Rate the Siggy!

[Fraxinus]

A pet peeve of mine is when someone just does the *same score here* just so they can get their signature re-rated without writing a nice critique for someone, so I am not going to do such...

I do like the brushes on the Big Octo banner, however, they don't use any special effects and are randomly placed on a plain background. Black dropshadows against white kind of end up giving off a bland grey color as well, so I'm not too pleased with the text either. Not that it's not a good signature--it's nice, but just isn't the best. The cookie one, I think I already mentioned how bad the antialiasing is, so yeah... Maybe a 5/10 on this re-rate.

*risked getting ninja'd* o.o

 

[Nicole]

7.5/10

I don't know who the render is of, but I like the way the effects blend. The basic idea of it is neat. I think the text says "Ichigo"(?), but it's a little hard to read. Pretty nice overall.

 

[surferguy7]

7/10

Nice effects, anime gifs are good, but the text is a bit hard to see.

 

[Myriadviper42]

6/10
Have I seen that before. I think someone else had a siggy similar to that.

 

[PK Love Omega]

7/10

Pretty cool, but a a bit complicated.

 

[Big Octo]

5/10 You need some new banners, the old ones were pretty good.

 

[Dr3W21]

Cookie=10/10
Sig pic=8.6/10
Other text and stuff=7/10
Overall score=8.3/10

 

[Big Octo]

8/10 Dude you changed everything.

 

[Dr3W21]

...
Same rating as the last post.

EDIT: Just added a shadow to make the R look less choppy.

 

[*M i d n a*]

Hm, not bad, is that 3 from Halo? Meh, who cares? It looks good. 8/10

 

[Big Octo]

Same rate. Keep it classy, Asty! (Hey, that rhymed.)

 

[*M i d n a*]

Haha, sure did. The cookie stands out more, 9/10

 

[Hero of Time]

9/10 Great siggy. Tetra <3 lol

 

[*M i d n a*]

I <3 Tetra! And yours looks cool and funny, 8/10

 

[molgera2]

sweet tetra pic backgrounds goodbut dont fit togther to well