Scariest game i've played... Ballz for the megadrive (genesis)
What makes it scary ? I'll leave it to you guys to figure that out if you want to kill some time.
Dead Space 2 is just creepy as hell. I don't do anything in that game but play the predictable Multiplayer portion because single player is too scary for my tastes. I saw all the DS2 Death scenes and I don't want that happening on my TV screen.
RE4 for me as well, i remember playing it at night with all the lights closed. I nearly pissed myself the first time i encountered the chainsaw guy hahahah
Well I WISH that I could say Amnesia. However, it bugs out whenever I try to play it on my PC so I'll just have to wait on that one. I guess I'd have to say Resident Evil 4, like many of you. Great game, that.