit above, though I think it relevant to mention that the game is basically a dressing room for Poy to try on different personas, and I can generally tell when his is genuine. His vibe is pretty okay, but that doesnt really mean anything to me being he hasn't been here to begin with
Ragnarokio- I'll leave this one a bit too, I wanna look at her ISO again
Johnny Sooshi- His posts have been extremely good, which is weird cause typically he posts a couple weird things here and there and ditches the rest of the day but he's actually been keeping a pretty clear sensible flow of thoughts. I'm going to look at his ISO and some other games right quick but I kind of dont want him to be scum cause its so nice to have this level of involvement from him lol
Killjoy/Silver- I really just dont know what this one, and I'm not bound to know since I never really can read Silver and I'm always thinking yes finally Silv rolled scum and it just never happens and then I feel bad.
MixMasterLar- Ima level with you and say I've never really liked you and have been avoiding everything except direct questions from you since I just have not been in the mood to have any sort of argument with you. I am in the mood now and you havent been quite as bad as I was expecting so thats cool. I'm still expecting to disagree with you on every single read and for every single reason that justifies each of those reads but at least I think I can do so without getting unduly frustrated.
Also yes I know intentionally not engaging someone is anti town and I'm aware you believe a b c d e f g and all the other letters of the alphabet are anti town thanks for coming to my ted talk
In terms of actually reading you I gotta say I appreciate the irony if you're putting on the charm as scum after saying that doesnt happen, I'm a little wary of that but tbh I cant remember why I had you as a town read in the first place other than the fact that the amount of effort you put in is enormous and its just easier that way, will check and get back to you
Oh yeah I just remembered sms thinks youre clear so thats cool
I found this lovely gem just a second ago when I was flipping through my tabs which I find hilarious and hopefully very accurate
"Everything Jinjo said was completely illogical and none of it stood up to rational examination. It seriously looks like Jinjo was trying to pin me as scum and was scrambling to find any argument, no matter how insane, that people might be gullible enough to fall for."
From Jinjo's scum game Rival Mafia
So poetic if that's true
It really sucks that we lynched sun day one not that theres any use crying about it but its like dang now I need another day of votes so I can actually try to read into some wagons when most of the first day's reasoning are "gotta kill third party" "dust wanna kill third party he could be helpful" so I hope we get some good stuff done today
Remember to like and subscribe for more of funnyguy555's readlists
