- Joined
- Feb 17, 2015
I seriously doubt there's any type of third party at this point. We'd know by now of the existence of a cult, and there's been no indication whatsoever that there's something akin to a Serial Killer.
Frozen Chosen: Claimed VT early, and there's no real reason to doubt it. He did it solely as a means to attempt to hunt scum (Johnny being the suspect), which has made the claim solid to me the entire game. Also very little scummy activity at all.
ErenTheGenderfluidTitan: I've believed the claim since Jamie specifically indicated he was my own counterpart (ie the same role, being that of a normal armyman). Jamie's out-of-nowhere spat with Soul earlier in the game perked my interest in the both of them, but I think it's more likely that Soul was playing a Town Leader game as mafia rather than Jamie coincidentally fake-claiming as my counterpart (if anyone else is my counterpart, a normal armyman, I'd like to hear it).
Johnny Sooshi: I never really bought that HeroOfTime was scum just because he gave off such typical newbie vibes. His spat with Viral earlier in the game is also a sign that he's not affiliated with them, as I doubt Viral would have allowed Hero to bring it up in the first place as a ruse.
Malon: Pretty much the last remaining player I don't know what to think of, solely due to Zelda15's severe lack of posting the entire game. Malon himself has also demonstrated the same meta as when he was town - just going with the flow and voting on popular wagons for no real reason. Leads me to believe he's probably once again town, perhaps our last VT? (Would be nice if you could give us a hint, @Malon )
A Link in Time: If I had to put money on someone being our last mafia member, I'd say it's him, for three main reasons. The first being that incredibly scummy plea to be investigated when it was painfully obvious that Tristan wouldn't get the opportunity. The second being that he failed to even soft claim yesterday. This is critical because 1.) No one had even soft claimed that day, giving him ample opportunity and with reason to do so because he was on the hot seat all day yesterday, and 2.) A true claim of some important power role (perhaps our other Vigilante?) would have put pressure on the mafia to pick their poison and perhaps give us another day with Tristan and his results. My asking him if he had a real reason for me to not vote for him was an attempt to put either of two points to fruition, which he failed to do on both counts.
He got lucky yesterday that Toxic dug his own grave by being silent, but I see no reason not to axe him off today.
Cthulhu: I've had an eye on Soul the entire game because his playstyle has been very reminiscent of other players I've known that pull off Town Leader styles very well. The guy played hardcore town the entire game, and I've just grown to have an aversion to that kind of player. The real thing that set me off was his extreme fixation with my not fully believing Kokirion's claim initially, something that irked me because I was the one that pointed out and made sense of the claim to him in the first place. If ALIT isn't mafia, I really don't have much of a lead other than him afterward. It's a long shot though, and I can't even say I'm that confident in this hypothesis.
Vote: A Link in Time
Hmm I like the points you make. I'm just hesitant to automatically go to ALIT lynch.
We are missing the counterpart of Johnny Sooshi VT. So perhaps ALIT is that role. However, the one thing that worries me is that Vergo's role is not really confirmed. He claims that Jamie indicated they both are of the same character, but I don't necessarily see that. I saw your soft claim and everything, but whose to say you are not Johnny's counterpart?
If all the claims of VT are true, then there should be two red vanilla townies and one blue, excluding me. One of the red is Johnny's counter part.
Vergo and Eren, if I may ask, what are the colors of your roles?