I've replied to the post before, but I'll try to sum up my rebuttal.
ALIT was all over the place. You even say he was super confusing to understand, and I am right there with you. And the moment Eduarda pointed out ALIT's mistake, I felt like we had found scum. So I attacked first. I saw liar and I went with my gut, just like you did with Sooshi. If you look back, Sooshi was pretty upset that I attacked ALIT so soon, like I didn't give him time to protect his scum pal. At that point, Sooshi was on my scum radar, but then the "who attack Eduarda" thing happened and I was fooled by Sooshi's claim. Many were. Except you, of course.
Also, ALIT for some reason latched himself to Doc, me, and Sooshi. Eduarda later on thought I was the scum in the three because Johnny was "town". But now we know that the one hiding in the three of us was Johnny.
JC, I don't know why you are so obsessed with my first post. At first, I thought it was a good idea. I didn't want it to be hard to kill scum towards lylo because they had too much health. Kokirion also presented a good idea, but not everyone was sold on it like you say it was. I was so confused with the different opinions that I stopped and said I have no idea what would be good.
Oh gee, I don't know. Maybe because I'm not a Mafia member? Oh, and yes, this is a major flaw.
What? I was agreeing with the suspicion! Sooshi made the same mistake in TF2 and sure he flipped town, but wouldn't there be a original VT? There shouldn't be a regular VT in this game but there should be an original VT. Therefore ALIT should have known about original if he was the same as Sooshi before.
If you have any other questions for me, please ask.