I don’t town read anyone for calling out Kreaal on his idea because it’s such an easy and obvious thing to do, and perfectly sensible for scum to use it for town points.
I also dislike Ex’s suspicion that Kreaal made his suggestion as some kind of mafia plan. Any remotely decent scum would realize that such a proposal would almost certainly backfire, because if they could deduce the obvious benefits for scum, then of course others in the thread would as well, and suspect them for it. It seems like he’s using dubious reasoning to shoot for an easy target here, and his attempt to go after Kreaal for not providing meta seems potentially similar. So I’m inclined to scum read him, and I think there’s likely at least one scum among those suspecting Kreaal overall. By contrast, the reasoning behind Minish’s suspicion makes a lot more sense to me, and I’m inclined to town read her for it.
As for Kreaal, I think I’m town leaning him. His mistakes and lack of caution seem like reckless town behavior, and as I said, I doubt he would propose such a plan as scum, unless he hadn’t thought it through, as Minish said. I’m also inclined to town read his tunneling of Moe, although if there were anyone strong enough to justify tunneling as scum, it’d be him.
Are you sure about this lol