It would seem that the game has taken quite a turn, from the one sentence mess-arounds I was seeing to now actual thinking and putting pieces together, which is excellent.
I'm really not 100% convinced that anyone might be the mafia yet, nor am I even convinced enough to turn my first FoS. But here's who I don't think it could be:
Master Kokiri 9: He just seemed way too active and excited from the start, telling me he had absolutely no intention of laying low. I mean really, he has THE FIRST post in the thread, calling out the mafia himself like I'd expect anyone who was excited for the game would do. He also seems way too "in-the-game" for me to think he's truly trying to manipulate anyone at all.
Viral Maze: I can definitely tell he's a long time veteran at this when compared to most all of us. If he's a mafia and trying his best to hide it, he's completely succeeded in my eyes, seeing as I have next to no suspicion. He seems to put way too much thought into everything, pulling the first vote (and with logical reasons too). But seeing as I know how to read Charge a lot deeper than most, doubt is starting to creep in as far as that vote is concerned, making me wonder if he's just wrapping up his theories in a pretty box and bow to pass right through us. But as of right now, he's low on the list.
PJDEP: A lot like Master Kokiri - Brand new to the game, got picked as the common townie, and jumped in as soon as possible to join in the fun because he had nothing to hide. He would have been like Xinnamin more in the way that'd he stay out of the huge picture and just post sly little comments taunting everyone else if this was his first go and he was a mafia.
Durion: THIS COULD CHANGE IN A HEARTBEAT You seem a lot like Viral in the way that you seem to do too much thinking in the right direction to truly care about the mafia. I agree with the vast majority of your thinking too, besides still suspecting me, which I've yet to get a cold-hard reason for doing so anyway. You're probably the closest I'm at to 100% townie as far as suspecting goes, but you're one of those guys who loves to back stab with Earthquake, so you could go at anytime in my book.
And then there's the guys who've gotten on and posted one sentence that included an accusation at someone for no good reason. I just see these as the in-experienced townies who still don't really know what they're doing.
As far as mafia goes so far...... TreeHuggerPanda and Xinnamin stick out most to me. TreeHugger just because she's contradicted herself SO MANY times, and Xinnamin because her first post just screamed mafia to me, even through she's doing her best to cover it all up now.
So yeah, my first FoS:
Xinnamin
TreeHuggerPanda
Day ends Monday, June 7th. Takes 13 votes to get a majority lynch.
