Game Thread Square Enix Mafia

[a'lana]

Actuallyhmm

Also this bizarre sequence of posts where he seems to be aware millers can't self-prove but yet says he doesn't know what a miller is.
I'm not even going to try to understand what the hell happened here nor why his first instinct is to get a null position on something he doesn't even remember what is.
Instead I'll just assume miscommunication in the scumchat if he flips red which is very subtle extra info

that is worth noting

 

[a'lana]

Mikey because IMO early unprompted claiming or softing is >randtown +I think him being overly suicidal is towny

Minish seems way more solvy compared to the Chaos Mafia game (you either co hosted or spectated) already.

you because I agreed with your early thoughts

CynicalSquid I'm currently rethinking my read on because my reasons are maybe weak (mostly an early reason for Sean vote and liked their explanation for early ExLight vote), back to null actually

Hapi since now became a full townread after she actually started doing stuff

The rest hadn't left an impression on me much, I know that Ragnarokio Numbers Raven posted but they all didn't leave an impression

And libk made like one post and disappeared. And person whose name I keep forgetting I didn't even realise posted

Oh I forgot ExLight.

For bringing the item stuff up

 

[ExLight]

For bringing the item stuff up

really? owo
people sometimes freak out when I bring mechanical talk early on because they think it's scum fishing for info or trying to shift attention from proper discussion so I always have to think twice before bringing those up

 

[Morbid Minish]

Do I bring up the "he's the most sus to me" contrasting with the "Don't really think he's scum"? no?

The first post you quoted came after the second though, which skews it a bit more to fit your perspective if other people aren't looking back at posts, which I find a bit interesting.

 

[Morbid Minish]

Also this bizarre sequence of posts where he seems to be aware millers can't self-prove but yet says he doesn't know what a miller is.
I'm not even going to try to understand what the hell happened here nor why his first instinct is to get a null position on something he doesn't even remember what is.
Instead I'll just assume miscommunication in the scumchat if he flips red which is very subtle extra info

I don't find this as bizarre as you seem to and don't think the explanation of it being a scumchat miscommunication makes much sense.

 

[Princess Abigail]

Mikey because IMO early unprompted claiming or softing is >randtown +I think him being overly suicidal is towny

Minish seems way more solvy compared to the Chaos Mafia game (you either co hosted or spectated) already.

you because I agreed with your early thoughts

CynicalSquid I'm currently rethinking my read on because my reasons are maybe weak (mostly an early reason for Sean vote and liked their explanation for early ExLight vote), back to null actually

Hapi since now became a full townread after she actually started doing stuff

The rest hadn't left an impression on me much, I know that Ragnarokio Numbers Raven posted but they all didn't leave an impression

And libk made like one post and disappeared. And person whose name I keep forgetting I didn't even realise posted

How dare! I was always doing stuff :p

 

[Killjoy262]

really? owo
people sometimes freak out when I bring mechanical talk early on because they think it's scum fishing for info or trying to shift attention from proper discussion so I always have to think twice before bringing those up

I've had a slight panic ever since you mentioned it. I just haven't mentioned it because I'd panic even more.

 

[ExLight]

The first post you quoted came after the second though, which skews it a bit more to fit your perspective if other people aren't looking back at posts, which I find a bit interesting.

I'm kinda just going back and forth the thread quoting as I find them
but yea, he became more "sus" to Squid after Seanzie prodded a lot of people and contested and asked Squid to elaborate on this accusation which makes zero sense

I do not appreciate the attempt of shading me when it being in the proper order is even more evidence of him being incoherent though

 

[a'lana]

I'd be fine with a libk policy lynch because I have zero patience with inactive players simply giving headaches to mods and their team

Lmfao two months ago I played a game where a majority of players were lurkers

People all early naked voted the PR and then left and no one cared, said PR claimed EIGHT HOURS before EoD three town players are all afk and then said PR only got saved because of both scum cfd'ing another townie

Next day only wolves post in first 24 hours of f5, next day town suddenly starts showing up. one of the town literally posted and voted only 8 hours before EoD and one of the town never showed up. It goes to RNG. F3 is like 1 post for 42 hours until town finally got arsed to vote the remaining scum

It was a ****show

 

[ExLight]

Lmfao two months ago I played a game where a majority of players were lurkers

People all early naked voted the PR and then left and no one cared, said PR claimed EIGHT HOURS before EoD three town players are all afk and then said PR only got saved because of both scum cfd'ing another townie

Next day only wolves post in first 24 hours of f5, next day town suddenly starts showing up. one of the town literally posted and voted only 8 hours before EoD and one of the town never showed up. It goes to RNG. F3 is like 1 post for 42 hours until town finally got arsed to vote the remaining scum

It was a ****show

the most shocking part is town ever showing up again honestly lmfao

 

[Morbid Minish]

I'm kinda just going back and forth the thread quoting as I find them
but yea, he became more "sus" to Squid after Seanzie prodded a lot of people and contested and asked Squid to elaborate on this accusation which makes zero sense

I do not appreciate the attempt of shading me when it being in the proper order is even more evidence of him being incoherent though

My quotes have always appeared in order of when they were posted regardless of when I quote them. Didn't know if it works different on different browsers.

But it also isn't more evidence. The way it's quoted it looks like he says that he's keeping his vote on Seanzie, though he doesn't remember the original reason for voting him, because he thinks he's most sus. And then after that saying that Seanzie hasn't done anything as explanation. When that was the explanation he couldn't remember before. And the timeline of the posts has Seanzie posting in between them. So the not doing anything coming second makes it look like it was more recent, after Seanzie has done more. You didn't quote the entire context saying that he feels like Seanzie hasn't done much and has felt that most of his posts have been jokes. Which, a lot of Seanzie's early posts are jokey. The "he's most sus" part came later after that and wasn't explained any further, so we don't know if something has pinged him as more sus since then or if it's still the same explanation.

 

[ExLight]

But it also isn't more evidence. The way it's quoted it looks like he says that he's keeping his vote on Seanzie, though he doesn't remember the original reason for voting him, because he thinks he's most sus. And then after that saying that Seanzie hasn't done anything as explanation. When that was the explanation he couldn't remember before. And the timeline of the posts has Seanzie posting in between them. So the not doing anything coming second makes it look like it was more recent, after Seanzie has done more. You didn't quote the entire context saying that he feels like Seanzie hasn't done much and has felt that most of his posts have been jokes. Which, a lot of Seanzie's early posts are jokey. The "he's most sus" part came later after that and wasn't explained any further, so we don't know if something has pinged him as more sus since then or if it's still the same explanation.

SIGH

 

[ExLight]

do I beg for forgiveness for quoting and copy pasting the messages (I do that because it's faster that having to wait for the browser to save the draft) in the wrong order now or what

 

[Morbid Minish]

SIGH

I don't know why you're sighing at me when I just find your logic and presentation of that logic to be suspect which, is the game. To me, presenting something in an order that can be read differently than it's intended looks odd. Even if you didn't purposely do that, I can't know that you didn't, so I'm going to state my suspicions.

 

[ExLight]

his original reason for voting seanzie was to pressure him into giving the '17 reads', obviously an early game joke
he morphs the narrative later into "Seanzie isn't contributing" which was a lie
when seanzie questions that and shows that he's been contributing his reasoning simply disappears and becomes "most sus" despite him not even previously showing suspicion towards seanzie
no reassessment on his vote, no attempt of finding better places to put a vote (which he keeps bringing up as necessary because he doesn't want to lynch Moe "who literally noone voted for" the Moblin), NOTHING

hope this clarifies it