Post Your Zelda Scores

[Skywaker]

LoZ: 9.5/10
LA: 9/10
MM: 10/10
FSA: 8/10
TP: 9/10
PH: 8/10
ST: 10/10
SS: 9/10

These are only the games I have 100% completed. I'm still playing AoL, MC, and OoT so I have no results for those yet. There are also some games like the Oracles, WW, ALttP, etc. that I don't own so I don't have scores for those either.

But as you can see my scores for each game I've listed are ranged from 8-10...

 

[You-Know-Who]

LoZ: 5 - Good at first, but then too hard
AoL: 3 - cant beat the 1st dungeon, ARGHHH
ALttP: ... haven't played yet
LA: ... havent played yet
OoT: 8 - very nice
MM: 9 - love the sidequest
OoX: ... havent played yet
FS: 6 - not he best, but i could still beat it
WW: 9 - very memorable, plus boat ride is AWESOME!!! Y U hate (boat ride) so much?!?!?!
FSA: 7 - very good, but coul be better
MC: 9 - best hand-held evar!!! Should have more stuff
TP: 10 - amazing, best game ever until SS. Cant see y ppl hate
PH: 8 - good, i love to play again
ST: 8 - same a PH
SS: FABULOOOUUSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Vanessa28]

TP 9/10
OoT 9/10
WW 8/10
SS 8/10
PH 6/10
ST 5/10
FSA 5/10

 

[Garo]

I don't like the X/10 system, since I prefer to use a 4-star system that measures qualitatively rather than quantitatively, but if I must...

The Legend of Zelda: 6/10
The Adventure of Link: 5/10
A Link to the Past: 6/10
Ocarina of Time: 8/10
Majora's Mask: 10/10
Oracle of Ages/Seasons: 6/10
The Wind Waker: 8/10
The Minish Cap: 7/10
Four Swords: 4/10
Four Swords Adventures: 5/10
Twilight Princess: 7/10
Phantom Hourglass: 5/10
Spirit Tracks: 6/10
Skyward Sword: 7/10

 

[PhantomTriforce]

The Legend of Zelda: 5/10
Adventure of Link: 4/10
A Link to the Past: 10/10
Link's Awakening: 6/10
Ocarina of Time: 9/10
Majora's Mask: 7/10
Oracle of Seasons: 9/10
Oracle of Ages: 10/10
The Wind Waker: 7/10
The Minish Cap: 7/10
Twilight Princess: 10/10
Phantom Hourglass: 7/10
Spirit Tracks: 6/10
Skyward Sword: 8/10

 

[Majora's Cat]

I find it hard to believe that everyone here has played all of the Zelda games and have give scores according to those personal experiences. So I'm going to keep it real and stick with what I know:

LoZ: 9/10
AoL: 8.5/10
ALttP: 9.5/10
OoT: 9.75/10
MM: 9.75/10
TWW: 9.5/10
TP: <3/10
SS: 9.5/10

 

[JuicieJ]

I don't like the X/10 system, since I prefer to use a 4-star system that measures qualitatively rather than quantitatively, but if I must...

How does a 10 scale system not judge quality?

 

[Sydney]

OoT: 10/10
MM: 10/10
SS: 8.5/10
PH: 8/10
ST: 7.5/10
TP: 7/10
WoG: 100/10

Don't like, don't look. :/

 

[Wolf Sage]

LoZ: N/A
AoL: N/A
ALttP: 9/10
LA: 9/10
OoT: 10/10
MM: 10/10
TWW: 9/10
TMC: N/A
TP: 9_9/10
PH: N/A
ST: N/A
SS: 10/10

I rounded most of the above scores to the nearest ten... SS, OoT, and MM were perfect tens in my book...

 

[Batman]

The Legend of Zelda 7/10

Zelda II: The Adventure of Link 7/10

A Link to the Past 10/10

Link's Awakening 8/10

Ocarina of Time 11/10

Majora's Mask 10/10

Oracle of Seasons 6/10

Oracle of Ages 7/10

Four Swords 6/10

The Wind Waker 10/10

Four Swords Adventures 7/10

The Minish Cap 8/10

Twilight Princess 10/10

Phantom Hourglass 7/10

Spirit Tracks 6.9/10

Skyward Sword 11/10

 

[JamesBond007]

TLoZ - 3/10 (BS Zelda 4/10)
TAoL - 2/10
ALttP - 8/10
AST - 7/10
LA - 8/10
OoT - 10/10
MM - 7/10
OoS - 8/10
OoA - 7/10
FS - 5/10 (Anniversary Edition)
TWW - 9/10
FSA - 7/10
TMC - 6/10 (European version 1/10)
TP - 9/10 (Wii version)
SS - 10/10

PH and ST not rated yet.

 

[KawiNinjaZX]

Since I have been playing since they came out I will rate based on how great they were at the time of their release:
LoZ 9.5
AoL 8
ALttP 9.5
LA 9
OoT 10
MM 9.5
Oracle games 9
Minish Cap 9.5
Wind Waker 9
Twilight Princess 8.5
Skyward Sword 9.9999999

Have not finished spirit tracks but it would probably be 8.5 for a Zelda game.

 

[Ouroboros]

I haven't beaten LoZ, Zelda II, LA, the Oracle games or Four Swords.. Sounds bad now that I write it.

aLttP: 8/10 - Great
OoT: 10/10 - Masterpiece
MM: 10/10 - Masterpiece
WW: 10/10 - Masterpiece
MC: 8.5/10 - Great
TP: 6.5/10 - Good
PH: 8/10 - Great
ST: 9/10 - Excellent
SS: 10/10 - Masterpiece

 

[Krazy4Krash]

For the sake of simplicity and to limit actual thought, rounded off the to closest .5 score.

LOZ - 7/10
AOL - 6.5/10
LTTP - 9/10
LA - 6/10
OOT - 9.5/10
MM - 8.5/10
OOS - 5.5/10
OOA - 5.5/10
WW - 8/10
FS - 6.5/10
(Never played FSA)
MC - 7/10
TP - 9.5/10
PH - 6.5/10
ST - 8/10
SS - 9/10

 

[boyrobot22]

LoZ-9/10
AoL-7/10 (I didn't like the side-scrolling)
LA-10/10
OoT-Ultimate Awesomeness
MM-Ultimate Awesomeness
PH-3/10 (It was bland, uninteresting, and a total copy of WW. Fail, Nintendo)
WW-10/10 (However, WW was totally awesome)
TP-8/10 (It was great and all, but the bosses weren't all that, and Zant was just creepy...)
MC-9/10 (A really good game, even if it was really short)
This is my list.