We need to combine into one being to become the ultimate mafia player with my pressuring and planning skills and your scum reading abilities we would dominate every game.
I'm disappointed in some of the mistakes I made this game. Such as the following:
1. Two consecutive days I started off suspecting Deku, and then switching my lynch target
2. I hid behind Minish at night even though I knew how suspicious kokis libk push was, I just read koki so poorly because he...
Really fun game, ALIT. There was a bit of luck on both sides (eclipse prediction, Deku's slip up for scum -- me not being tracked, storm dying early for town), but overall I think it was a great game.
There are possibly some things you can do with the setup, but I honestly don't think scum had...
I think your assumption that there was parity could have possibly saved the game. I asked @A Link In Time about a million questions pregame about the setup including that, so I knew that was wrong, but the fact that you thought it was right really helped.
Although, I imagine vergo would have...
"Well, let's start as we discussed:
*Koki kills Kaio-Kenshin*
And continuing the history of me following our next target
*Deku tracks Jamie*"
"Hmmm I was thinking of only killing Jamie while not making use of our second kill. Kaio is a threat, yes, but we can kill her after you are lynched and...
So even though I never got around to being able to implement it, here was what my thoughts were if koki flipped town:
Bok or Minish would be scum, and I'd be leaning towards Minish. So, the question would be whether or not to hide behind Minish, I had this sort of thought process:
If it gets...
Alright I'm going to just go with my gut that I'm right. My current assessment is as follows:
Koki - astrologer
Bok - VT
Vergo- survivor
Minish - hot pocket lover
Me - Jesus Christ
That's what I believe.
Cause the reason I'm saying this isn't just the parity but that she was sure the person in neighbourhood 3 was the town asshole. Doesn't that sound like she knew that the hot potato (almost said hot pocket lmao) was in neighbourhood 2? How else could she know this? Or do you think it was just a...
@Prophecies About Bok Choy while I know minish cannot confirm it herself, how do you feel about my assessment of minish link being the hot potato due to the comments about neighbourhood parity? Do you agree?
You know what, I'm changing my mind on this one. Last time I changed my mind it ended poorly but I remember Minish mentioning something about parity in the towns. How if Johnny has a role in neighbourhood 1, there must be an Asshole in neighbourhood 3. All I can think about that is how did...
In order of scummiest to least scummy:
Minish_Link
kokirion
Bok
Vergo
Myself
Basically vergo if you are scum I think we all agree you win. If Minish_Link or kokirion dies here and flips town I think we are going to have to take a close look at bok the following day before making a decision...
@Minish_Link @Ver-go-a-go-go I encourage both of you to place votes as well. I am not even close to convinced and so I feel fairly unconfident here and would be fine with kokirion as a lynched as well.
Not sure what to do. Part of me thinks that Minish_Link is scum and was working together with Deku to plan everything. Part of me thinks kokirion is scum and led a Libk lynch on the idea that he was good enough to defend himself from any possible lynch. I'm not sure. I'm going with my gut. Like...
I can't confirm or deny your idea of my role because I'd be mod killed but I will say that the asshole is in a precarious position now for the reasons you pointed out.
Yeah, I agree vergo is most likely town.
I am not saying this is Bok's meta but rather because he is new I really don't...
I really have this between koki and Minish_Link and I'd be surprised if other users didn't also have this mindset. I feel, Minish, like you could easily have coordinated your moves with koki. I'm fairly convinced at this point that if bok or vergo are scum, town is losing this game. I would like...
I was so goddamn close to switching my vote to Deku last night. After he mentioned the Eclipse thing I felt like that was so ****ing scummy to bring that up at the end of the day like that, but I couldn't bring myself to switch my vote
So, here we go:
1. @Ver-go-a-go-go where the **** are you...
I don't really see any role indication about TA anywhere. Where are you seeing this? You think he wants to get a scum attack targeted to him? I don't read koki as scum so I don't follow your logic.
It's much more suspicious to not say anything than to say your suspicions even if they are not concrete. You realize if Libk is scum you're probably going to be lynched right after the double night right? Which may jeopardize our chances of winning at the end of it all if you're town.
I never said it's ideal, I said I'm okay with it. It's not Lylo. I'm leaning towards you but I'm relatively unsure. I can't convincingly make a 100% argument for either person. Therefore, coin flip is okay for me. And ALIT confirmed just now what I thought was the case, even if we lose 3 town in...
Lmao then vote for me then. Actions speak louder than words.
I don't think it's scummy at all though. I'd prefer a lynch of you but Deku isn't exactly squeaky clean. I've never been opposed to coin flips before if I'm unsure.
I'm fine with a coin flip lynch if that's what it comes down to. Not sure of the current vote count. I'm pushing for Libk's lynch due to Deku's post about Pendio though.
@A Link In Time
Is a case with 2 townies, 1 survivor and 2 scum a win for scum or is it still a winnable game for town? I think we are all wondering this after Bok's post.
To be honest I find it weird that they want a double night now given that if Libk isn't scum and then there's 2 consecutive nights the deaths would lead to a DekuNut lynch almost certainly. But I guess at the end of the day, 2 mafia kills is 2 mafia kills, but it does make me feel like they...
Yeah, I agree with your assessment that it's more likely to be a town mistake than a mafia mistake, and definitely more likely to be a town mistake than a purposeful scum move. I wouldn't pin Deku as someone who would do that. Personally I'm really careful to never make mistakes like that...
It's always possible it was just a scum slip-up, something that must be considered. And yeah, well, I think it's a given if Deku is lynched and flips town we will be going after each other tomorrow.
@Libk if we assume you are town, then do you believe that Deku intentionally screwed up thinking Pen was alive to gain town credit? Or do you think I'm scum instead?