I believe that he is a Townie due to the fact that he can't be the Mafia, because no Seriel Killer in their own right state of mind would attempt to kill themselves hoping that the Doctor would save them, thus clearing their own name of being the Seriel Killer.
Mafia Round 2
- Thread starter Ver-go-a-go-go
- Start date
- Status
I believe that he is a Townie due to the fact that he can't be the Mafia, because no Seriel Killer in their own right state of mind would attempt to kill themselves hoping that the Doctor would save them, thus clearing their own name of being the Seriel Killer.
What does the Mafia have to do with the Serial Killer?
Xinnamin
Mrs. Austin
Wait, what? Why can't he be mafia? I'm not following that logic...or was that a typo?
Damn it, EBWODP (unless someone posts before I can)....
He could however be Mafia, as he would know if Triforce Eden was Mafia or not, thus allowing him to say "Scum or not" (which in my mind, could lead some to believe he was a townie). However, from the way he voted and for what reasons he did so, I have concluded that he isn't Mafia due to the fact his voting is strategical enough. I believe the Mafia would aim for someone who has made some comments that have already attracted attention (and suspicion), or their posts can easily brought to attention (and once again, everyone's suspicion). Therefore, eliminating two more Townies (or the SK) out of play...which Zenox clearly isn't doing. Although, I've getting rather suspicious of you Zenox.
Next, this going on argument between Master Kokiri 9 and Atsuma is arousing suspicion, although, the majority of that suspicion is aimed at Atsuma. Master Kokiri 9 on an offensive more against Atsuma. Which rises some suspicion, but I believe the Mafia wouldn't be so bold about killing a townie, why would they need to be? But last round Master Kokiri 9 was a Seriel Killer and that tactic worked great for him as he survived for many rounds, so who says he is using it again as a Mafia?. And this attack is starting to punch holes through Atsuma's defense, such as him evading questions or not quite fully answering them IMO. I'll have to fully analyse both parties posts tomorrow as I am too tired to do so tonight, after all, it is 2:28 in the morning.
He could however be Mafia, as he would know if Triforce Eden was Mafia or not, thus allowing him to say "Scum or not" (which in my mind, could lead some to believe he was a townie). However, from the way he voted and for what reasons he did so, I have concluded that he isn't Mafia due to the fact his voting is strategical enough. I believe the Mafia would aim for someone who has made some comments that have already attracted attention (and suspicion), or their posts can easily brought to attention (and once again, everyone's suspicion). Therefore, eliminating two more Townies (or the SK) out of play...which Zenox clearly isn't doing. Although, I've getting rather suspicious of you Zenox.
Next, this going on argument between Master Kokiri 9 and Atsuma is arousing suspicion, although, the majority of that suspicion is aimed at Atsuma. Master Kokiri 9 on an offensive more against Atsuma. Which rises some suspicion, but I believe the Mafia wouldn't be so bold about killing a townie, why would they need to be? But last round Master Kokiri 9 was a Seriel Killer and that tactic worked great for him as he survived for many rounds, so who says he is using it again as a Mafia?. And this attack is starting to punch holes through Atsuma's defense, such as him evading questions or not quite fully answering them IMO. I'll have to fully analyse both parties posts tomorrow as I am too tired to do so tonight, after all, it is 2:28 in the morning.
Master Kokiri 9
The Dungeon Master
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2009
- Location
- My ship that sailed in the morning
I know I'm late to defend myself, but I didn't vote at all during this day yet. And just clear things up, that bit about me being the person to vote for Eden with no rhyme or reason is a joke on our somewhat rivalry in this game.
Sorry guys, what I meant to say was that Zenox can not be a Serial Killer...I'm tired, which people will probably see as an excuse and find it suspicious...
Master Kokiri 9
The Dungeon Master
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2009
- Location
- My ship that sailed in the morning
Sorry guys, what I meant to say was that Zenox can not be a Serial Killer...I'm tired, which people will probably see as an excuse and find it suspicious...
Meh, your logic's still good and I don't see a reason to suspect you.
Ongoing arguement? Durion, where have you been? I haven't said much about Atsuma in a while.
I agree with this. It's true that I was the Serial Killer and that I had lasted pretty long (at least, for a Serial Killer), but really in all honesty, I wasn't "so bold about killing a Townie". Well at least, not in the later parts of the game when I was in it (I was thinking too much like a Mafia and I tried to frame Charge by killing Viral
) and, in all honesty, tried to find the Mafia.However, there's a chance I could be employing that tactic again as scum, be me the Serial Killer twice in a row or Mafia, but I'll let you guys make that choice.
