I can actually see where Panda's getting at. If the mafia is filled with inexperienced players, it is only likely that they will get rid of all the skilled players, or at least try to, first. By doing that, they can last longer in the game and won't have much to worry about with the other players. Or at least I see it that way.
That's some good logic, I'll admit, but allow me to give you the perspective from a Mafioso in a previous game. You see, I was a bit of a newb (but a semi experienced one at that) in that particular game and I had an experienced Godfather (or rather, Godmother in that particular case). She suggested we kill off one of the experienced players and I went along with it. Not because I was a newb or anything, but rather because it made sense because it was only a matter of time before the skilled players figured us out, not to mention it wouldn't directly make either of us look suspicious.
Anyways, just pointing that out, feel free to say I'm wrong and ignore me. XD
Wait, what? Wasn't OrlovYan killed by the Vigilante? At any rate, I'm not seeing how Axle's death points towards the Mafia being mostly inexperienced. I think even an experienced Mafia would want an experienced townie dead, right?
Took the words right outta my mouth. But I gave an example from a past game.
Anyways, I think I'll just ask this question to everybody: who do you think is the most scummy so far?
As for me, I don't really know who seems most scummy. Everybody seems to be on an equal level of scumminess to me.
