You're defending her an awful lot based on your own interpretations of her messages, I'd rather have her explain what she meant herself but if she's scum now you gave her excuses all chewed up so now my whole attempt to prod her is useless
:^)
:^)
Game Thread CHAOS MAFIA VII- BUCK IN NEW YORK
- Thread starter Storm
- Start date
saying hapi is being voted unfairly because people aren't considering her meta and following it with saying hapi is one of the scummiest in a group she's analyzing is a blatant contradiction
if she truly thinks hapi has any reasons to be scumread then she would not dismiss other players' votes purely as lack of meta
Aside from the crossvote thing there's not much that comes from personal interpretation? Most of what I pointed out was actually in the text.
She literally just says she's townreading me more than KoD. That's not a scumread in anyway considering she's pretty consistently townread me so far, especially since she also states that he's not worth lynching in her mind.
She doesn't think Hapi's scummy though. She just puts her as the most likely scum of four people who aren't scummy to her. Nothing a'lana's said about Abi's meta suggests she thinks Abi's play is town-indicative with meta, just that it's not scum-indicative and she doesn't think pushing her without considering meta is smart-- that lines up reasonably with "Abi's not as townie as these three other people". Again, she explicitly says that none of the four players in the crossvotes are scummy to her, which means Neon is by that statement obviously not considered seriously scummy to her.
idek where you coming from because i can't tell whether you're white knighting her or just taking her text at too much of a face value
if she really was townreading you that much she'd be trying to get steam off you asap by help identify other viable options for a wagon, from where I stand it feels like you were pocketed pretty badly
if she really was townreading you that much she'd be trying to get steam off you asap by help identify other viable options for a wagon, from where I stand it feels like you were pocketed pretty badly
Princess Abigail
Resident Juice Sipping Icon
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2020
- Gender
- Female
Alana is also right by the way. Voting me without meta knowledge generally ends poorly 98.5% of the time and Alana knows this because even though we only played one game together I was ran up day 1 but ended up helping win the game in lylo and admittedly I played poorly until lylo 2 electric boogaloo but I was indeed town despite the incessant pressure early.
And indeed this is my problem. My most usefulness is in lylo. It was lylo 2 where I reread sparkles and won the game. In champs with kod it was near lylo where I reread kod admittedly way to late in the phase and inevitably caused his night kill and in lylo where I actively attempted to pressure his correct mafia read although we lost.
But in general I'm an enigma early because of numerous factors which include me wanting to have fun in a game rather than push psychological reads of some words on a page early that mean nothing without context and my absolute inability to trust my reads ever, something I've been working on. And indeed day 2 I often do become more useful unless I see something really off-putting to me early like voting without context which is a big hell to the naw to me.
Just because she isn't spelling it out doesn't mean she isn't throwing shade at Hapi by singling her out with her "most likely to be scum out of those"
throwing shade at Hapi and KoD saying they're less likely to be town than the people she already put in a mini readlist as town contributes literally nothing since it was already implied and if anything just gives her an excuse for her to potentially swap her vote into later on, as well as giving it fuel for potential people to sheep the opinions
...Can you explain the term "white knighting" in a Mafia context? I have never seen it before this game and this is the second time I've been accused of.
You do have a bit of a point about a town player most likely being inclined to defend their townreads. Skimming through her posts she hasn't done much in the way of actually trying to get others to where she's at with any of her reads.
You do have a bit of a point about a town player most likely being inclined to defend their townreads. Skimming through her posts she hasn't done much in the way of actually trying to get others to where she's at with any of her reads.
Princess Abigail
Resident Juice Sipping Icon
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2020
- Gender
- Female
In a game where day 1 lynches are necessary such as mafia I find that attempting to read people ends just as often in town getting lynched day 1 as just kinda shooting a fish at random in a barrel and while I will vote for the person I find scummiest day 1 it will generally be more for something like being non existent or refusing to post context or getting super defensive over little unnecessary things than anything else. But in the case of Dawning they've been growing on me and admittedly the defensiveness while largely unnecessary was directed at the right things which is important in this context.
Princess Abigail
Resident Juice Sipping Icon
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2020
- Gender
- Female
I believe it's essentially being overly protective of someone and not letting them defend themself but defending them unwaveringly but I could be wrong lol
it's pretty self explanatory
but yea, basically what Hapi said
it's when you rush to continuously defend someone just for the sake of being protective of that person, without considering much as to why the person is being prodded or accused
but yea, basically what Hapi said
it's when you rush to continuously defend someone just for the sake of being protective of that person, without considering much as to why the person is being prodded or accused
I don't think she'd put Seanzie as town? Previously anyway. On that note I am a little confused at Neon being more scum than Seanzie since neither of them are marked as being considered anything more townie than "not scum indicative in their meta". Though yeah putting KoD as less town than me really doesn't do very much when she's alread said she thinks I'm townie and not done so for KoD.
But I don't feel it'd really be effective as an excuse to vote them, given she states multiple times she doesn't view either of them as scummy. That'd be kind of obvious backtracking unless something later could naturally be sold as something she'd see as scummy from them.
I didn't say that? What's your point here?
What I'm saying is that:
- She publicly posted having a town read on me, you, and Raven.
- If she's scumleaning Hapi and KoD, she's suddenly throwing shade at Hapi who she had just defended
- If she's neutralreading Hapi and KoD, all of those posts are CWAC, because it adds nothing to what we couldn't figure out from her previous readlist
- She publicly posted having a town read on me, you, and Raven.
- If she's scumleaning Hapi and KoD, she's suddenly throwing shade at Hapi who she had just defended
- If she's neutralreading Hapi and KoD, all of those posts are CWAC, because it adds nothing to what we couldn't figure out from her previous readlist
*to what we could already figure out