Alrighty, I'm home and can give a little more meat to my post this time. I'm going to go over the list and give my thoughts on everybody.
Moonstone - Me, town 100% likely, but of course I would say this.
Mido - leaning town. Someone pointed out it would be a weird move for scum to lynch the only person who voted with them. Plus he's been pretty active and helpful, even if he does turn his attention to me sometimes, I get it. Townies don't know who other townies are so of course they might be against each other sometimes. I'm feeling about 80% towards town.
Dekunut - again leaning town. He's also been very active and I've been feeling good about him all game. I guess I would put him at around 70% because there simply isn't very much evidence either way, but I do appreciate his participation.
Tristan - also fairly active. Slight town lead. About 60% to me, especially if he did have a chatroom with Storm due to his role. I doubt a mafia member would be allowed to choose another person to talk to as part of their role, but I could definitely be wrong. Still, I think it's more likely that he's town or at worst 3rd party if he did get to chat with Storm. If he had the ability to choose one person to talk to, I would not be surprised if he chose Storm considering they have a history.
karu - has recently gotten quite active especially now that she's talked to Pendio and gotten some pointers. Plus not knowing the 3rd party and bringing it up seems a little more townie to me. But she could be getting pointers from scum buds as well when they are active. I'm still leaning slightly town, probably about 55% likely town.
Libk - has been a little active but not much. 50%
Toxic Snowman - not very active, hasn't really posted anything of substance or made any strong moves. 45%
Ver-go-a-go-go - Similar to Johnny (below) but with less posts to analyze. I don't understand why he wouldn't vote towards his suspicions unless he knew that Doc was really town, but unless he starts making some town plays like I know he can do, I'm pretty suspicious of him. 40%
Johnny Sooshi - While I appreciate that he was trying to put some pressure on me, I have to wonder why he didn't vote for me if he thinks I'm so suspicious, especially so close to the end of the day. I found it quite suspicious and if the day hadn't ended before I could get a word in, I would've dared him to vote for me and see what he said. Of course, that's because I think he's likely mafia and if he is mafia he knows I'm either town or 3rd party, likely town due to my activity and scum hunting, and knows that my flip will draw suspicion. 30%
I want to see what everyone thinks of my list before placing my vote, but as it is I'm probably going to vote for Johnny.
I also want to add that the doctor probably knows who the mafia attacked last night so I think we'll start seeing more townies come together. I also want to add that while I do think the poisoner is probably mafia aligned or 3rd party, IIRC in Pokescum I was a town aligned poisoner so it can happen. I doubt that the poisoner this time town but it could happen and of course it was awhile ago and I can't really remember.
http://zeldadungeon.net/forum/threads/pokéscum-mafia-the-first-generation.49879/page-55
Tristan, you were the mod for that game, do you remember and would you mind reminding me whether I was town aligned or 3rd party poisoner? I know I wasn't mafia aligned.
Moonstone - Me, town 100% likely, but of course I would say this.
Mido - leaning town. Someone pointed out it would be a weird move for scum to lynch the only person who voted with them. Plus he's been pretty active and helpful, even if he does turn his attention to me sometimes, I get it. Townies don't know who other townies are so of course they might be against each other sometimes. I'm feeling about 80% towards town.
Dekunut - again leaning town. He's also been very active and I've been feeling good about him all game. I guess I would put him at around 70% because there simply isn't very much evidence either way, but I do appreciate his participation.
Tristan - also fairly active. Slight town lead. About 60% to me, especially if he did have a chatroom with Storm due to his role. I doubt a mafia member would be allowed to choose another person to talk to as part of their role, but I could definitely be wrong. Still, I think it's more likely that he's town or at worst 3rd party if he did get to chat with Storm. If he had the ability to choose one person to talk to, I would not be surprised if he chose Storm considering they have a history.
karu - has recently gotten quite active especially now that she's talked to Pendio and gotten some pointers. Plus not knowing the 3rd party and bringing it up seems a little more townie to me. But she could be getting pointers from scum buds as well when they are active. I'm still leaning slightly town, probably about 55% likely town.
Libk - has been a little active but not much. 50%
Toxic Snowman - not very active, hasn't really posted anything of substance or made any strong moves. 45%
Ver-go-a-go-go - Similar to Johnny (below) but with less posts to analyze. I don't understand why he wouldn't vote towards his suspicions unless he knew that Doc was really town, but unless he starts making some town plays like I know he can do, I'm pretty suspicious of him. 40%
Johnny Sooshi - While I appreciate that he was trying to put some pressure on me, I have to wonder why he didn't vote for me if he thinks I'm so suspicious, especially so close to the end of the day. I found it quite suspicious and if the day hadn't ended before I could get a word in, I would've dared him to vote for me and see what he said. Of course, that's because I think he's likely mafia and if he is mafia he knows I'm either town or 3rd party, likely town due to my activity and scum hunting, and knows that my flip will draw suspicion. 30%
I want to see what everyone thinks of my list before placing my vote, but as it is I'm probably going to vote for Johnny.
I also want to add that the doctor probably knows who the mafia attacked last night so I think we'll start seeing more townies come together. I also want to add that while I do think the poisoner is probably mafia aligned or 3rd party, IIRC in Pokescum I was a town aligned poisoner so it can happen. I doubt that the poisoner this time town but it could happen and of course it was awhile ago and I can't really remember.
http://zeldadungeon.net/forum/threads/pokéscum-mafia-the-first-generation.49879/page-55
Tristan, you were the mod for that game, do you remember and would you mind reminding me whether I was town aligned or 3rd party poisoner? I know I wasn't mafia aligned.