I think that the first one is pretty weak. The testimonials are pretty vague and don't actually say anything about the game. People saying that the game is outstanding, beautiful, or colorful really tells the viewer nothing, and these adjectives could be used to describe any game.
While I don't love the second one, it is definitely much better. They chose testimonials that talked about the motion controls, a major part of this game, or gave more powerful praise. For instance, "This game alone is a reason to go out and become a Wii owner," is much more convincing than "This was my first Zelda game; it was outstanding."