Wasn't that what he was doing already? Anyways, I'm not sure you could call it so much an attack rather than an analysis with... interesting... results.
EBWODP
Err, not however, but I just meant I agree that I could be employing the tactic again.
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2008
- Location
- Chula Vista, San Diego, CA
To explain, why I said "Even if you aren't scum ..." was due to what happened last time, in case this is actually a mistake. Last time, Elfen was taken out due to his lack of thinking things through, and turned up on the townie side, so my voting was based on his facts having little solid ground, yet being so quick to do so as well as the serial killer attack on me last night, giving me reason to vote for him. Along with this, even if I was wrong, his debates don't seem intelligent enough to really help anyone out, explaining the last part of that.
Also, my FOS remain on those I said last time, but MK9, got my eye on you.
Also, my FOS remain on those I said last time, but MK9, got my eye on you.
Master Kokiri 9
The Dungeon Master
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2009
- Location
- My ship that sailed in the morning
EBWOTP Also, I just said I'd let you guys make the choice of whether or not I was scum because really, there's no way that I could manage to truly convince you guys with just mere words that I'm not scum.
I'm not going to jump on the Atsuma bandwagon just yet, due to the fact that from my quick read-through of the thread I haven't quite seen the factor that makes him so suspicious. There's a lot to go through, and I'll get around to that later tonight once this thread has calmed down a bit. I can't stand it when a thread grows while I'm reading it. :xd:
But, one thing that did catch my eye during my quick-read through (just a note to those who don't catch on; if something catches my eye when I'm skimming through something, it really stands out) was how aggressive zack125 while interrogating Atsuma. In the last game, zack125 was somewhat calm and rarely posted anything other than throw-away statements until the end, when the pressure was on. This time, he's on the setting from Day 2. I'm not saying that I suspect him too much, but it is a tad odd to me. Look at this, for example:
IGMEOY, Atsuma and zack125
But, one thing that did catch my eye during my quick-read through (just a note to those who don't catch on; if something catches my eye when I'm skimming through something, it really stands out) was how aggressive zack125 while interrogating Atsuma. In the last game, zack125 was somewhat calm and rarely posted anything other than throw-away statements until the end, when the pressure was on. This time, he's on the setting from Day 2. I'm not saying that I suspect him too much, but it is a tad odd to me. Look at this, for example:
Particularly with the repetition of the phrase "Even if you were busy", it seems like he's jumping down Atsuma's throat. A little bit overboard, to say the least. Also,
this is faulty logic. A great deal of people voted for Elfen because everyone else did. Or at least, they caught on because of it. I'm not going to support Atsuma too much, as that would make me look suspicious, but I just thought I'd point out some statements that looked unfair to me. As I said, I'll go through the thread later and examine Atsuma more closely. I'm a tad suspicious merely because everyone else seems so convince, but nothing solid yet. In conclusion,
IGMEOY, Atsuma and zack125
Master Kokiri 9
The Dungeon Master
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2009
- Location
- My ship that sailed in the morning
Read the post below this one and the EBWODP'd post above you. Just saying, it'd probably clear up any suspicions you may have on me.
Last game, I was part of the mafia, which means that I already knew who the other members were. That's why I didn't pressured anyone because I didn't see the point. All I did was defend myself, which turned out to be lucky because I didn't expected to stay that long.
Considering that last game was my first game, and what I also said in this topic: As players get more experienced their ability to spot and use deception increases. I just took it as an advantage.
As I tried to explain to Viral in the last game, English isn't my first language so I will make repetition errors and grammar mistakes. Not trying to make excuses, but that's what it is.
T
Triforce Eden
Guest
Zenox, the fact that you unvoted me right after the first suspicion leveled against you proves that you are just doing anything to get people to suspecting you. Not to mention the fact that you accused your accuser with even less evidence than what I had against you. Zenox is clearly scum. Also, in response to Master Kokiri saying he suspects me a bit, I direct you to this:
He clearly has a vendetta against me.
He clearly has a vendetta against me.
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2008
- Location
- Chula Vista, San Diego, CA
Well, whatever. If you want to make chaos, go ahead. It only proves that you are scum more and more as time goes on. If people start to catch on, I'll defend, but you're just trying to create a scene to get me killed. I'm going to ignore you for now.
T
Triforce Eden
Guest
The classic "Fine, do what you want" maneuver. In my experience, this is usually used by mafia members as a last ditch attempt to confuse their accuser. The fact that you are using this technique tells me you're mafia. However, I find it odd that you're using it when only one person has voted for you. Shame. You have confirmed my already strong suspicions.
- Status