To give a little update on my "progress", I've been playing Fantasy Life a lot and my initial enthusiasm has gone down a bit. I still like the game, but I honestly find the story mode atrocious. Characters talk way too long about things I mostly didn't find particularly interesting, though humourus at times. I've gotten all four Goddess Treasures so I reckon I'm pretty far into the game and I have yet to find an antagonist. Everytime someone interesting popped up, they turned out to be friendly after all. Every story arc so far basically ended in "Oh, they were suspicious at first but they're good people after all! How lovely!" I don't mind lightheartedness, but this game is really lacking in the drama department so far. Not to mention that anything story based wasn't challenging at all. You get that ominous scene when you venture into Elderwood Forest for the final treasure, with the Spirit warning you not to enter and then... you fight two wolves and the rest are basically cutscenes.
I also find the lack of depth disappointing. I've got tons of consumables, but the more interesting ones with temporary effects don't seem to last long enough to be useful, and I honestly find it hard to even remember what most of them do. I found myself just eating a random piece of food hoping it would boost a relevant stat when I was having trouble in a fight because the pouch doesn't tell you what things do, and it would be really tedious to go into the item menu and find the item I want to use in the huge pile of stuff I have everytime.
During my playtime I've had so many ideas for useful items and yet I see none of them. Instead, there seem to be a ton of things that have pretty much the same effect with small variations. There's endless wasted potential in this game, but I'm not really sure it's going to be used up.
Why am I posting this? Oh, first of all, I had to rant for a bit because I really want to love this game - I love the concept, the style, some of the music. The other reason is that, out of the huge pile of stuff you guys recommended me so far, I was wondering wether based on the rant above, you could recommend me something more to my liking. Much appreciated.