Libk
Spaceballs: The Mafia Player
That's reasoning enough to me
Vote: Doc
Vote: Doc
Skyward Sword Mafia
- Thread starter Pen
- Start date
- Status
Go_Dark_Link
If there ever was one
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2011
Yes, I agree, whoever Link is should probably speak up.
If I had to guess, I would say the green clad boy isn't actually looking for a specific character. He probably didn't go after anyone on the first night, then went after Blackkirby on the second night. When the kill didn't go through, he must have found it odd, probably thought it was the job of a roleblocker. He must have decided to go after Blackkirby again because something felt off, and there was a chance that the roleblocker would change targets. When the kill failed again, and theories of the jailer began popping up, the green clad boy must have agreed. The jailer and he must have likely been going after the same person, so when someone suggested that the jailer go for someone else since mafia kills weren't going through and their target had probably been mafia so the green clad boy could kill him, the boy must have thought that was a good plan. He was suspicious of Blackkirby as it was, and there was a final chance it would work. When the kill didn't go through again, the green clad boy realized that rather than outside intervention, his target must either be hiding, or be nightkill proof (which didn't assuage his suspicions as GF=no nightkill) but he realized he was wasting his abilities and costing the town an advantage, so he must have decided to go for someone else. Seeing as Frozen had turned out to be town, then his natural choice must have been Doc.
The green clad boy probably did go after Doc, who was protected by Mellow. However, since the green clad boy probably isn't only able to kill a specific target he had been looking for, and the previous nights were simply elements of chance, he probably can't 100% confirm that Doc is or isn't town, only that he did in fact go after him last night.
Of course that is all just speculation. As for my own thoughts, I am currently suspicious of Doc, Blackkirby, and Eduarda.
Doc- same reason as everyone else. Third member of the neighborhood, so prolly evil.
Blackkirby- this is entirely based on the the green clad boy's actions. I am thinking he is either the godfather or another nightkill-proof role.
Eduarda- ever since her day one actions, Heroine always struck me as a tad bit suspicious, unvoting Dekunut and all. Then, it made sense to me that if there was no jailer roleblocking the mafia, then the reason for their lack of kills had to be inactivity, and Heroine fit that role. Then, I am trying to figure out why the mafia would possibly go after musicfan. They know that he already used his role earlier in the game, everyone was aware of it. It would make more sense to go after Mellow, who made hints at being able to save the doctor role, or someone else on the chance that they might hit the vig. Why musicfan? My thought is either they just wanted to get rid of an almost confirmed town, or they weren't fully aware that musicfan had already used up his role. The only way I can see this happening is if the mafia is someone who wasn't present for earlier day actions, hence Eduarda.
tl;dr:
Here is my current list:
Likely Town
Mellow
Linkdude74
Batman
Sadia
Suspicious
Doc
Blackkirby
Eduarda
Overall, I'm not sure about Doc. I get a feeling that he isn't good, but after yesterday's failure over Frozen, I'm a bit more hesitant. Still, I think it is our best bet, so I'm going to
Vote: Doc
However, I advise that no one hammer yet. I want to hear what he has to say.
Doc
BoDoc Horseman
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2012
- Gender
- Male
Well, it seems like I will most likely be lynched today. I don't see a way to save myself, I have absolutely no way to defend.
I'm not scum, I wish I could help you believe me. I am worried that through lynching me the town will lose a vote that is trying to help them win and secure the mafia's win.
As for Mezlo's reason for voting me, I don't believe that Link is a cop-vig however you all described it. A role like that sounds a bit OP, but I don't know. I may role claim later in the day if the vig doesn't (I'd much rather hear from them to see if they can clarify how their role works).
As of right now, the only evidence against me is that I am a member of the Neighborhood. Which time and time again, I have said I believe to be random. Frozen' character should show that. Gaepora and Fledge have a very thin connection to one another in SS, and, unless I'm mistaken, are never shown to even interact.
As for my vote, I will place it on
Vote Eduarda
I said before that Heroine narrowly surviving a lynch was suspicious. Scum want to jump on easy lynches, which Heroine would have been. The only reason that scum wouldn't secure Heroine's lynch, in my opinion, is because she was their scumbud. That's the only explanation I can think of at this point. Especially when they are so close to winning, letting a day go by with a no lynch doesn't make sense to me.
I'm not scum, I wish I could help you believe me. I am worried that through lynching me the town will lose a vote that is trying to help them win and secure the mafia's win.
As for Mezlo's reason for voting me, I don't believe that Link is a cop-vig however you all described it. A role like that sounds a bit OP, but I don't know. I may role claim later in the day if the vig doesn't (I'd much rather hear from them to see if they can clarify how their role works).
As of right now, the only evidence against me is that I am a member of the Neighborhood. Which time and time again, I have said I believe to be random. Frozen' character should show that. Gaepora and Fledge have a very thin connection to one another in SS, and, unless I'm mistaken, are never shown to even interact.
