Slight suspicions about her saying roles and names aren’t related. Not too abrupt about it though and seems technically for the most part true since the roles aren’t thinned enough and relation isn’t clear enough yet for us to make any realistic guesses, but eventually I feel we might be able to make some deductive reasoning (the question I have is how murdering roles will look when dead; aren’t some roles like innocent child just inherently town or mafia?). 6/9 not a lot to go off of.
I didn't say they weren't related. I said something like it not being productive to discuss or something like that? I do think they are related, but the reason I said that is that like with mine it makes sense with my name but also you all likely would have never guessed it. So I figured that was likely the case with most roles so I felt discussing it was probably distracting us from more pertinent topics.
Animaeus, I had a spur-of-the-moment thought of who you could be, even though there's no way that's you. How long does it take you to paint a fence?
I really don't think they're who you think they are. I would be very, very shocked if they were.
I don't, should I feel bad
I mean, I see something they did in that post. Not sure if it was intentional or not. But it makes me think of one person but I have no clue if it's them because I remember absolutely nothing about how they played.
I feel a bit less dumb now, but still pretty dumb.
I can't quite figure out who you are but for some reason I'm really liking you. Not in a town read sense. I just like your posts.
why are we townreading 10? I think I missed some logical point here
I don't think 12 is scum tho, I feel like scum tied two leading town wagons to reduce the chances of them getting lynched or expecting someone would tiebreak it
which makes me slightly scumread Ballin', Deflective, and Fashionable for now
10 is being tentatively townread for trying to save a townie when alignments don't flip. If they are scum then them voting 12 was a weird move. I mean 10 could be scum and 4 and 12 town and it was all for ****s and giggles but that's not the more simple explanation.
What changed your mind on 12? You were voting them d1.
So, since you never answered me earlier, essentially your argument for suspecting me is that I was voting for a townie at the end of the wagon? How do you feel about people who took no position at all?
I answered your previous post in the above post so some explanation is there. I also realized that the reason I feel off about you is I think due to the fact that your posts sound logical almost to the point knowing more about the gamestate - a mafia perspective. It's like you know what to say. Also ngl, your name has me paranoid that you're a godfather type role.
I haven't placed as much focus on those off wagons because it's harder to read into their motives since they didn't take a stance. I think it's unlikely that all scum didn't vote, and in a game with no alignment flips they can be bolder about controlling things. I did point out a post from 11 that is giving me bad vibes though. Starting to reconsider them and may add them to PoE.
So we're going to just believe that Gumball the High is telling the truth? When flips don't give us any info, it is safer for mafia to pull off potentially risky moves, meaning it is much harder to
It's fair to question my claim. I feel like I'm decent enough at mafia to control the votes just by my posts if I'm scum though, instead of taking a risk with a fake claim when I don't know if town has a role cop, alignment cop, or any other role that could out me.
Anyway, @Player 9 have you abandoned your suspicions of Player 6 or are they still there? Because now I get the impression that you're cooperating with that slot where previously you were on the same track as me in that you felt they weren't really saying a lot in spite of their needlessly high post count. Just asking because I don't recall seeing you back off, or were you never really suspicious in the first place? This could also he my brainless sleep deprived mind speaking.
My suspicions aren't as strong as d1, but they're not completely gone. The thing is, as town I typically cooperate with people I know think similar to me so that I can pick their brain a lot which gives me more information on them to analyze.
6 has given me some of their town vibes, but it hasn't been as strong. Which is hard to parse because I don't know if it's just because they don't have meta to work on or if it's something malicious. I know they gave an explanation for why they weren't on a wagon but it still feels unlike them. Also they seemed to be going in a direction today that I feel like scum would have went after d1, but again that could he due to lack of alignment flips. I want to see what they do now that I've provided more information about alignments, because now it is much harder for scum to control the narrative.
