I'd say E10+
It will have it's share of borderline stuff to be sure though
Looking at OoT3DS which got an E10+ rating, despite the bottom of the well, the shadow temple, the great fairies, dead hand, redeads....ya know, all that stuff that totally WON'T induce nightmares in anyone. Totally. (It's even worse in MM, and that still goes by an E rating...)
I'm not worried...I'm sure SS will have it's share of dark 'n creepy as well. Nintendo seems to like slipping that kind of stuff in their Zelda games, so I wouldn't doubt anything different for SS. Expect a new generation of creepy-looking impressionistic redeads. :nod:
Probably E10+ but hopefully T.
Although I didn't really consider Twilight Princess a dark game. At all. In fact, at some points it got so make-me-gag happy that I wanted to punch the TV. So....why was it rated T?
Probably for the cut scene after you finish collecting all the tears of light in Lanayru province. Oh, and the cutscene with Ganondorf in chains. So basically...just for a couple of cutscenes. That's it. And yeah, I think MM is more T-ish than TP is >_>