As for my vote, I will place it on
Vote Eduarda
I said before that Heroine narrowly surviving a lynch was suspicious. Scum want to jump on easy lynches, which Heroine would have been. The only reason that scum wouldn't secure Heroine's lynch, in my opinion, is because she was their scumbud. That's the only explanation I can think of at this point. Especially when they are so close to winning, letting a day go by with a no lynch doesn't make sense to me.
Batman
Not all those who wander are lost...
@Go_Dark_Link Why do you think the green clad boy kept going after blackkirby? Maybe I missed something.
Batman
Not all those who wander are lost...
Also, I will hammer Doc if he has nothing else to say.
Eduarda
Srishti is annie is eduarda right?
I guess I should defend myself? Well, I can't really. I can't speak for Heroine of Time's actions. And I know that doesn't mean her actions should be overlooked. But I can defend the part against me.
I knew that musicfan used his role, already. In my first actual post in the game, I put musicfan on the list of confirmed townies. Because I knew he used his role, and ended up killing a Mafia member.
I'm not sure as to why musicfan was killed, too. I think confirmed townie is the best answer but if the game still continues tomorrow, I'd like to look at musicfan's posts and see if I can catch another reason. Maybe the mafia found him as a threat?
Eduarda
Srishti is annie is eduarda right?
Mellow Ezlo
Spoony Bard
The problem I have with GDL's theory is that Pendio is known for his flavour, and there is absolutely nothing in the flavour for Link's actions that suggests roleblocks or protections or anything. It specifically states in all night scenes, and I'll quote them for proof, that he couldn't find his targets, which would mean that he is in fact looking for a specific person and was unable to find them. If he was roleblocked, we'd know. Look at the latest night scene; Pendio made it extremely obvious that he was protected, and that he had actually found his target.
I know it's not the most concrete evidence, but it's something, and lynches, whether on town or scum, mean everything. Doc flips town, we have one more confirmed townie and the scum list is narrowed down. Doc's mafia, then fantastic! Even if it's at the expense of losing a townie, lynches give us information, and this information could be vital.
Look at the player count. There are still 8 players left, 2 of which are most likely scum. If Doc is mafia, that leaves us with 6 townies and 1 scum. If Doc is town, that leaves us with 5 townies and 2 scum, or 4 townies and 2 scum going into the next day. In either case, the mafia is still outnumbered, and the lower the numbers, the easier it is to find scum.
I know it's not the most concrete evidence, but it's something, and lynches, whether on town or scum, mean everything. Doc flips town, we have one more confirmed townie and the scum list is narrowed down. Doc's mafia, then fantastic! Even if it's at the expense of losing a townie, lynches give us information, and this information could be vital.
Look at the player count. There are still 8 players left, 2 of which are most likely scum. If Doc is mafia, that leaves us with 6 townies and 1 scum. If Doc is town, that leaves us with 5 townies and 2 scum, or 4 townies and 2 scum going into the next day. In either case, the mafia is still outnumbered, and the lower the numbers, the easier it is to find scum.
Mellow Ezlo
Spoony Bard
The first he, of course, being Doc. The second he is Link. Don't pronoun on a lack of sleep kids. :cooky:
Doc
BoDoc Horseman
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2012
- Gender
- Male
I am worried that there is more than just two scum left, but possibly three. The remaining two bosses and Demise. With that in mind, lynching me today will end with 7 people. Plus tonight's kill, tomorrow we will have six. This could very well be lylo and I am worried that we may be rushing to a lynch. It might seem like I'm saying that just to save my bacon, but considering there is already a possible hammer and we're not very far into the day, there isn't nearly enough discussion.
Doc
BoDoc Horseman
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2012
- Gender
- Male
My claim would do me no good, really. Perhaps it will help dissuade some people but if I can't be trusted, it won't help. I'll probably claim soon though if the vig doesn't do so first. It looks like a big part of the suspicion against me is the fact that the green clad hero attacked me last night. Knowing that my character would never be Link's target, I assume that there is a different reason that Link couldn't find his targets the previous nights. The vig can hopefully provide a bit of insight on why those kills didn't go through or something.
Batman
Not all those who wander are lost...
Eduarda
Srishti is annie is eduarda right?
@Sadia
@Blackkirby
Can you two make at least one post on this situation.
If none of these two claim Vig, then that means that the Vig agrees on this lynch. Everyone else has posted at least once today.
@Blackkirby
Can you two make at least one post on this situation.
If none of these two claim Vig, then that means that the Vig agrees on this lynch. Everyone else has posted at least once today.
Eduarda
Srishti is annie is eduarda right?
Vig, only claim if you disagree with Doc being lynched. I think that would be a fair middle ground?
- Status