Minish's post didn't particularly ping me, but I've played with her like three times before and I definitely feel like she kept up with the thread a lot more then (those games were also in 2020 though so this might be worth taking with a grain of salt), so I guess I could agree this might be indicative of something? Would like to hear Seanzie detail his actual reasoning for surs though.
I really wanted to see if Fext was able to analyze anything, but they aren't going to, so I'll talk about Minish now.
Their one post reads more like receipts than thoughts. They mention all the things going on (and give an excuse why they didn't mention more), and say a few things here and there are NAI, but don't take any sides, don't make any conclusions about people's alignments. Also, while town can be hedgy, I felt like the way they were being hedgy (for example with DW, saying scum might not change their mind so quick but might if they think it is easy to latch on to, negating eachother) was possibly more about making their post denser than actually progressing a read.
So, I felt it was a bit IIoA and more of "look at what I read" instead of "see what I think".
Still early so I'm not going to ride-or-die this read, but I thought it was worth mentioning Minish's name as they have not yet inspired any confidence in me.