pkfroce
Skelepuns
She didn't draft me. My role was originally given as a Member of the Fellowship. This would be so much easier if we could name claim. But yeah. I wasn't converted. I am originally a Fellowship Member.
Lord of the Rings Mafia - The Treason of Isengard
- Thread starter Keeseman
- Start date
- Status
Pen
The game is on!
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2010
I would like to point out something that struck me as quite weird. Even though Thareous role claimed as the Doctor a few days back it does not seem like the Mafia has even attempted to kill him. We know there was a Bodyguard in this game (a protective role), but I am pretty sure there should be a classic Doctor as well. Considering nobody has counter claimed Thareous in all this time, to me it makes little sense not to trust him. But still, the fact that he is still alive worries me a wee bit.
Keeseman
Smash is Life
- Joined
- Sep 23, 2012
- Location
- Beijing, China
Day 7:
ALIT: 3 (musicfan, pkfroce, Pendio)
Not Voting: ALIT, The Marshal, Big Octo, HoT, Thar
Day ends on Wednesday, 8:00 PM EST. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to reach a majority.
Just a reminder, pkfroce has made a claim, so no one else may (a no-claim rule would have made this so much easier...). Also, I'm still counting the number of posts by the end of the day, so make sure you post at least 5 times; though some of you already have, I still want to make sure that I don't have to modkill any of you.
ALIT: 3 (musicfan, pkfroce, Pendio)
Not Voting: ALIT, The Marshal, Big Octo, HoT, Thar
Day ends on Wednesday, 8:00 PM EST. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to reach a majority.
Just a reminder, pkfroce has made a claim, so no one else may (a no-claim rule would have made this so much easier...). Also, I'm still counting the number of posts by the end of the day, so make sure you post at least 5 times; though some of you already have, I still want to make sure that I don't have to modkill any of you.
Last edited:
pkfroce
Skelepuns
That's been troubling me too. Not so much that I'm suspicious, but I'm just curious as to why he's still alive. Could he not be Town? If he wasn't it could even out the number of Town versus Mafia versus Wraiths.
Ya know... I've been wondering the same thing myself.
Interesting to see my own logic from yesterday being used against me. After seeing Rachel's claim yesterday and supporting the high probability of Keyshe being mafia due to the high number of deceased town power roles, it seems this same line of reasoning is being used against me since around half the living members have been confirmed town by Rachel or otherwise.
Although there are other potentially dubious people still floating around, attention seems to be floating around me even though I am one of the more active players remaining.
I believe it's unwise to narrow down focus so early in the day. How often do you see a mafia doublevoter when there is already a mafia roleblocker?
Yes, it's true that Draco and Keyshe had made several references regarding me not being scummy, but I never defended them. The relationship is one way. I had nothing to do with them and as I've already explained, it was a smart move for them in hindsight because people were already suspicious of me to begin with.
Although there are other potentially dubious people still floating around, attention seems to be floating around me even though I am one of the more active players remaining.
I believe it's unwise to narrow down focus so early in the day. How often do you see a mafia doublevoter when there is already a mafia roleblocker?
Yes, it's true that Draco and Keyshe had made several references regarding me not being scummy, but I never defended them. The relationship is one way. I had nothing to do with them and as I've already explained, it was a smart move for them in hindsight because people were already suspicious of me to begin with.
How many games have there been with a cult? How many with a town cult? The town cult puts the mafia at a disadvantage. Why not give them a boost with a DV?
Well, let's put it like this.
If you lynch me and I turn out town, who's your next suspect?
If you lynch me and I turn out town, who's your next suspect?
I would say my next suspect is the marshal or HoT then PK force. Although he claimed Rachel never said there was a preexisting existing member unless If im misinterpreting her post.
I have another example of Keyshe using inverse reasoning. #1364
She reiterates the confirmed town, conveniently forgets the existence of a town cult as Big Octo also notes, clumping Rachel and Pendio with the Wraiths.
But the most fascinating part is who she claims is town and who is mafia. We now have solid reason to believe pkfroce and Big Octo are town and we know Mido was mafia. If she died, Keyshe thought she could conceal Mido's identity by calling him out as potential mafia making it seem she framed a townie.
I agree with musicfan that The Marshal and Heroine are prime suspects right now.
One of them is likely mafia, the other the Dreaming God.
Vote: The Marshal
She reiterates the confirmed town, conveniently forgets the existence of a town cult as Big Octo also notes, clumping Rachel and Pendio with the Wraiths.
But the most fascinating part is who she claims is town and who is mafia. We now have solid reason to believe pkfroce and Big Octo are town and we know Mido was mafia. If she died, Keyshe thought she could conceal Mido's identity by calling him out as potential mafia making it seem she framed a townie.
I agree with musicfan that The Marshal and Heroine are prime suspects right now.
One of them is likely mafia, the other the Dreaming God.
Vote: The Marshal
Who do you think would be a better lynch target then?
For today, The Marshal. I'd like to see what he has to say today.
- Status