Scrubs Mafia: My First Scum Hunt

[Sadia]

I recall having at the very least 6 mafia in a game a long time ago, and I have played with poisoners.

So were they town - alligned or third - party?

 

[A Link In Time]

I cast my vote upon thee because you are one of the three

Yet in Pirate's mafia, I wasn't afraid to kill one of my own.

On a side note, I don't understand JC's vote on Xyphon. Explanation maybe?

 

[Justac00lguy]

My vote was half joke/half suspicion, I was mainly playing off his wording but from past posts in Day 2 and Day 3 I still have genuine reasons to vote.

 

[Raindrop14]

So were they town - alligned or third - party?

They were third party. Although I think a poisoner can be town aligned too (I think possibly any TP role can be town aside from Serial Killer).

 

[Pen]

oh and this

"making the lynch a wee bit easier." unnerves me.

How so?

 

[Keyshe]

Would I be lying if I said I didn't see that coming?

Yes?

Well ****.

I still rocked this game hard.

If you lose this town, I will personally berate and call every one of you girls names for as long as you exist on this forum.

****ing Carol!

You still killed the cop... if you hadn't done that you could have called a perfect game.

 

[Josh]

Cop still came back for one day - so just barely less than perfect

 

[Sydney]

Erm, I still wanna hear more from ALIT: who do you think is the most suspicious? Assuming there are 1-2 more mafiaso left, who do you think they are? Why?

So, JC, did your JoAT role extend to poison, thus you killed Annie? Or was that you acting as Vig? :?

Eh, Xy, who do are you suspicious about?

Go_Skyward, why so suspicious of ALIT and HoT? You didn't really justify why you wanted to vote for either of them. :I

Luna, thoughts on the poisoner situation?

I think Heroine is a viable suspect. She's barely active in this game, and barely votes. She did the same thing in BM7 and MBM, where she was Mafia in both. She's worth looking into...

 

[Raindrop14]

I'm not entirely sure right now. My main suspicion was Pancake but now he's gone.

Don't give me that, what the heck is this then?

Lynch me, NK me, whatever, but remember this statement folks:
If I die and you realize I'm town, lynch Raindrop. Definite scum.

Vote: Rainy

That's called planting seeds.

That's called playing dumb when a mafia forgets what he's said before.

Vote: Xyphon

 

[Sydney]

Guess who didn't turn out townie. :yes:

Sounds like you have the whole thing planned out, lmfao.

 

[CynicalSquid]

Guess who didn't turn out townie. :yes:

Oh

Um...

Hold on, I got this...

Reggie Fils-Aime?

 

[Sydney]

No, I don't. But I said several times if pancake is townie, Rainy is mafia. Pancake was mafia. So I still don't know on Rainy.

Really? 'Cuz you seemed pretty confident...

 

[Raindrop14]

My suspicions of you have dissipated as I expressed previously, in case you didn't see me say it several times, IF PANCAKE TURNS OUT TOWNIE, RAINY IS SCUM. I said previously that I took back my definite scum claim and changed it to if Pancake is townie, and I stuck with that and said it several times.

Just a note on how to play well in mafia, refer to your post where you said things instead of saying you said them; it provides a better back up to your statement. :yes:

By the way, why would I be scum if Pan was town? There were plenty of others who voted for Pan, why just me?

My vote stands.

 

[Justac00lguy]

So, JC, did your JoAT role extend to poison, thus you killed Annie?

Mebby

So my vote stays on Xyphon, I think this game now needs to be more aggressive, try and pick of our suspicions and narrow it down. I'm still searching through the thread trying to pick out who I think could be Mafia, based on what we know now.

 

[Sydney]

About what? Pancake being mafia? I thought he was. If you mean Rainy being scum, that was ONE post. I implore you to look at my following posts and look what I said differently. If you want to call me scum for one post, go ahead :yes:

I just feel that this is rather strange.

Keyshe - 7 (justac00lguy, Xyphon, Raindrop14, Pendio, Heroine of Time, Atticus, Pancake Samurai)

Scum lies among here, and it's not just Pancake. Just so everyone knows, my softclaim has been proven by Josh's death. Pendio, Rainy, Xy, or HoT are the possible remaining mafiaso.

I'm thinking Rainy and Xy. :T