Ok, I really do think it's Mido.
1) We know the mafia has been active enough to kill every night. Mark hasn't been active at all since his one post here, unless he's communicating his kills through other means. Anyway, I really don't think Sadia is the remaining scum. Also welcome to the game Sadia. Your input would be appreciated as soon as you can read though and tell us what you think.
2) While Doc, Frozen, and music are a little suspicious (everyone is to me, the only person I was sure about was Pendio), they have both been very active in the game, voting to walk, acting on their own accord. I'm not especially suspicious of them. If I had to choose between the three, it would be tough. On a whim, I would choose Frozen I suppose. HOWEVER, all three have actively been voting in this game, and to me, votes are solid evidence. Mafia has to be afraid of voting because they might get some heat when they vote to lynch a town member, which leads me to this-
3) Mido has only made one vote this whole game
That's quite the list, Johnny, and I thank you for posting that! If anything, I think your findings for the most part coincide with Kiddrangon's ideas. In that regard, we may be in a good position. I just have a quick question about the silver planeswalkers. I may be misreading your post, but are Karn and Ugin the only silver ones, and does the five-colored aspect to the silver planeswalkers apply per individual, or the the collective silver walkers as a whole? Also, with JC mentioning Thar's death in conjunction with the plane, I wonder if that also had any effect on GDL's revival? If so, this plane is probably not in our best interest to stay in anymore. Now, as for GDL's livelihood, I'm all for hearing him out, but I still think he's our best bet for today based on our knowledge at this time.
Vote: Go_Dark_Link
Vote: Walk
I remember seeing the post on that, but what concerns me is that Kiddrangon mentioned how red and black planeswalkers ranked in the upper echelon in terms of chances of being Mafia. GDL turned out Red/black if I recall right.
and that was a vote on what was likely a mafia in the first place come back to life. It was a very obvious lynch. Otherwise, unless someone can point something out that I missed, all he has done all game was pepper the thread with repeats of what other people were saying. He might've given a few suspicions, but it was never a vote or anything, nothing really concrete that we could use against him later.
I know I lead the lynch on Justa yesterday, and I'm sorry for that. It was a toss up between Justa, Blackkirby, and Mido for me yesterday (I'm not including Pendio because I was giving him the benefit of the doubt and I knew who he was at very least), I only went with Justa because he is usually more active and helpful in the game as opposed to the other two. The difference in behavior make me think he might be scum.
Anyway, I just got home from work, and have a bit of a headache from looking for all of Mido's posts. I want to come back tomorrow with all the vote tally's as evidence, but I just can't bring myself to dig through the whole thread again.
