PalaeoJoe
The Diplomatic Dinosaur
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2012
- Location
- Early Cretaceous North America
Amy Lu Minati and Deus I disagree that the would be able to pull of/should try, to make Zelda a modern or futuristic setting (even for just one day). I don't think they would be able do it in such a way that would fit the series. Don't get me wrong, I think steampunk should be explored more, especially in the adult time line after Spirit Tracks. And I like the use of some advanced technology, but it should not be something that has a huge impact on the type of world you explore. Zelda should (and I think always will) have a medieval fantasy setting. I know that with such a fantasy settings you can push the boundary of what you would see in a "medieval kingdom" (advanced tech peppered in where appropriate) but futuristic I don't think can work here as a whole. Steampunk I think could be integrated into such a setting as Hyrule to a large degree and still fit well. But futurism and especially modernism would not.
Now there is the argument that: Final Fantasy began as a medieval fantasy series and often still maintained it's core aesthetic feel. And that is mostly true, I think though that FF both evolved it's 'core aesthetic feel' to greater degree and began with an aesthetic that was more open to interpretation and (tech-)diversity. So such radical changes in the setting fit the spirit of FF. While I do think Zelda can also have radical changes in it's stetting and themes, but they should go about it in different ways then FF did.
I have some more specific ideas about these "radical changes" that can be done with tLoZ, but before I give any I will wait for a rebuttal from one or both of you.
Now there is the argument that: Final Fantasy began as a medieval fantasy series and often still maintained it's core aesthetic feel. And that is mostly true, I think though that FF both evolved it's 'core aesthetic feel' to greater degree and began with an aesthetic that was more open to interpretation and (tech-)diversity. So such radical changes in the setting fit the spirit of FF. While I do think Zelda can also have radical changes in it's stetting and themes, but they should go about it in different ways then FF did.
I have some more specific ideas about these "radical changes" that can be done with tLoZ, but before I give any I will wait for a rebuttal from one or both of you.