I had much to say to yours and others so it would only follow that you could if you looked
Are you implying I haven't read those posts? Cause I have. Lol. You had a lot to say because you disagreed. I agreed so I didn't feel the need to reiterate that if I had nothing else to add.
Echo can come off genuine with anything I'd think. We all know she is like 12, she adds the crying emojis, you want to believe anything she says, lol. Idk in games I toss that all aside though.
Look at the difference between her answering if she were mafia and then her confession. I think she just said "No I am not mafia" (which technically wasn't a lie, lol). It was minimum and to the point probably because she knew she was hiding something even if she technically told the truth there. Then when she was asked if she is town, she came clean. I dunno, but that contrast feels actually genuine to me. And I feel she would be much stiffer with her replies if she were lying.
I don't find it overflowing with genuineness
It's more like the circumstances do it credit
See the above reply to SMS. But also, her freaking out about dying and promising to help town and catch scum didn't feel like she was playing anything up to me. She reiterated like 5 times that she was working with town. Lol.
This vote makes no sense, even as a pressure vote.
Why doesn't it make sense even as a pressure vote?
The reasoning SMS himself has given is different though, and I can’t help but wonder if he’s using this as an excuse to backpedal now that he’s been called out for his vote. Anyway,
Unvote
Vote: Johnny
Why spend half that post talking about suspicions on SMS only to vote Johnny?
What if Echolight faked an unintentional 3P slip so that we would write them off as genuine, but they were scum the whole time and only wanted us to think they were a passive 3P?
Regardless I always lynch 3Ps so imma keep my vote here until I scumread someone else.
"I always lynch 3rd party, until a better mislynch comes along that I can hop on without suspicion".
If you always lynch 3rd party why would you switch later?
Minish did you role scum again—again?
Nope. And it would've been more like again, again, again. Lol.
The first part is blatantly untrue in regards to SKs. In fact, typically SKs are just as dangerous to scum as townies, perhaps even moreso since they have their own agendas. So saying third party are low priority for scum is just wrong, especially SKs, because even if the wincon is to win with the winning team it would be easier to win with town than scum. And if the wincon is last man standing, then they'll pick off their biggest threats first, which should be scum leans.
The second and third parts feel contradictory to me. You say you'll unvote her if she says she isn't SK, but then you say if she is then she can work with town? If that was your thought, why did you bother voting her in the first place? Day 1 third party lynches are not helpful since they don't help us progress at all in reality and I will always suspect those who 3p hunt during the first day. We're here to hunt scum, if a 3P exists (which we know it does), she won't be a big threat to us until later if she even is one at all.
It is for this reason that I also suspect Poyzin. 3p lynches day 1 are just way too easy and feel like copouts to me.
Ugh, I like this Tristan post a lot which makes me conflicted. Sensible Tristan is scum Tristan except for when me and funnier lynched him as jailer.
But for real, these are a lot of my thoughts on stuff which Tristan usually tends to do a good job of thinking the same way I do. I think I'm just gonna town read it for now and wait to see if Tristan makes me hate what he's saying. Lol.
Oh wait you could’ve said they admitted it, I thought it was because she said “I’m not mafia”.
Do you even read the thread? Yeah that was one post. But there have been multiple posts discussing her admitting to being 3rd party. How could you get the idea that people thought she was 3rd party, but not get the idea that she confessed to being 3rd party?
I actually think Poyzin's behavior here is quite different from the last game when he was scum. Sure, Poyzin pulled the same "I'm X. Lol not really" but aside from the claim of being Ike, a lot of his posts were reactionary then. This time he feels like he's scumhunting and genuinely trying to get those "town or scum pings."
I disagree with his "always lynch 3P" mentality but I am leaning towards it being a town mentality nevertheless.
Bless town Doc. We will keep you safe from the bad man this time! Despite his title he is far from innocent.
There's no reason to lynch Echo and I'd rather go for one of my stated scum reads, likely SMS. Given that there's already a bandwagon on him, his lynch would give the most information.
I refer back to my earlier replies to your quotes. Why vote Johnny if you'd likely rather go for SMS?
I'm not mentally well enough to scumhunt rn tbf
I feel like Echo will prolly get lynched because town doesn't want that backfiring later
Why do you feel like Echo is gonna be lynched? There are multiple people saying it's a bad lynch.
...
The amount of people who say they are getting reads on me this early is baffling, especially because I haven’t even don’t anything townie yet. Sussing those who have done so.
With that being said, my Mellow Ezio read overrules that and I think they’re in the town boat with funnier and Johnny Sooshi, but I’m fine with being wrong once in a while, so I’ll have to re look over those tomorrow. Or maybe today if people are pushy. I think Doc or Minish are most likely to be scum at this point in time.
How can you say you're suspicious of the people town reading you, then give half of them a pass, except for Doc. And then throw me in as a scum lean even though I'm not even town reading you? Like why even make a point of calling out people town reading you and then just throw that away?
And for what it's worth, people can have opinions on you for things that don't align with your own thoughts of being read. It's frustrating when people say stuff like "you can't read me yet because I haven't done things I feel are AI".
