Game Thread Square Enix Mafia

[Libk]

I'll
Vote: Neon

I'm not buying this belief you have of mirrored roles. I think this is scrambling

 

[Ragnarokio]

Yeah no.

vote: Libk

as scum libk could just as easily lie and make up a role (like doctor) that couldn't be confirmed and say he did target someone n1 and 2, so this isn't really AI.

 

[Princess Abigail]

Do you disagree that giving up one of your shots to confirm yourself as town would be worth it?

Yes.

Do you disagree that targeting mikey wouldn't have resulted in a town ability being blocked?

No

 

[Princess Abigail]

I'll
Vote: Neon

I'm not buying this belief you have of mirrored roles. I think this is scrambling

I've played many games with mirrors and it's rarely town mirroring town.

This set up is insanely town sided wolves having a JOAT with an extra kill would be highly intelligent game design.

 

[Princess Abigail]

as scum libk could just as easily lie and make up a role (like doctor) that couldn't be confirmed and say he did target someone n1 and 2, so this isn't really AI.

Sure but I see numerous reasons why making up a role is more detrimental than using the one provided to you.

It is very easy to tell truths intermixed with lies to convince town its much harder to just lie and lie some more

 

[Princess Abigail]

Anyways I'm going to bed. I think I need to die before mylo so I'm okay if you lim me today but please remember what I've said in mylo

 

[Ragnarokio]

No

If you weren't thinking of mikey's role as being passive i don't see why you would have asked me this

Why target a miller with your ability?

And for clarity's sake for everyone else, its obvious enough and i suspect neon is scum so the mafia should already know anyway, but I'm a motivator.

 

[Libk]

This set up is insanely town sided wolves having a JOAT with an extra kill would be highly intelligent game design.

It's neat that you believe my second ability is a kill. It's not

 

[Princess Abigail]

If you weren't thinking of mikey's role as being passive i don't see why you would have asked me this



And for clarity's sake for everyone else, its obvious enough and i suspect neon is scum so the mafia should already know anyway, but I'm a motivator.

I do think Mikey has a passive role I do think targeting Mikey would have cleared me probably I don't think it was optimal in any way.

 

[Princess Abigail]

It's neat that you believe my second ability is a kill. It's not

Than your not a JOAT lol

 

[Princess Abigail]

I legit don't see a world where my role makes sense as mafia.

And I think I'm only being wolfread because of an ability that doesn't exclusively point to me

I still think I probably need to die today though.

I do want to know something did Ex ever explicitly confirm Mins action?

Because otherwise I could see a world where Min is wolf. Complaining about being RBd on 1 and 3 while using the dead who can't verify an action on 2

In fact unless another RB comes forward it is possible that she didn't even get blocked on 3 since I know I didn't block her

 

[Princess Abigail]

Unless there's a bus driver

 

[Ragnarokio]

ah i see i read your answers backwards, my mistake

 

[Ragnarokio]

I legit don't see a world where my role makes sense as mafia.

kind of irrelevant because we don't know for sure what your role is. Jailer is a pretty common fakeclaim for mafia roleblocker, although the fact that you weren't familiar with the role makes that less likely.

 

[Ragnarokio]

I could probably be convinced to lynch outside neon, especially with additional input from mikey, and additional analysis of his claims.

Her recollection of her experience this game matches up with her being a jailer for the most part.

I find it odd that she both felt convinced she would be lynched if she claimed but also felt convinced that using her role on N2 was bad as town. Normally someone who thought it was a bad play should believe that other people will tend to agree with them, assuming they think of both themselves and others as generally rational people.

I also find it strange that she implies that she gave numbers expressing why a roleblocker wouldn't target on n2 as a reason for not breadcrumbing having targeted minish n1, when she had ample opportunity to express that before numbers did. It seems to me like a town roleblocker who blocked someone n1 and then had that person complain about it should have reacted in some way, but it seemed like neon just completely ignored the roleblocker discussion.

Its not unusual for a couple things to not fit when a person is thinking back about how they felt earlier in the game though, because people aren't good at remembering things chronologically.

For the time being, neon still seems like the strongest lynch to me by a decent margin.