Search results for query: *

@Stormageden747: Is that all you have to say?

The Storma wagon and the reasoning behind it seem logical enough: the flavor argument looks sound, and the slip-up he just made seems incriminating, although the similarity of the names does provide the possibility of a simple mistake. Even if he does flip town, though, he's already used his...

I'm somewhat skeptical about trying to lynch Storma based on interpreting the flavor, but it's something I'll have to look into after this post. In the meantime: The difference is that Krow actively pushed for a funnier lynch, whereas Pendio merely kept his RVS vote on. Which would normally...

It makes sense that Storma would be blocked given his roleclaim, so it's not that hard to believe, even if I'm still suspicious of his initial refusal to answer. Could also be worth looking at the final vote tally from yesterday: musicfan - 7 (PancakeSamurai, Kirino, funnier6, Bok Chan Sama...

What risks? I can't possibly think of any. This, along with the fact that you weren't killed, makes me suspect that you're fakeclaiming.

I think the Mafia killed funnier: as an active and essentially confirmed townie, he was an obvious target for them. Presumably they used a strongman for fear of doctor protection, with him just happening to be bulletproof. As for LG, I think it's more likely that she was killed by an SK, as I...

I'd be fine with lynching either Musicfan or Pancake, really. I don't generally like lynching inactives if I can help it, but either would certainly be preferable to a funnier lynch. If I had to pick, I'd probably go with musicfan, mostly due to a gut feeling and since he's at least taken one...

We have to lynch someone by 8 PM today. Although I have a fair amount of town reads, I don't have any real scum reads. I'd be interested to hear if anyone else does. @Musicfan: are you still suspicious of funnier? @PancakeSamurai, @Libk: Any thoughts on the last 9 pages? I may have missed...

I've played multiple games with town JOATs, and most of the JOATs I've seen are town. I think it's likely that Storma is telling the truth; if he were scum, then there's the possibility of being countered, and the inability for him to use his abilities could get him exposed. The exception would...

I don't recall anything stated by anyone or done by you, in my three games with you, that would've made your reasoning at all obvious, and it's moronic of you to expect me to read an entire game I wasn't in as a prerequisite to ask you such a simple question.

If @funnier is powerhunting, then storma's the best person he could've asked, given that I can think of no one else who would reveal their role simply because they were requested to do so, with funnier probably knowing this. Now that you've asked and received his role, what was the point of...

I don't agree with funnier much either, but this seems like typical town play from him. It's still quite early, but I'd be against his lynch as things stand. Also, LG seems to be playing like typical LG, and that makes me think she's town as well. I honestly can't remember the last time we...

oh

@PancakeSamurai: Why suddenly roleclaim VT for no apparent reason, especially since, as far as I can tell, you've tended to be hostile to claiming?

@funnier6: In many games I've previously played, the problem is that RVS lasted too long and things took far too late to get serious, hampering town efforts on Day 1 and subsequently. So I think the starting of any serious discussion at such an early point is beneficial, and setup discussion...

@funnier6: If you were critical of my approach, then you should have actually stated that instead of the response you gave. In any case, I don't see how no discussion at all is superior to setup discussion, especially if the information discussed is relevant.

Instead of just random voting, I thought it would make more sense to start genuine discussion and contribute by providing speculation on the number of Mafia, since the changes leave it an open question and the information is relevant. If you don't find it valuable or have nothing to add, then...

The original set-up likely had 3 Mafia members, which may have been increased to 4 to accommodate the two additional players; the former would follow the 1/5 ratio in this case, and the latter (roughly) the 1/4 ratio. The latter seems slightly too high in favor of the Mafia, though, and one...