This is interesting. Paints OG as mafia, and doesn't give him a newbie pass. Without knowing OG's alignment it is hard to say the motivation of this. I am curious what makes you think this about him though.
Its a personality read, and based on the impression i get of OG as a person rather than anything concrete.
While her single post about OG matches this vote, saying he's her strongest read does not. She has not talked about anyone else outside of calling Storm fatalistic. With her previous OG post this makes sense, but the explanation behind it does not. I could see her as mafia bussing mafia that messed up.
Why doesn't me saying OG is my strongest read not track? If i only talked about them would they not be my strongest read? What about my explanation behind my OG post doesn't make sense? in the scenario where me and OG are mafia, in what way did OG mess up?
3) This makes no sense. If the mechanics are what caused the issue then how does that make BMG players look worse? If it is a mechanics thing then why is it more likely BMG players were the killers?
there was meant to be a linebreak partway through there, and so the final two lines were a summation of my feelings considering all three points. If mechanics caused the kill it does not implicate a BMG player.
It is really suspicious that Rag is separating players by websites in this post. While calling out individual players is one thing, she is instead trying to pin the whole mafia as from one site.
I didn't mean to insinuate that the whole mafia was from one site and such an event is statistically unlikely. What i meant to insinuate was that given the kill, it seemed to increase the likelyhood of bulbagarden players being represented in the decision making process behind the kill. As an example, if the mafia team were jamie, OG, and HHH, and jamie said in their night chat that he thought beryl would make a good kill because he thought that she was a cop then HHH, being a relatively accomodating player, and OG being new might have gone along with the plan. In this case, jamie's association with the soft-heavy meta of BG drove the kill even though the mafia team would have been 2/3 ZD players. Its also true that just because someone is from BG doesn't mean they'll consider softs when picking a kill, whether or not they tend to prefer to play the game that way. Jamie himself has said that he didn't think beryl was softing with her post, and thats feasibly how he actually feels, in which case even if jamie is mafia and decided to kill beryl it wouldn't have been because of softing like i posited. There are also going to be BG players that are more or less likely to engage in that kind of gameplay, although i'm not familiar enough with the players to make a guess about who would be implicated by that kind of kill. I'm sorry if you find the characterization of bulbagarden players offensive, though i don't think its an unreasonable guess that bulbagarden players on average will be more likely to choose a kill based on perceived softs than players from other communities would be on average. Its not necessarily true, but i'm working on limited information and trying to work towards winning the game by making the best guesses i can.
I have yet to see Rag do anything except accuse others. Min as mafia would have no reason to say she got rolecop results unless a townie came out with saying they rolecopped someone. There is just no scum motivation in it.
What does one typically do in mafia aside from accuse others? Defend themselves? I haven't been attacked until now so i haven't had an opportunity. Help solve mechanically? I did a bit of that, although i don't think there's much of that to do yet given the lack of results and their uncertainty. I don't tend to townread players as often as i scumread them (although anyone i'm not scumreading looks better by process of elimination), so i guess that might be what you're looking for in my play? If so, why do you think townreading players is alignment indicitive? I tend to read by looking at player actions and finding situations where i think they would play something differently as town than they would as scum, and adjust my reads based on that. You've seen two examples of this in the form of thinking OG as mafia is more likely to try and make a tricky play than he would as town and feeling like his "mistake" could be a representation of that, and feeling like the kill on beryl being possibly soft-motivated indicates that jamie could be the killer, becaues scum jamie is more likely to kill beryl for softing cop than town jamie would be. I haven't yet seen any player do something that i feel they would do as town but wouldn't do as scum, and i think thats probably rarer than the opposite case, because scum has motivation to play like town but town does not have motivation to play like scum.
As for minish's motive to claim the rolecop results, she gave them herself. She feels that mafia, if given another player's investigative results, would feel pressured to share them for fear of looking suspicious otherwise. Whether minish is town or mafia, her saying this is probably honest, and thus it can be said she has motivation to share the results if she is mafia.