Lol same game, opposite rating. I 'd easily give SS a 10/10, my opinion on the gameplay is also opposite, I found everything new and exciting and really not any more linear than the other 3D Zelda games, I mean, there were technically 4 overworlds in the game and there was so much more to do outside of the main story compared to the other games (gratitude crystal side quests, treasure hunting for stuff other than money, boss endurance, item and potion upgrades. A buy and sell system that depended on the time of day...etc.) I loved the motion controls and I think it did a lot better than twilight princess in pretty much everything (story, boss fights, character dev, gameplay, minigames, exploration). I replayed this game along with ALTTP the most. But I guess people do like different games for different reasons.The legend of Zelda skyward sword, I have total conflict with this game were I loved the story of the game but the motion controls and gameplay over all got repetitive and really linear. I found it hard to make it to the end I only really did it because I wanted the story out of it, so overall probably a 5/10 I would much rather replay twilight princess I had a much more enjoyable game play experience out of that game